|
THOMAS P. HARDEMAN ministered to Churches of Christ for
seventeen years and taught in Church of Christ Bible colleges for six
years before leaving to serve the Unitarian-Universalist Church as
lecturer and teacher for three years. He is at present deeply
involved in the varied social welfare programs of his home state,
Florida.
Specializing
in Biblical studies at David Lipscomb College (Nashville) and
Freed-Hardeman College (Henderson, Tennessee), Mr. Hardeman completed
his B.S. at Murray State in Kentucky (1947). He went on to the
University of Illinois, where he earned his M.A. in 1949 and his
Ph.D. in 1956, both in philosophy. He has taught philosophy and
religion courses at Florida Christian College (1949-52 and 1955-58),
at the University of Illinois (1953-54), and at the University of
Tampa (1955-61) .
Concentrating
on social services in recent years, he has been Project Director for
the Community Service Foundation in Florida (1962-64) and is
presently its vice president. He is a member of many philosophical
and social welfare organizations and has served as an officer in
most. He has conducted many radio and television programs based on
his twin interests and continues to be busy as speaker and writer. He
was consultant to the OEO Task Force for the Community Action Program
in Florida in 1964.
Born in Graves County, Kentucky in 1925, Mr. Hardeman is married and the father of four children. |
WHY?
By
Thomas P. Hardeman
|
For what the birth of the masses? Or why the lives of the few? To what run the paths of the greatest?
Whither
it leads, what they do?
For what the breath that is given? Or whence the power to fly? For what all the glories of heaven?
Is
every answer a lie?
Man born to die is a question, Ever and always to seek Not the mysteries of God high above him, But the mission of man who is weak. Is it pain? Is it joy? It is neither — Not regret nor false bliss can repay, But the good that man does to another
Is
the end of his life every day.
|
|
(Pat Hardeman, 1946) |
After
two years each at David Lipscomb and Freed-Hardeman, what an
experience it was to confront Emerson and the professor who taught
him to me. Properly schooled to combat evil, I helped secure the
professor’s censure for calling “sacred truths”
into question. It was poetic justice that my own similar questioning
led me fifteen years later through the same fires he suffered.
The
professor was more easily disposed of than was Emerson, who lingered
inside, caused much disquietude, and eventually outweighed earlier
influences. The poem above, so indebted to Emerson, was born in
Murray, Kentucky after many days and nights of youthful, enthusiastic
questioning of my place in the scheme of things. It also represented
the first serious grappling with two basic thrusts in my life—“the
mysteries of God high above him,” and “the mission of man
who is weak.”
I
remember so well the immediate reaction of parents and friends to
these lines. “Why do you say it is not
man’s
mission to seek the mysteries of God?” they inquired. So deeply
was it ingrained in me to be “sound” that I said
something like, “Well, there are many mysteries not revealed to
man in the Bible. We must deal with what is revealed.” But I
had not meant that when I wrote the poem. Humanism, flowing from
sources deep within me (in streams dammed up subsequently by many
years of obsession with conceptualizing and rationalizing those very
“mysteries” rejected in the poem), wrote the lines.
My
graduation address at Lipscomb High School had been entitled, “The
Value of Service.” Although it received the compliments of the
brethren at Lipscomb, it is basically a humanistic document, heavy in
its emphasis on man’s duty to his fellow man. Subsequently,
this concern for service to others sometimes led my preaching to
dwell on those practical evidences of religion which Jesus loved to
stress. I shall never forget the poignancy of the occasion when one
minister disposed of such a sermon by snorting, “Why, Brother X
(a church cooperation partisan) could have said every word you did.”
He dismissed all that Jesus said! Why? Because Brother X could have
said the same!
Eventually,
however, I became the protagonist and apologist. Because debaters are
so highly regarded in the Church of Christ, a fluent young man can
easily have his head turned by praise of his cleverness in debate.
Pride in the skill of forensic effort quickly dominates any effort to
weigh fairly one’s own position. However, the remorseless
requirements of logic itself forced me to reconsider each of “our”
major tenets. I was undone by the honesty of the very methods I used.
I knew that propositions seeking to capture the essence of the
conceptual system inherent in the verbal inspiration view of the
Bible simply had to be consistent. The truism that if two
propositions contradict, one must be false, led to my reassessment of
many widely accepted views. For example, if we are truly “silent
where the Bible is silent,” what justification could there be
for adding to the simple description of disciples meeting on the
first day of the week to break bread the dictum that Christians must
do it every Sunday, but never
on
any other day?
Debating
was my undoing, or, rather, the undoing of my earlier creed. Men like
Frank Pack and E. H. Ijams early kindled an interest in philosophy,
leading eventually to my graduate major in that subject. I wrote to a
friend that I was planning to major in philosophy “in order to
contrast man’s views on right and wrong with God’s truth
on the subject.” This helps explain why my years of graduate
study in philosophy, filled as they were with preaching and debating,
never really allowed the great thinkers of the ages to combat my
creed directly. I studied them to use them in combat. This continued
until one momentous night when my favorite professor and I clashed in
a friendly but deeply probing debate on the foundation of the
Christian faith, the bodily resurrection of Jesus. Literate and
skilled, this professor led me into an examination of the very
concept of evidence for “supernatural” events. My
brethren wrote high praise of my efforts, but Sara and I questioned
the basic presuppositions of my arguments.
Having
no definitive criteria for determining the supernaturalness of
historical events, how could I be so sure that a given event was
supernatural? I wondered, and I wonder, despite the arguments of A.
E. Taylor, C. S. Lewis, et
alia.
My
creed was shaking on its foundations. Perhaps with a different field
of graduate study for the previous years I would have backed away
from such painful reappraisals and silenced my doubts. This may be
sufficient cause for the warnings frequently uttered against “our”
preachers becoming immersed in philosophy. Still, the training from
childhood, the host of friends and relatives, the many tasks I had
planned, the books I had written and would write—all these
conspired to delay my departure and extend painfully my inner
struggle. One does not cast off the commitment of faith and family as
lightly as he sheds a coat for an hour. I shall list below some of
the issues (minor by contrast with the major struggle just mentioned)
involved in the dissolution of my “Church of Christ Faith.”
My
early and adult manhood can be divided into several periods with
labels easily obtainable from those who went through similar
experiences. The Lipscomb years, for example, were concerned with
piety and evangelism. The Freed-Hardeman years concentrated on a
doctrinal soundness based on selected “pioneers,” on
McGarvey, and on moral correctness consisting mainly of conformity
with “brotherhood” rules of conduct. The
post-Freed-Hardeman years at Murray State introduced me to part of
the real world, in contrast to the monastic kind of life in the
Freed-Hardeman complex (a type of life so unreal in its abhorrence of
the outside world of “infidels” that the head of the
school could jestingly call them “in-for-hells,” and
refer to sectarians as “insects”).
At
Murray State there were pagans, preachers, priests, and all sorts of
people whom I set out to save by vanquishing them in argument. This
interest diminished in direct proportion to my immersion in the
delightful studies of political science, literature, and philosophy.
Here I met Emerson, Plato, Aristotle, and a line of intriguing
authors from St. Augustine to the more recent empiricists and
rationalists. Here was Kant with whom I really did not struggle till
postgraduate years. Here was Mellon, the English professor, with whom
I did struggle immediately. (Straight from Freed-Hardeman and filled
with authoritarian attitudes, I secured his demotion on grounds that
his liberal views had a bad influence on students; it eases my
conscience slightly to know that seeds he planted bore fruit later in
my life and vindicated him completely in my own memories).
Most
importantly, at Murray State, I met Sara, that beautiful Irish
Catholic girl whose religious upbringing was so abhorrent,
challenging, frustrating and, ultimately, deserving of warmest
admiration, that I loved her at once, ridiculously rebaptized her,
joyfully married her, and have been blessed by her and our four
children beyond description. Together we have loved, fought, and
struggled for life’s meaning and purpose. Sara must have loved
me far more than I knew.
Ironically,
the reputation I gained as defender of the faith by attacking my
English professor won me an invitation to a church near the
University of Illinois, where I could preach while doing graduate
work in philosophy. Those first years, during which I earned my
Master’s Degree, were my most partisan and argumentative years.
The church wanted to reach the University with its message and our
method was across-the-board attacks on everything from Disciples to
Darwinism. The philosophy I was being taught was neatly
compartmentalized, often utilized for my sectarian purposes, but was
not contemplated. I had yet to learn that philosophy yields up its
secrets only to men with time and will to contemplate.
Next
came the call to Florida Christian College. Before my decision was
final there was bitter infighting among friends and relatives as to
whether I should join the family forces at Freed-Hardeman (my father
hoped I would not), or go with the new administration to Florida. For
the next three years I talked so much, either in preaching, debating,
or overload teaching tasks, that I had little time for more than
routine studies. Still, through all this, I found time to edit a
paper and write articles, mostly in apologetics, and to do an
exhaustive study of Freemasonry to determine with complete authority
that “a Christian” simply could not be a Mason. How
“sound” we were! During this time the college, with minor
exceptions, moved to the right to join the Gospel
Guardian forces
in anti-church-cooperation (meaning no-contribution-from church-treasury-to-causes-lacking-specific-apostolic-example).
The Florida Christian College years (1949-52) came to an end after a beautiful midsummer night when Sara joined me for a weekend in Atlanta after two months’ separation because of my evangelistic work. We talked things over carefully and decided to go back to the University of Illinois where I could complete a doctoral program in philosophy. The same church I had served earlier now had a new building near the campus and wanted me to return.
What
exciting years followed! The study of philosophy and ancient history,
learning to read several new languages, working in the new medium of
television, more writing, establishing and teaching in the MeGarvey
Chair of Philosophy of Religion, debating and endless preaching.
During this time Sara managed to sing, to play in the symphony, to
pursue her college degree, to have a baby, and to help me immensely
in everything I did.
But
unanswered questions persisted.
I
shall never forget the shock of having challenged my philosophy
professor to name a better account of creation than the first chapter
of Genesis,
only
to have him reply: “The first chapter of Genesis
with
the first and fourth days reversed.” All of Milligan’s Scheme
of Redemption, with
its sober description of a “luminiferous ether” activated
on the fourth day, plus all of Rimmer’s instances of light
independent of the sun, seemed weak by comparison—and still do.
I
returned to Florida Christian College in 1955, but this time with a
difference. My contract was with two schools, FCC and the University
of Tampa. The contract was symbolic of the widening schism in my own
interests; it foreshadowed the break that had finally to come.
Teaching philosophy at the University of Tampa half the week,
teaching philosophy and apologetics at FCC the other half, and
preaching in Jacksonville on weekends to a church whose leadership
was just breaking away from FCC, was quite a life. The church in
Jacksonville was “soft,” Tampa University was “worldly,”
and to cap it all, my Ph.D. in philosophy had made me suspect at FCC.
By
the year 1957, I loved the world. Whether loving the world in the
“Demas” sense, Or in the spirit of John 3:16 (as I
believed), my involvement with the world outside the “Church of
Christ” was so complete that I moved in the fall, by mutual
agreement with FCC, to exclusive teaching at Tampa University. A
simply incredible church quarreled to the formation of a new
congregation of which I became minister. This church met first in my
home because the split with the other church occurred just after my
being put to bed for six weeks with what was believed to be a heart
attack. When I was able to preach again, another building was ready.
But I was not the same. Those weeks in bed, which I had intended to
spend in reading, were spent instead in thinking and rethinking.
My
felt obligation to the world was very real and somehow I had to solve
the problem of whether this obligation could be discharged through
the “Church of Christ.” Within a year after getting up it
was apparent to me that it could not.
It
is certainly of little significance to anyone else, but for the sake
of those who have asked me, I wish I were acute enough in
self-analysis to say just how much the frustration of my felt
obligation had to do with my questioning the whole of traditional
theism. At any rate, the doubts became overwhelming.
In
order to fulfill several desires, I became minister of a Unitarian
Fellowship. Here my questioning was welcomed and heartily shared,
though the degree of social commitment of the members was
disappointing to me. In every sermon I made serious effort to explore
ethical and religious alternatives in a way I never could before.
These years were happy and fruitful, even when filled with the
controversy that a vocal liberal invariably encountered in a southern
city. My wife and I were pleased to note our children’s growth
in independence of thought and feeling in those character forming
years. Stimuli for this independence came both from the Liberal
Religious Youth of the Unitarian Fellowship, and from their
participation with their parents in the defense of several causes we
felt to be involved in our obligation to society.
Looking
back over the skirmishes of those years. I see how the spirit and
tactics of my earlier religious debates were now employed in such
causes as promoting internationalism (especially the U. N.) against
the isolationists of our community, upholding constitutional rights
by work for
the
American Civil Liberties Union and against
the
John Birchers and assorted reactionaries. What I had yet to learn was
the way communities can be moved by working with, rather than
against, their leaders. This came to me gradually in the throes of
constant controversy. The art of political compromise is not easily
learned by a staunch idealist. But it can be learned.
In
1957 my public defense of the United Nations against the American
coalition of Patriotic Societies, headed by an arch segregationist
gubernatorial candidate, led to a weekly TV program, “Your
United Nations.” During the two years or more that I did this
show, I was in a running battle with the Birch forces that were
ultimately to pressure the Tampa University administration into
denying me tenure, and eventually banning me from the campus. The
controversy spread over many states and resulted in my basic decision
not to go North, but to stay right here in the South where I felt an
obligation regardless of the particular work I might have to do to
earn a living.
Separation
from the University coincided with my decision to leave the ministry.
Something new emerged—a human being without title of preacher
or professor, just a citizen with a family to feed and to enjoy. The
problem of feeding was solved admirably by an immediate offer from a
wonderful Rabbi who asked me to join his real estate firm. No one was
ever kinder or more generous than he was to me. The new world of
business was fascinating, hard, intensely competitive, and
profitable. Working day and night to sell property, I was allowed
several weeks off to run for political office—really the best
way to learn politics. I have never regretted running or losing,
though it is terribly expensive.
Then
it happened. The real beginning of a new career. Community Service
Foundation, searching for a Project Director, offered the position to
me. Their work had been mainly in beginning self-help programs for
underprivileged southern Negroes. I had been involved in enough
causes, I thought, so I visited the President to get the job for a
friend. He turned down the friend, and I turned him down again. But I
could not put it out of my mind. I sat alone through the night in a
hotel room wrestling with the decision. After all, I had for the
first time in my life a job whose rewards were directly proportioned
to the kind of ability and energy used in it. Finally, I made the
choice for this new work—this new kind of ministry. Sara calls
it “doing the Lord’s work.” And how we have worked!
Starting and coordinating for a year an after-school and Saturday
enrichment program that enrolls over 2,500 Negro children (now an
official program of the school system); training several VISTA groups
for their work in the War on Poverty; setting up a statewide program
to benefit the wretched migrant farm laborers in Florida-and so on,
and on-doing the Lord’s work.
I
have no recommendations as to what course others should follow who
may be troubled as I was. I know only that I am experiencing a
fulfillment of the old idealisms, uncluttered now by quarrels over
dogma or ritual. I no longer feel the need to prove the rightness of
these actions. Time, experience, and the judgment of God and men will
do that. But, knowing how many have wondered, I made the promise in
this essay that I would list some of the barriers to my remaining in
the Church of Christ. Here they are:
The
only-true-church issue. I
once reviewed a book, Christianity
Rightly So Called,
in
which the author had defined the essentials of true Christianity in
such terms as to include Christians in all conservative
denominations. This list of essentials was too broad, I argued. The
Bible, not conservative Protestant churches, defines the essentials.
But
that argument cuts equally well against the “Church of Christ.”
Which branch of this post-Campbell body is the true church: the
anti-Sunday School branch? the Nashville branch? No one has written
anything like a “scriptural” justification for the view
that all
these comprise
the true “Church of Christ” and that some number of them
are “erring brethren.” Nor does it seem likely. Still,
that view prevails—or did among many “church members”
several years ago. The movement begun by Jesus has had a complex and
checkered history. It now strikes me as pure presumption for any man
to try to say where the “true” church stops and “false”
ones begin, although God knows I have been guilty of it often enough.
The
binding of apostolic examples. The
“true church” issue is vitally connected with the
question of “binding apostolic examples.” Early I learned
that the binding obligations of “true” Christians are (a)
direct commands, (b) apostolic examples, and (c) necessary
inferences. The commands did not bother me too much except for
certain ones like the holy kiss and the injunction to anoint the sick
with oil, both of which (along with several others) my church
conveniently dismissed. More recently, as part of the cooperation
controversy, I was bothered by the “Do good to all men”
imperative addressed to the Galatian churches but interpreted with
all sorts of restrictions by anti-cooperation brethren.
The
apostolic examples, however, were troublesome. Not until my 15th year
as a minister, after attending innumerable lectureships, did I hear a
young speaker at the Florida Christian College lectureship say in a
discussion of how to justify the binding of examples: “We begin
by assuming that Acts 20:7 is binding, and all others we bind are
derived from that assumption.” How true that is! How little
anyone said against it. How many have privately admitted it and
expressed the hope that somehow, somewhere, somebody would find
justification for what “we” had bound on the “church”
for so long. Could it be, for example, that esteeming “one day
above another” really is for the individual conscience to
decide?
The
necessary inference position is even worse. The trivial instances
usually adduced do not really support the practical requirements of
“our” positions. For instance, is it really a “necessary
inference” that because Paul commanded collections to be taken
on the first day of the week he also included communion in that
command and limited it
to
the first day? Logicians would be highly dubious of the “necessity”
of this inference. An inference is “necessary” only if,
by asserting the premises and denying the conclusion, one is involved
in self-contradiction. In this case, that does not happen.
The
Communion. As
I preached repeatedly on this subject, a question began to burn in
me: if one combines the scriptural account of “the living
bread,” which is Christ’s flesh, with the accounts of the
last supper, are not the differences in representation,
consubstantiation, and transubstantiation at least trivia
and
at most different
ways
of commemorating Christ’s sacrifice? The charge of cannibalism
often made against transubstantiation on the grounds that a
communicant actually eats flesh rests on a crude ignorance of the
doctrine. If Christ is “present” in some way in the bread
and/or wine, he is remembered and his sacrifice becomes more
meaningful. Whatever others may think, my own hope is to see
Protestants and Catholics taking communion together—each
interpreting Christ’s “presence” as his perspective
dictates.
Casuistical
Morals. I
was indoctrinated at an early age against drinking, gambling,
dancing, “mixed” swimming, Sunday (and at some periods all)
movies,
and women’s (and at times all)
smoking.
I was disturbed when occasionally I allowed the facts of Biblical
remarks on dancing to upset my church’s dogma against it. The
trouble really began when our eight-year-old daughter was bitterly
denounced, along with her parents, for enrolling with neighborhood
girls in a ballet class. Nothing seemed amiss in her behavior. No
scripture or moral principles I could find made it suspect.
Then
our love of activity with our children caused us to subscribe to
family rates at the local community swimming pool next door to
Florida Christian College. What was a delightful family experience
became a scandal when pictured by the puritanical. Again, no
scriptural or moral principles condemned our action.
Along
with the controversies touched off by what we knew to be innocent
behavior went an intensive study of Christian ethics and morals in
the light of a fresh examination of the New Testament. The results
were revolutionary. Paul had asked, “Why should I be judged by
another man’s conscience?” Yet this same chapter was used
in the Church of Christ to argue the necessity of being judged by any
and everyone’s conscience. Paul’s assertion that “nothing
is of itself unclean” had been forgotten in a puritanical
assault on everything that somebody did not like.
Truly
disturbing to us was that good friends in “The Church”
agreed with us privately, but implored us not to do the things in
question “lest you destroy your effectiveness in The Church.”
The rightness of the actions when done in moderation and with respect
for the rights of others implied to us the freedom to do them. It
still does. If “The Church” would not tolerate us when we
were doing something right, then the necessity of our tolerating “The
Church” became questionable.
The
Church of Christ seems unwilling to allow individual members to use
their own consciences in deciding whether to dance, drink or gamble
in moderation. The dogmatism in these matters stems, it seems to me,
from the assumption that God has spoken in clear sentences and that
he has given infallible understanding of His will. In reality each
person, especially ministers and elders, becomes a miniature Pope,
with ex
cathedra utterances
on any matter that either God or the “pioneers” has
vouchsafed to him. Safeguarding the system of doctrine becomes much
more important than reflecting Christ’s regard for people and
their needs.
POSTSCRIPT
My
aversion to traditional theism has somewhat abated. I am intensely
interested in and excited by the fresh ecumenical winds blowing
across today’s churches. May they not diminish! Let us hope
that when Christians finally get together they do not ignore those
Jewish thinkers who are finding new appreciation for the person and
work of Jesus. A warm cooperation among all segments of our
Judeo-Christian tradition in the interest of helping solve humanity’s
pressing problems would be most significant. Before such a moral
force, aided by the good people of Eastern and African traditions,
perhaps even the age-old spectres of war and peace, poverty and
plenty, justice and injustice, could be banished. That would truly be
the real millennium.