|
J. P. SANDERS was born in Nashville, Tennessee in 1917. His father was a Church of Christ minister and the family, on both sides, are members of that church. Mr. Sanders attended the Austin, Texas high school for the blind, graduating as valedictorian in 1936. He graduated summa cum laude from Abilene Christian College in 1940, with a major in English and Bible. He earned an M.A. at Vanderbilt in 1941, and a B.D. from Vanderbilt’s School of Religion in 1943, where he won the Founder’s Medal for scholarship. He studied at Yale in 1943-44. Mr. Sanders served Churches of Christ in Covington, Kentucky (1944-47) and Cincinnati, Ohio (1947-50). In the Ohio area he preached in most of the Churches of Christ in the Great Lakes region and served the Christian Leader as associate editor. From 1950 to 1954 he served the Kilburn Avenue Church in Rockford, Illinois, where he also organized and directed a camp for under-privileged children. In 1954, Mr. Sanders accepted a call to the First Christian Church in Anaconda, Montana, remaining until 1959. He went next to the First Christian Church in Missoula, Montana, and remained there until June, 1964. He moved to the Fruitridge Christian Church in Sacramento, California, in 1964. His strong concern for social justice keeps him involved in many service areas. He works now with the Sacramento Peace Center, is on the board of the city’s Society for the Blind, and labors with the Social Action Commission of the Sacramento Area Council of Churches. |
THE
FAILURES OF
FUNDAMENTALISM
By
J. P. Sanders
When faith dies, its remains are embalmed into a creed. After fire goes out, only ashes are left as a reminder of the warmth and glow. When the spirit flees, the letter stays.
This alternation is discernible in literature, art, politics, and religion in what we know as convention and revolt. When a creative and dynamic spirit appears, it finds the old forms and conventions inadequate for its use. It revolts against them in order to express itself in its own way. Its new forms are fluid, experimental, subservient to the spirit that struggles to express itself. In time, however, even this revolt is captured by the system-makers who proceed to turn the revolt into a new and rigid convention. After a while, a new rebel arises to break through this convention and form his own medium. New wine can never be contained by old wine skins but must be forever finding new ones. Each new skin in turn becomes old.
A
Shelley finds the literary conventions of his day brittle and
confining for his free spirit. He rebels and shocks contemporaries
with radical innovations. The critics who followed him, however,
accepted his new forms and made them into another orthodoxy. In
religion there is a built-in tension between convention and revolt.
It is not always described in these terms but is more often described
as conflict between letter and spirit, between law and grace, between
works and faith. To put it in personal terms, the alternation of
convention and revolt can be seen as the perpetual struggle between
priest and prophet.
Micah,
the revolutionary prophet, attacked the priests head-on when he asked
religion’s basic question: “With what shall I come before
the Lord?”
Micah
wanted to know if (as the priests were saying) he could come to the
Lord with burnt-offerings and calves a year old—that is,
would outward ceremonies and works of obedience bring him to God? If
he brought thousands of rams and ten thousands of rivers of oil—would
the multitude of the works bring him to God? This was a clear
taunting of the priests and their system of external works and
doctrinal orthodoxy. In contrast, Micah made the startling challenge:
“What
does the Lord require of you but to do justice, to love mercy, and to
walk humbly with your God?”
Space
does not permit me to explicate this tension as seen in the writings
of Hosea, Isaiah, Amos, Jeremiah, and some of the late psalmists. All
of them, in their own way, challenged the same orthodoxy and with the
same revolutionary insights.
Twice
Jesus quoted Hosea’s succinct attack on the priests: “I
desire mercy, and not sacrifice.” He used it to summarize his
own battles with the Pharisees. He told them to go and learn what
Hosea meant. His hearers were proud students of the Scriptures who
were surely familiar with this saying from their prophet. Jesus seems
to be saying that they had so conventionalized the rebel that they
could no longer comprehend what he was really saying. Thus the
priest, though well-versed in the letter of the law is unable to lay
hold of the spirit of the law which is its true meaning. It was their
misunderstanding of the prophets that let them decorate the tombs of
the prophets while they themselves were unprophetic and would have
killed the prophets if they had lived at the same time with them. The
Daughters of the American Revolution are perhaps the last ones to
comprehend that revolution because they themselves are so
unrevolutionary. The Pharisees had conventionalized the prophets’
revolt and made their heresy into an orthodoxy. What the prophets had
cried out in the power of the spirit, the Pharisees had formalized
into the letter. Faith had become a creed, the fire ashes. The
dynamite of the prophets could now be handled with safety.
It
was this battle for the prophetic faith which brought Jesus to his
death. Defenders of the priestly orthodoxy would not let him live. He
showed them that their own prophets, Elijah and Elisha, did not share
their racist views. His statement that “the sabbath was made
for man, not man for the sabbath,” was itself enough to mark
him as a dangerous radical who was distressingly “free”
in handling Scripture and its requirements.
Paul’s
conversion, in my understanding, was not so much the conversion from
one religion to another as it was the conversion from priestly to
prophetic faith. He said he was brought up in the “strictest
sect” of the Pharisees. He evidently was unhappy in it quite
early and was tempted to rebel, for he “kicked against the
goad.” He was wretched under that strict system, for he found
in it only condemnation. If Paul had been brought up in the prophetic
tradition instead of the priestly, his subsequent life would
doubtless have been much different. Needless to say, in that event
Christianity itself would be much different. What Paul found in Jesus
Christ was what Jesus himself had found in the prophetic stream of
Judaism. When he wrote that “the letter kills, but the Spirit
gives life,” he was probably speaking out of his own harrowing
experience of changing from the priest to the prophet.
Paul
soon found that even Christians, called to the prophetic faith, could
fall back to the priestly way without leaving their formal
relationship with the Christian church. Christians can make a
convention in their turn out of the Christian revolution. Paul found
it necessary to remind his Christian friends that “circumcision
is nothing, and uncircumcision is nothing, but faith working through
love.” This was precisely the same point Jesus had made about
the sabbath’s being for man, not man for the sabbath. Paul’s
battle with the Judaizing teachers in Galatia was the same as Jesus’
battle with the Pharisees, or the battle of the eighth century
prophets with the priests of their time.
FUNDAMENTALISM
AND THE PRIESTLY TRADITION
The
Protestant Reformation was the revolt of the prophetic spirit of the
sixteenth century against the conventionalized religion of the
priestly medieval church. Luther’s stress on faith within as
opposed to outward works, on individual conscience as opposed to
dogmatic orthodoxy, on the freedom of the man in Christ—all
this was but a re-phrasing of the old prophetic language. Again, it
was the struggle of the spirit against the letter.
In
our day, this prophetic Protestant revolt has been conventionalized
into a new orthodoxy and rigid creed. This modern priestly form of
Protestantism goes by the name of Fundamentalism.
As
we have seen, the words and phrases used in the battle change from
age to age, but the basic issues remain the same. Fundamentalism has
the four inevitable marks of the priestly tradition in all ages, and
in our time we have chosen to term these issues as follows:
Scriptural literalism, legalism, sectarianism, and social
irrelevance. I should like to discuss these marks in order and
demonstrate how they are the essentials of any Fundamentalist—or
of any other priestly system.
SCRIPTURAL
LITERALISM
The
priest, in seeking a system of faith which can be the unquestioned
basis for conformity within the sect, may find authority for the
system either through an infallible church or an infallible
Scriptural interpretation. If he chooses the latter, the
interpretation must be literal, since close attention to the spirit
of
the writing is individualistic and leads to heterodoxy. The jot and
the tittle become supremely important, for the system as a whole
depends upon them.
In
his conviction that he can discover through the letter what the early
church was and taught, the priestly type is persuaded that he can
“restore” that early church by duplicating it detail for
detail in our time. Restorationism is the effort to catch an
historical process at one moment of its evolution and to fossilize it
at that point for eternal duplication. Literal interpretation, at the
most, can hope to resurrect only the corpse from the past; the
experimental, fluid, and dynamic life is too elusive for such
capture. The early church was not itself a rigid structure; the
development of it, as seen through New Testament letters, shows this
clearly. To talk about “restoring” the early church
requires that we designate which
early
church—for example, the one of Corinthians, or the one of the
pastoral letters.
It
seems to me that literalism, with its consequent efforts at
restoration, fails to take into account the most elementary findings
of modern Biblical scholarship. The Scriptures were obviously not
written to be complete descriptions of anything, or blueprints. Paul,
for instance, wrote letters as they were needed and addressed himself
to the specific problems before him. He did not self-consciously
write Scripture. He did not try to portray in detail what the church
was; his readers already knew. We do not even have all the letters he
wrote, and what he said that has now been lost may be most vital to
any type of literal interpretation. Trying to piece together a
coherent picture of the early church from these miscellaneous
fragments is like following a truck loaded with a pre-fab, hoping
that we can rebuild the house from the few pieces that chance to drop
off.
There
have been so many glosses, additions, and editorial changes in the
process of time that we have no way of knowing exactly what the
original text was. From what we have, we get glimpses—little
more.
One
detail will suffice here. Acts 20:7 says that “on the first day
of the week, when we were gathered to break bread ...” From
this passing reference, some restorationists have tried to develop a
pattern as to frequency of celebrating the Lord’s Supper.
All
that this verse says, however, is that on that particular day of the
week that particular group in that place met to break bread—whether
it was the Lord’s Supper or a common meal is not even made
clear. We do not know whether this group always met on that day, or
if it did we do not know that other groups did; certainly we do not
know whether it was a common or universal practice. The fragmentary
nature of the Scriptural record makes any such conjecture vain.
Restoration,
it seems to me, is not only futile but also undesirable. Why should
the church of the twentieth century want to be like the one of the
first? That church became what it was in order to meet its needs and
exigencies; to attempt to follow its exact form today is to deny the
urgency we ought to feel for meeting the needs and exigencies of our
own day.
We
can read the New Testament and find the spirit of Christ at work. We
can see men “compelled by Love,” going forth to call men
to God through Christ, and into fellowship with each other. But to
assert that we have discovered the pattern of what that church was is
to assert more than we can prove and more than we need to assert. The
spirit of that early church can still give us life, but trying to
live by its letterwhich we cannot even discern fully—is lethal
indeed.
LEGALISM
We
have seen that the priest seeks an exact system of faith which can be
the basis for the sect, and he seeks it through the authority of the
church or the authority of literal Biblical interpretations. This
system is a code of requirements, or what is often called “the
plan of salvation.”
Legalism
sees sin as a violation of the written code. The code may or may not
have relevance to man’s need; it may be simply arbitrary
requirements revealed by God. Man’s disobedience to these rules
becomes an affront to God.
The
Pharisees loved the sabbath but saw little in it except its legal
value as a rule to be kept. Jesus called on them to see the real
meaning of the sabbath—it is made for man. These people were
scandalized when Jesus pointed out that one of their heroes, David,
had illegally eaten the sacred bread when he was a hungry fugitive.
Man’s need had precedence over legal requirements and taboos.
Paul,
under legalism, was wretched because he was honest enough with
himself to know that he could not fulfill any law which God would
give. The fault, he said, was not in the law but in his own fleshly
weakness. He went on to say that not only his
flesh,
but no
flesh,
could be justified by law. Under legalism he had to fulfill the law
to be justified, but he could not fulfill it, so that the law was to
him constant death and condemnation. In Christ he found freedom from
legalism through a new basis for salvation: his relationship to God
through inward faith. Now, as a son, he worked harder than he had as
a slave—not to fulfill legal requirements, but in response to
the love that had set him free.
The
dilemma which Paul posed remains legalism’s dilemma. How can
imperfect man be saved through the keeping of a perfect law? Some
solve this dilemma for themselves by reducing the law’s
requirements to a keepable minimum. Since man cannot measure up to
the law, then cut the law to his size.
Some,
for example, put great emphasis on baptism as “essential to
salvation.” They do not usually put the same emphasis on
forgiving enemies as “essential to salvation” —though
Jesus said more about this than about baptism. Some will make a test
of fellowship on church polity but will not make a test on the
weightier matters of justice, mercy, and faith. In short, legalism,
in its efforts to find justification by works of the law, eliminates
the more difficult requirements in order that it might establish a
law that can be kept.
Since
legalism holds sin to be a legal violation, it holds salvation to be
a legal payment. Man as a sinner must do certain things required of
him for forgiveness. This is like paying a grocery bill or any other
legal obligation—so much for so much. If the grocer agrees to
discount the bill and will settle for five cents on the dollar, still
this is a legal transaction and a means of achieving debt-free status
by meeting the required payments.
Prophetic
religion would insist that salvation is not through a “plan”
at all, but through a relationship; not through meeting requirements,
but through love. Good works are a response to God’s love, not
a means of earning it. When love is there, there is a seeking to know
God’s will for his family; this means an involvement with the
social problems of the day. Jeremiah blistered the priests in
besieged Jerusalem for offering the people a false hope through
legalism. The priests were saying that the city could not be captured
because it had God’s temple and because its people were
obedient at the altar with their ceremonies. Jeremiah said that the
truth was that “if you thoroughly amend your ways and doings,
if you thoroughly execute justice between a man and his neighbor, if
you oppress not the sojourner, the fatherless, and the widow, and
shed not innocent blood in this place neither walk after other gods
to your own hurt: then will I cause you to dwell in this place …”
The people, following their priests, were trusting in their
scrupulous obedience to outward forms of religious practice and were
ignoring the real will of God, which is for the relief and help of
his people. Jeremiah called on the people, as Micah did, to seek God
through social justice to his people, rather than through obedience
to meaningless legal requirements.
Legalism
begins with a God who is Judge, loving his law and wanting it kept;
prophetic faith begins with God who is Father, loving his children
and wanting justice and mercy for them.
SECTARIANISM
Priestly
religion seeks to establish a legal system or code for salvation
through literal interpretation of Scripture. The code so arrived at
must be accepted in detail by all who would be of the “in-group.”
Agreement on this legal code becomes the touchstone of belonging to
the group. Those who differ are of the “out-group.” The
in-group, by definition, becomes a sect, and its accepted
interpretation becomes its creed, whether written or unwritten.
Restoration
and its “plea” became such a creed for the sect which
separated itself from other Christians on this basis. This view of
the church is the same as that held by the medieval Catholic
Church—the only difference being that restorationism marks the
church by its “true doctrine” while Catholicism marked it
by the “true priesthood.” In both cases the church is
seen as a definite organization, exclusivist, infallible.
In
the early days of the restoration movement, it was held that
restoration of the early church pattern was the only means for
uniting Christians. Unity and restoration were part of the same plea.
It was thought that if the Biblical pattern could be presented,
right-thinking people would all agree on it and unity would follow.
However,
time and experience have convinced us that there is no one pattern
that is convincing to all right-thinking people. Historical criticism
has shown that with the process that produced the Scriptures it is
impossible for any coherent pattern to be found. Thus, far from being
a basis for unity today, patternism or restoration may become a sure
and certain barrier to unity and has, as a matter of fact, resulted
in more divisions. Any pattern we propose becomes divisive, marking
those who reject it as the “non church,” and those who
accept it as “the church,” that is, a sect.
A
group may advertise itself as being non-sectarian, when the very
claim is in itself sectarian. By this claim, it marks itself as being
different from other groups, unique in having some special truth that
keeps it from being a sect. A group may say that it has no creed,
while its very “creedlessness” is its test for exclusion,
or its creed. If an unimmersed Christian should seek to enter that
church, he might well find the sect’s creed on immersion
barring his way.
Paul
told the Romans that “the kingdom of God is not eating and
drinking, but righteousness, peace, and joy in the Holy Spirit.”
Evidently some of them were literalists and legalists, exalting petty
details into required doctrine which all must accept. Paul told them
to center on the real matters of the faith. He urged them to get rid
of the legalism and sectarianism that caused them to quarrel and
divide over the minutiae.
We
have not yet seen a sect built on justice, mercy, faith, peace, and
righteousness. Such great concerns produce something greater in
fellowship than a sect.
SOCIAL
IRRELEVANCE
The
sect, by the nature of its life, is introspective. It has mirrors
where windows ought to be. Its concern is for its own housekeeping
problems—how to maintain the orthodoxy of the sect, and how to
bring others to it. It must constantly define and redefine its terms
so as to guard against creeping heterodoxy. In this introspection, it
loses significant relationship to the world around it. The sect is
not only separated from other sects but is also cut off from the
mainstream of secular life. Being absorbed in its own institutional
purity, it becomes irrelevant to the social concerns of the world.
Since
the sect seeks to live by a document of two thousand years ago, which
it interprets with great literalness, its look is also primarily
retrospective. It lives in the backwater of life, talking of old
questions and ancient issues but unable to come to grips with the
contemporary urgencies. The early church was vital and dynamic,
turning its world upside down, because it was valiantly dealing with
the problems of its day. To try to live by a literal imitation of
that church and its solutions is to be called from the living present
to the dead past.
In
a world like ours, filled with revolutionary change and challenge,
the church must find through faith the insight and courage to
minister as the early church ministered—but not by the same
letter. A world with increasingly crushing problems of exploding
populations, urbanization, automation, racial tension, emerging
nations, armaments escalation, the constant threat of nuclear
disaster, mounting discontent of the world’s poor in the
presence of over-abundance—in all this the church must have
something more to offer than dry-as-dust irrelevances about the form
of baptism, frequency of the Supper, and church polity. While the
world is topsy-turvy in its search for new and meaningful value and
understanding, the church cannot sit it out, arguing about the
details of its own housekeeping chores. The church must be in the
world to minister to it, and to give its life as a ransom for many.
When
Paul was brought before Gallio for trial, his Jewish accusers babbled
and quibbled about hair-splitting differences of their literal
interpretations. Gallio, a pagan but a judge concerned for justice,
became disgusted and said: “If this were a matter of right or
wrong, I would deal with you. But since it is a question of words and
names in your own law, see to it yourselves. I am not minded to judge
in such matters.” He drove
them
from the judgment seat. Here is the sad spectacle of a pagan man
driving religious men away in indignation, not because they were too
challenging and demanding, but because they were too trivial, talking
nonsense to a man concerned about more vital things.
In
his parable of the good Samaritan, Jesus did not have to include a
priest, but he did. The priest was pious, orthodox, meticulous about
proper details of doctrine and practice in his temple functions, but
he passed by his neighbor’s need. His religion was of the
temple, not of the road or marketplace. The one Jesus approved in the
parable was the heretic, the despised Samaritan, who doubtless
worshipped at the wrong temple in Samaria and who followed corrupted
rituals at an illegitimate altar. Jesus’ contrast between the
priest and the Samaritan was not the contrast of race, for we do not
know the race of the man who needed their help. He was contrasting
priestly religion—the religion of the altar, the legalistic,
literalistic, sectarian religion of the Pharisees—with the
prophetic religion that is relevant to the bleeding of needy men.
When
Jesus talked of separating sheep from goats, he said not a word about
sound doctrine, the true sect, or any of the other priestly
conditions. On the contrary, he talked about social needs: feeding
the hungry, clothing the naked, ministering to the thirsty, the sick,
imprisoned, and strangers. Jesus held that separation comes at the
point of a man’s involvement with his brother’s need and
his willingness to sacrifice to release him from misery. He further
said that when we minister to men we minister to him. Micah had asked
how we shall come to the Lord. Jesus said that we come to him through
ministering to suffering. This is not far from Micah’s own
answer: “to do justice, to love kindness, and to walk humbly
with thy God.”
The
twenty-third chapter of Matthew contains parts of the bluntest and
most scathing prophetic denunciation of priestly religion to be found
anywhere in literature. There Jesus scored the Pharisees because they
would carefully “tithe mint, anise, and cummin, and leave
undone the weightier
matters
of the law: justice, and mercy, and faith.” The conflict
between priest and prophet is always here: which is more important,
tithing and the other housekeeping chores of the sect, or justice in
the marketplace, mercy towards the oppressed, and inward faith toward
God?
One-tenth
of our brethren in the United States are humiliated from morning
until night every day of their lives simply because they are darker
than most of us. Their cries for justice have gone unheeded, even by
the church which should have been most concerned for this brother
beside the road. The cry and demand has been taken into our streets.
Still the nation resists, and still the church hesitates to take an
unequivocal stand for their rights as men. Could anything be more
priestly than for us to continue to baptize, commune, tithe and the
rest, while our brethren and their children are daily humiliated?
Shall we continue to call the people to solemn assemblies, to
religious feasts, to prayers, and hymns, or shall we with Amos say
that all these externals are no delight to the Lord but that we must
let “justice roll down like waters, and righteousness as a
mighty stream”?
Let justice roll down like waters for the colored people of the United States and of South Africa and everywhere else. Let justice roll down for the two billions who are hungry from birth until death, while we, the minority, kill ourselves with fatness. Let justice roll down for the hungry who need bread instead of our bombs. Let justice roll down like waters, that His kingdom may come, that His will may be done on the earth even as it is in heaven.