|
NORMAN
L. PARKS is professor of political science and head of the department
of social science at Middle Tennessee State University. He was
educated at David Lipscomb College, Abilene Christian College (B.A.),
Peabody College (M.A.), and Vanderbilt University (Ph.D.).
Prior to
his present position, Mr. Parks taught for eleven years at Vanderbilt
and Peabody, and served for a time as senior editorial writer on the
Nashville Tennessean. He was dean of David Lipscomb College for eight
years, and also taught at Freed-Hardeman College and Oklahoma
Christian College.
Although
he has preached and taught often in Churches of Christ, Mr. Parks
considers himself anything but a professional pulpiteer. Of his
experiences in this field, he writes:
“I
have spoken in many churches and on occasion still do, but because of
a lack of the pulpit stance and orthodox sermon technique it has not
been hard to preserve my non-professional purity. At MTSU I conducted
for a number of years a ‘laboratory’ in fellowship by
sponsoring a student magazine called
The
Campus Christian. The
editor came from a premillennial church, the assistant editor from a
Disciples church, and the staff from other segments of the Church of
Christ. It was remarkable how well they worked and worshipped
together. Such experiences may sometimes tempt us to say, ‘If
there were only some way to protect the young from the old.’”
|
THY
ECCLESIA
COME!
By
Norman L. Parks
In
a world of national states the problem of citizenship may be truly
insoluble for a person like the late Mrs. Schwimmer of Supreme Court
fame who had “only a cosmic sense of belonging to mankind.”
In a religious world of sects and denominations there is perhaps
something of an inevitable alienation for those who have only a
cosmic sense of belonging to Christ.
This
appears to be particularly true within the confines of the
Campbell-Stone Reformation movement, where fragmentation has reached
a crisis stage. One may deeply desire to be a “disciple at
large,” but the degree of his acceptance by this or that
fragment will depend on his acquiescence in its prescribed parochial
loyalties.1
The theory of congregational independence will in no way protect a
congregation from proscription if it extends full fraternity to any
prominent disciple branded as unorthodox by that faction’s
ruling hierarchy.
Though
never claiming less than discipleship-at-large, this author has spent
his active religious life within the parochial confines of that now
badly fragmented wing of the American Reformation denominated “Church
of Christ.” Within this time he has seen its leadership abandon
the main goals of the Campbell-Stone movement—unity of all
Christians and the reforming of religion by purging it of hierarchy,
clergy, institutional machinery,
collegia
de propaganda de fide,
non-Biblical
terminology, and all post-Biblical dogma, ritual, and trappings which
are made measures of orthodoxy. Indeed, he has seen this group
develop the very accretions and perspectives which Campbell and Stone
attacked and so widen the gap between itself and “that ancient
sect first called Christians at Antioch.”
Viewed
sociologically, the Church of Christ is far advanced on the
sect-denomination continuum, though there is a spread among its major
segments. The Church of Christ (one-cup, one-book, one-assembly) is
closest to the sect pole. In its emphasis on lay leadership, lay
teaching, informal services, and its sense of hostility to the
“world,” this group is closest to the pioneer spirit of
the preceding century. It would probably have a strong appeal to the
underprivileged urban masses if its evangelism were directed at the
urban slums. The Church of Christ (premillennial) is also closer to
the sect pole, though developing colleges and a clergy. However, it
is distinguished by its marked pietism, its sense of the presence of
the Holy Spirit, and its consciousness of a broader fellowship. Both
the Church of Christ (institutional) and the Church of Christ
(anti-institutional) are near the denominational pole and may be
considered together.
The
Church of Christ colleges freely describe themselves as “church
related” in educational circles, and they follow clearly
identified denominational goals.2
The faculty of the oldest college must formally commit themselves to
follow the canons of faith prescribed by the board of directors.
These colleges talk in terms of campaign goals of $10,000,000 and
$25,000,000. They maintain seminary departments and some invent
degrees which match, alphabetically at least, those of Protestant
seminaries. One college bulletin with a prescience unmatched in
prophecy actually pinpointed the number of God’s redeemed at
slightly in excess of two millions! The church press boasts that the
Church of Christ is now the ninth largest in America and “the
fastest growing.” As a middle class denomination,
sociologically speaking, its clergy is well paid, gross income of
$8,000 to $15,000 not being uncommon. Far from being a sacrificial
vocation, its ministry offers some of limited education and ability
more than they could command in secular work. Some of the larger
churches round out their professional staffs with associate or
assistant “ministers” and “directors of
education.”3
The church long ago dropped its frontier-inspired hostility to
imposing church edifices (“decorated like a theatre to gratify
the pride of life,” as Campbell described them), and makes
efforts to put buildings in the “best” part of town.
Like
the larger denominations the Church of Christ has given preeminence
to the professional “pulpit.” Its occupant is the one man
known to all within and without the congregation. Advertising
features his face, his name, his sermon subjects. The service is
built around him, what precedes his front-center sermon being
preliminary and what follows being anticlimactic. In the author’s
home city laymen are less likely to fill the Church of Christ pulpit
than those of other Protestant churches. When the “regular”
minister is absent, nothing is more certain than that another pastor
will take his place.
To
at least as great an extent as most of the leading denominations, the
Church of Christ (institutional) has rejected the “Christ
against culture” concept of 1 John in the economic sphere and
has come to terms with the world. Capitalism is viewed as a part of
God’s law and the business order as the fruition of the divine
scheme. The successful businessman, provided he is not niggardly with
his money, is emerging as the layman hero of the church and the
logical candidate for deacon or elder. The board of elders itself is
patterned after the corporate board of directors. Nowhere has “the
Protestant ethic” enjoyed a higher endorsement. The social
radicalism of the nineteenth century pioneer and redneck has been
replaced by a deep-dyed economic and social conservatism which is
hostile to social reform, welfare programs, state intervention in the
economy, labor unions, racial integration, disturbers of the status
quo, and “those who have turned the world upside down”
(Acts 17:6).4
The
eagerness of the church colleges in seeking federal grants5
and loans reflects the shallowness of the commitment to the principle
of separation of church and state. The stream of right-wing political
propaganda from the executive offices of certain of these colleges
drapes the robe of religion with a contemporary form of Social
Darwinism and is an eloquent testimony to the fact that the Church of
Christ has made its peace with the world.
With
respect to government, its members seek high office, its
congressional representatives being conspicuously in the neanderthal
wing of politics. Abandoning its pacifism, the church gives status to
its ranking military. Socially, it has made adjustments in keeping
with its economic ethic. Dancing may still be occasionally identified
as “reveling” in sermons, but the minister, to prevent
the young people from attending the high school junior-senior “prom,”
may preside over a late-late skating party featuring hand-holding
partners performing to music.
The
Church of Christ appears then as a lower middle class phenomenon “on
the make” at its socio-economic level. In the author’s
own area it includes the congressman, the university president, the
county judge, the city mayor, the sheriff, bank executives, bar
leaders, medicos and dentists, and sundry business executives.
Approximately 20 per cent of the local university’s 5,000
students come from Church of Christ homes. In general, the church
does not compete at the upper middle class level, its economic
ceiling being second level “organization men,” smaller
business tycoons, and junior oil millionaires. Nor is it active at
the “unwashed throng” level, leaving the lower urban
classes and slum warrens to the Pentecostals and Jehovah’s
Witnesses. In summary, the Church of Christ’s behavior as a
sociological group reflects the expected pattern of religion
interacting with social factors (breakup of older communities,
urbanization, industrialization, impersonalization of society) as the
group moves along the continuum toward mature denominationalism. This
interaction centers around the drives and frustrations of men within
the social stratum in which the church largely functions and the
means of dealing with them. In a society in social and economic flux,
religion itself is in a constant process of change, and in this fact
lies part of the crisis which has engulfed the Church of Christ.
Though
the church meets most of the sociological criteria of a mature
denomination, it still remains at the sect stage doctrinally, as
reflected in the priority given to doctrinal affairs at the expense
of ethical principle. There is a powerful instrument of solidarity
and cohesion in the boast, “We have the truth,” when
aimed against other religious groups. Doctrinally it is on a
continuous military footing. Its militant state of mind allows little
room for love or accommodation and none for unity in diversity. Since
it is no longer at war with the secular economic world and
infrequently effects confrontation with its denominational rivals, it
tends to turn its sectarian hostilities inward and is presently
devouring its energies in internecine conflict.6
In
a second respect, the church remains at the sect stage in its claim
of “literal” adherence to Biblical command, example, and
“necessary inference.” In this area it has tended toward
bibliolatry. This adherence follows the sect pattern of careful
selectivity of Scriptures to support the party’s position. It
is interesting to see which examples are binding as examples, and
which are not. Examples which are
not
considered
examples make up a long list: foot washing, observing the Lord’s
Supper on Saturday night (assuming Acts 20 refers to the Lord’s
Supper), speaking with tongues in public or private, observing the
love feast, solos and group singing in assembly, anointing and
prayers for the sick by the elders, the teaching function carried on
in the main by the elders, deaconesses as well as deacons, religious
head-coverings (not fancy hats) and uncut hair for females, wearing
of jewelry, and congregational participation in decision-making on
the Antioch and Jerusalem model. Anyone insisting upon the Biblical
pattern in these matters would quickly be termed a troublemaker and
would sooner or later be excommunicated.
But
other criteria less clear or certain than some of the above are made
the standards for establishing the claim of the Church of Christ to
uniqueness: the Lord’s Supper every Sunday (and Sunday only),
mass singing only and without an instrument, the “right name,”
the “laying by in store” every Sunday, the “right”
baptism where validity is best ascertained by the “soundness”
of the baptizer, and the right “organization” of the
church under a plurality of elders and deacons.
In
its emphasis on the external observance of certain doctrinal
formalities and in taking for granted or ignoring the really
fundamental questions of religion, the Church of Christ is “majoring
in minors.” The emergence of “the lonely crowd”;
the impersonalization and institutionalization of business,
education, religion, and government; the involvement of man in
far-off places and crises beyond his personal reach, and the decline
of “community” have turned men to religion for answers.
But one may search literature and sermons of the Church of Christ in
vain for concern with such questions as: what is the meaning of life?
how does the individual cope with the sense of meaninglessness, with
frustration, with suffering? how can one really know God? how does
one learn to love, and how does one learn to teach others to love?
how do the just live by faith? how can a deeper understanding of the
grace of God be won? can the Christian live a life free from fear?
how is the Christian free from law, from sin, from death? how does
freedom accord with necessity? how can we better meet man’s
need for fellowship?
While
an ever increasing number of its younger generation find themselves
increasingly concerned with issues like those above, the Church of
Christ poses as the most fundamental question of all the “right
church” issue—a matter that is inherently institutional
and denominational. The criteria which it advances to identify the
“one true church” among the many claimants are those
which distinguish an organization rather than a people or a way of
life. Those who are involved with the deeper issues of life are
seeing these criteria as peripheral. 7
Let
us consider the criterion of “name” —that the true
church is the one with the right name. The very term “church”
is unBiblical, substituted for the Greek
ecclesia
(assembly)
by ancients who were involved in creating a power structure within
the Christian religion. The
ecclesia
of
Christ has no name. It is as absurd to emphasize the name of the
assembly of Christ as to emphasize the name of the sun. Paul’s
warning to Corinth shows that the “of Christ” cry can be
as denominational as the “of Luther.” With respect to the
hard legalism read into the criterion of baptism for the remission of
sins, reflection will suggest that baptism is an individual
expression of faith in Christ, while remission of sins is God’s
role, not man’s motive.
And
the legalist’s case for the Lord’s Supper every Sunday
and Sunday only is shadowy. It was first observed on a weekday
evening, and Christ’s omission of a prescribed time or
frequency for its observance suggests his concern for the spirit of
it. It is by no means certain that Acts 20:7 refers to the Lord’s
Supper, but if it does, the occasion was Saturday night. No day is
more of a “holy day” than any other day in the Christian
life, and the making of the first day of the week into a holy day has
no more Biblical basis than Christmas or Easter.
Completely
without authoritative substance is the “lay by in store”
command based on 1 Cor. 16:1 and making weekly church contribution a
required act of worship. The incident referred to was a means of
dealing with a particular problem in the early life of the church. A
congregation composed of artisans and wage earners operating on a
week by week economic schedule were instructed, “Every first
day of the week each of you is to put aside (at home) and keep by him
a sum in proportion to his gains so that there may be no collecting
when I come.” This had nothing to do with a church treasury and
it was not an “item of worship.” As a law applied to
Christians with monthly or seasonal income, it is absurd. Instances
of giving in the New Testament always related the giver and the gift
to a specific purpose—a fundamental characteristic of alms—and
never to an impersonal treasury for undefined ends or to a group
worship act on a holy day.
The
legalistic case for congregational singing without a musical
instrument is at best negative—silence of the New Testament on
the subject. Here again the emphasis is qualitative, as in other
aspects of worship. It is remarkable that the legalists stop short of
their own logic in refusing to accept solos (“if a man hath a
song”) or group singing (“speaking one to another”).
The
criterion of “the divinely patterned” organization stated
in absolutes leaves too much unanswered. It assumes that the church,
instead of having organization as a means,
is
an
organization completely subject to the authoritative rule of elders
and deacons (junior executives) responsible only to God. If every
church is scripturally required to have a select few to “rule”
it, why is the Bible not clear in explaining how these men became
authorities? Why is the suggestion that they be elected by the
congregation for a term of one or two years greeted with horror? What
is the scriptural basis for a self-perpetuating board of elders and
deacons? If the modern church must have deacons, but not deaconesses,
why does the New Testament fail to mention a single function they
discharge (the explanation that they are “servants” is
not valid, since all Christians are also servants)? If elders are
pastors, why do they not do the job instead of hiring a professional
shepherd? Why is not the popular election of “the seven”
by the Jerusalem church regarded as a working example for the church
to effect organization? Why does the Church of Christ utilize a
prejudiced translation, designed to support the episcopal system, to
establish the right of elders to “rule”? How much of a
“divine pattern” exists in a plurality of elders but a
single “minister”?
Alexander
Campbell described the church in its activities as “radically
and essentially” democratic; a fraternity of equals, such as
Paul pictures in 2 Cor. 8:14, can be nothing else. Removal of
authority and responsibility from the members and their concentration
in the hands of an elite is as dangerous to the welfare of a church
as it is to a state. People alienated from decision-making lose
initiative, creativity, and obligation. The pews become passive, the
services ritualistic, religion professionalized, and influence weak.
When elders spend $10,000 of church money on a single enterprise
without advice or consent of the members, hire a preacher without so
much as a “by your leave,” and assert the power of
ultimate decision as to what members may believe, what they may read,
whom they may hear, and who may lead the prayers or voice a
sentiment, the result is a dictatorship in defiance of the whole
nature of the Christian society. However “good”
individual elders may be personally, the whole system is wrong.
This
analysis has proceeded far enough to indicate that the Church of
Christ has chosen to rest its identity on some doubtful, peripheral,
or erroneous criteria while neglecting weightier matters. It has
nothing fundamental to lose in holding that though the frequency and
time of the Lord’s Supper is moot, its observance each Sunday
is an appropriate response of those who wish to remember Christ.
There is no loss in conceding that while there is no “law”
on the church treasury, weekly collections represent a practical way
for members to consolidate their giving for specific purposes,
provided this practice does not substitute for private alms giving.
There would be no loss in granting that there is no merit
per
se
in
singing with or without an instrument, but there is no limit to the
power, richness, depth, and spirituality of
a
capella
singing when developed by hard practice, mastery of music, and
individual specialization. There would be no loss in agreeing that
while there is always a place for leadership (in contrast to
“ruling”), the power of any group is magnified by full
participation in decision-making. There would be no loss-except the
loss of the cocoon of legalism which has been spun around the entire
church.
The
redefinition of its identity in non-legalistic concepts will be
necessary before the Church of Christ can communicate in the larger
assembly of God. The steady attrition that accompanies the increasing
education of its members cannot be stopped until the disgracefully
mediocre scholarship and shallow legalism of its present pulpit,
press, and seminary leadership is modified by a deeper spirituality,
a greater magnanimity, and sounder learning. Actually such a process
is under way. Beneath the surface there is a vast unrest, indeed, in
the very citadels of orthodoxy—the colleges—as well as
elsewhere, demanding a religion of grace and a gospel of good news to
replace the hardshell legalism of the core church. In 1965 a college
located in the heartland of “orthodoxy” lost a half dozen
of its abler young men for this reason, and it will lose others,
either by resignation or purge.
It
is ironic that though the American Reformation was a revolt against
Calvinism, the Church of Christ is today one of the most Calvinistic
bodies in the Protestant arc. In spirit it has gone all the way back
to Geneva to produce a modern version of
The
Institutes of the Christian Religion.
Its
code is constantly revised to include new laws on the millennium,
biology, institutionalization, fellowship, capitalism, Biblical
scholarship, or whatever is the issue of the moment. Legalism and
authoritarianism reduce Christianity to a system of law and a
salvation by merit, authoritatively proclaimed and enforced. Such a
religion presents the God-man relationship in dichotomies of
creator-creature, wrath-fear, command-submission, and
authority-conformity instead of I-thou, friend-friend,
redeemer-redeemed, father-son. Its authoritarian God is jealous of
his rights and angered when denied propitiation by money, time,
service, and ritualistic observance. His will is stated in laws, and
to break one of them is to suffer guilt for all. He forgives, but
only when directly asked, and watchfully totals all of man’s
debits and credits.
Such
a view of religion produces two extremes. One is the self-righteous,
judgmental, and aggressive person who lives up to the “law.”
The other is the insecure, neurotic, fear-ridden, and guilt-laden
individual who, try as he may, is overwhelmed by the possibility that
he has not been right enough or done enough to win salvation. For
both types the lesson of Romans remains unrevealed. Between the
extremes are others, who, for sanity of mind and to escape the plight
into which legalism thrusts its victims, find an answer in reducing
the laws to formalities within their reach. Others manage in spite of
the law approach to find meaning in a religion of grace and faith.
These are the people who see the Christian assembly as a community of
seekers, who desire to promote fraternity, dialogue, and love, and
who would welcome the exploration of the “freedom that is in
Christ Jesus.” Needless to say, they are preservers of its
candlestick.
Efforts
to enforce conformity reflect the degree of authoritarianism in the
Church of Christ. The free man questions, tries, tests. He
acknowledges no authority to which he does not freely consent as
internalized truth. He is subject to no control above his own
conscience. He does not obey because it is commanded, but because it
is the way of truth and wisdom. The free life is also the faith
life—faith in the determinable elements of life as well as in
its spontaneity, freshness, and potential. The free man defines
authority as the
right
to acceptance
which
is inherent in truth, fact, reality. He is not free to believe or
practice anything else, because it would be injurious or
self-defeating. To him the only conformity that is healthful is the
conforming of thought, feeling, and action to truth—to the true
reality outside of self. Authoritarianism, in contrast, emphasizes
externalized power, superordination and subordination, superiority
and inferiority, rule and submission. It finds lodgment in
father-dominated families, class-structured societies,
anti-democratic governments, and legalistic religions. It has
psychological roots in individual personality: overly-felt need for
security, which may be temporarily satisfied by either submission or
domination; fear of self-direction and preference for obedience to
outside authority; tendency to conform compulsively to the orthodox;
preference for “order” and discipline over freedom and
spontaneity in human relations; satisfaction derived from identifying
with a superior “authority”; emotional rigidity and
limited imagination; excessive concern with group acceptance;
abnormal loyalty to the in-group; insecurity in the presence of
out-groups; attraction to the cult of personality—the WHO
rather than the WHAT or the WHY; the tendency to look on “those
in authority” with reverence and loyalty; acceptance of an
inferior status for women.
The
authoritarian view of the social order is revealed in an essay by a
Christian college president on the segregation issue:
True
enough, slavery is unlawful in the United States. The fine principle
involved in the master-slave relationship, however, obtains today in
both social and civic relationships of a like nature as it did in
Paul’s day. The fine principle involved in the master-servant
relationship, [sic] obtains in such as the employer-employee
relationship, the literate-illiterate social relationship, and the
privileged-underprivileged social relationship. The system of
jurisprudence often refers to the master-servant doctrine …. 8
Certain
evils inevitably flow from an authoritarian religion: (1) a passive,
submissive membership lacking in imagination and creativity; (2)
aggressive, power-hungry leaders who sublimate their own insecurity
by speaking as oracles and demanding acceptance; (3) loss of freedom
of inquiry and freedom of speech; (4) little identification with God
as love; (5) centralization of decision-making in a handful of
“authorities”; (6) growth of coldness, formalism, and
ritualism; (7) the use of scholarship to preserve the status quo,
thus stopping progress; (8) conflict between rival “authorities,”
producing factions and splits; (9) increased pressure for conformity
in opinion; (10) growth of suppressed anxiety and guilt in the
membership; (11) rejection of the idea that a congregation is a
democracy or brotherhood of equals; (12) tendency of the leaders to
hold the ability of the general membership in low esteem, making it
necessary for the authorities to decide for them so as to avoid
“mistakes” ; (13) concentration of control of the church
property and funds in the hands of a few; (14) an “etatist”
rather than an instrumentalist view of the church, holding the church
to be an organism superior to and, in a sense, separate from the
individual and for the good of which the individual can be
sacrificed; (15) interpersonal relations definable in terms of
“brother’s keeper” rather than “brother’s
brother”; (16) insistence that “the” faith is a
finished system completely known to the authorities, beyond
re-examination, and capable of being authoritatively defined and
enforced.
A
power structure is an inevitable part of a legalistic religion. Not
since Puritan days has as much power gravitated into the hands of the
ministers as in the contemporary Church of Christ. This post-Biblical
officer has gathered in his own hands the teaching function which
originally belonged to the elders. In the typical church he is at the
center of the decision-making process. Excommunication bulls are
prepared by him. Supervisory functions fall to him. The church
bulletin is his voice. He speaks
ex
cathedra
for the church. He influences the choice of personnel for the
“Crusade for Christ” and the “Youth for Christ”
revivals. He attends the annual council at the nearest church college
to help firm up the party line and make contacts for future
engagements, and in this capacity serves as the main link between the
brotherhood power structure and the congregational power structure.
The
latter is made up of the self-perpetuating board of elders and
deacons who “rule,” control the treasury ($50,000 a year
spells considerable power), grant recognition to complaisant members,
and “silence” the “dangerous” ones. The
elimination of the mass of members from any significant role in what
the congregation is to do or how its money is to be spent is
unquestionably a major landmark in the development of the Church of
Christ into an authoritarian denomination. The total elimination of
women from the business meeting reflects the conviction that they,
like children, are “subordinate.” A highly educated woman
member, with a personal income in excess of most men in the
congregation, may make banking and commercial decisions of major
importance during the week, meeting men on the basis of equality, but
be deemed entirely unfit to pass on the business of the church.
However, with the growth of the power system, the mass of male
members has, in effect, fallen into the same state of inferiority.
Viewed
either sociologically or scripturally, the Church of Christ is not
the church of Christ. Its members, in a sense, are neither
“Christians only” nor “the only Christians.”
Its fragmentation cancels out the first proposition.9
The arrogance of the second displays an attitude wholly contrary to
the genius of Christianity. The author believes that there are great
numbers of noble, dedicated Christians in the Church of Christ. He
has no desire to be alienated from them. As children of God they are
in his family and should share with all the others his fellowship.
Any difference in opinion or understanding of religious truth should
never be a barrier. But indifference alone could lead the author to
ignore or gloss over the denominationalism, authoritarianism,
corroding legalism, or depressing institutionalization of power in
the Church of Christ.
There
is the plaint that one must not criticize the church lest its “image”
be hurt before the world. The acid language of
Galatians
should
be answer enough to this rationalization. It is not the image of the
church but its essence that counts. If the Church of Christ is not
capable of self-examination, there is no hope for it. If it cannot
accept unity in diversity, there is no place for it. If it cannot
deal with differences and new concepts by dialogue, there is no
progress in it. If it cannot preach “good news” instead
of legalistic “bad news,” there is no need for it. If it
cannot replace law with love, there is no redemption in it. If it
cannot promote the Christian ethics which will reconcile rather than
alienate people, there is no vitality in it.
A
fellowship of reconciliation is still its possible future. The author
has never encouraged any frustrated Christian to abandon the group
for a wider fellowship. He does not believe one must be surrendered
for the other. Nor can he think of a more urgent service than to work
for the reign of God to come more fully to the Church of Christ. The
difficulties and ostracism for those who stand for fellowship and
reconciliation that will bridge differences and allow for each man
his own exploration in the realm of faith may well increase before
the tide recedes. For those who can hold fast, this may be a kind of
saving suffering which Kierkegaard saw as a part of the process of
“becoming” a Christian.
The
goal is well worth the perseverance: an
ecclesia
which
embraces the imperatives of truth while rejecting the law-obeying
concept; which is a society of love and trust, not of command and
obedience, for this is the will of God; which avoids judgment and
promotes free interpersonal relationships; which can hold fellowship
with imperfect men without “endorsing” their
imperfections; which views religion as a way of life, with no
distinction between the secular and the religious; which holds the
church to be people living in confraternity rather than an
institution; which accepts the necessity that a Christian society
must have organized effort, but views organization merely as a means;
which rejects the domination-subordination dichotomy in favor of an
order of equality in which the only primacy is that which flows from
a superior example and a richer experience. With such a consummation
in mind we can still pray, “Thy ecclesia come!”
1 Preachers are keenly aware of the tests which they must pass, for example, before they can appear on the Church Council (“lectureship”) programs sponsored by Church of Christ colleges. Trafficking in reputations is an Important business of the lectureship managers, The vigilance of these guardians of orthodoxy ranges far and wide, as the author was recently reminded. A young instructor at David Lipscomb College told him In 1965, “I became deeply prejudiced against you as a freshman because Dr. _______ held you up in class as an example of dangerous liberalism.” It had been 23 years since this writer had taught at that college.
2. The reader is invited to examine the brilliant analysis of the miscarriage of Christian education by Robert Meyers, “Church of Christ Colleges: Is Anything Wrong?” Restoration Review, Fall, 1960, and the reflections of Alexander Campbell on colleges to propagate religion in The Christian Baptist.
3. The development of a professional pastoral office has been carried out under the term “minister.” An English transliteration from the Latin Vulgate translation of the Greek original, the term actually meant “slave” and was used to describe the relationship between man and God of those who were “bought with a price.” In no instance did it indicate office or the relationship of a preacher to a church. The absurdity of “assistant slave” needs no comment.
4. See unpublished manuscript by Rex Turner, president of Alabama Christian College, entitled, “The Attitude of a Christian in the Midst of a Race Crisis.” The Christian, says Mr. Turner, must never cause “excitement” or support change in a society. “The present trend on the part of a segment of gospel preachers and leaders to crusade for the cause of desegregation is contrary to the true spirit of Christianity.” However, there is little doubt that the Christian colleges will open their doors to Negroes in order to receive federal grants and loans. Such is the power of mammon when Christianity itself is unable to effect the result.
5. One such college, which mimeographed its own biology textbook in order to eliminate the word evolution from the science vocabulary, has received a federal grant in excess of $400,000 to erect a science building. Another college, known widely for its private enterprise emphasis and its constant criticism of “Socialistic” spending, has received a federal grant for over $340,000.
6. A phenomenon of more than passing significance is the attraction which Its pulpit has for the charismatic leader with authoritarian and aggressive characteristics. Aggression which would not be tolerated in other situations may find complete sanction in the pulpit. These psychological types vent their hostilities and find verbal outlet for deep-seated aggressions in “skin-em-alive” attacks on persons and groups. They are often adept at exploiting the neurotic guilt and fears of their hearers who have accepted a System of meritorious salvation, bringing them temporary relief and attaching them to their personal following.
7. One young college student remarked to the author recently that “you go to church and you hear the same old things, just doctrinal rocks being rolled around, and what is said is not really relevant to your needs and concerns, and then finally you stop going and you don’t feel very guilty about it:”
8. The confusion of the values of a dominant Southern social class with the principles of Christianity in this statement by Rex Turner reflects the middle class ideology of the Church of Christ, Communism is frequently attacked from the pulpit, but democracy is bluntly rejected, particularly in the religious society. The author has heard the right to work emphasized, but never the right of workers to bargain collectively for the price of their labor. He has heard socialism attacked. but never private monopoly, He has heard capitalism praised, but never a word about the tension between the profit motive as self-aggrandizement and Christ’s “deny yourself.”
9. No clearer example of this can be offered than a recent incident in Murfreesboro. When a group given to the “anti-institutional” persuasion proposed to start a congregation on one side of the university campus. the “minister” of the “institutional” Church of Christ located on the adjoining side of the campus urged the zoning board to block the proposal. His argument was that “We do not fellowship this group.”