|
CARL
L. ETTER graduated from Abilene Christian College in 1922, and did
graduate work in religion at the University of Michigan and the
University of Southern California while preaching for Churches of
Christ in Detroit and Los Angeles. He went to Japan in 1928,
intending to spend his life as a missionary. When his sponsoring
Church of Christ declined to support him while he learned the
language, he became a teacher in one of Japan’s government
universities and supported himself for four years. Upon leaving the
university, he offered again to do missionary work, but the
sponsoring church felt incapable of supporting him because of the
depression in the United States.
Mr.
Etter was offered scholarships at the University of Edinburgh and at
the School of Religion in Berkeley, California, but he returned to
southern California. After continued studies at the University of
Southern California he began work with the Los Angeles city schools
as supervisor of guidance and rehabilitation for physically limited
students. He considers the chance to help some 25,000 handicapped
students become vocationally adjusted a compensating experience for
one who was dedicated to the ministry and to missionary work in the
Church of Christ.”
Before leaving the Church of Christ, Mr. Etter declined invitations to serve as minister for churches in California Michigan Tennessee, and Texas, and to become president of two different Church of Christ colleges. He earned the Ph.D. degree in 1953 from the University of Hokkaido. His doctoral dissertation on the animistic religion of the aboriginal tribes of Japan was published as a book, entitled Ainu Folklore. |
IN SEARCH OF FREEDOM
By
Carl L. Etter
EDITOR’S
NOTE: When Carl and Grayce Etter left the Church of Christ in 1945
many of their friends were dismayed. The following explanation of
their move appeared in the West
Coast Christian in
that year. Mr. Etter has added recent comments in a postscript at the
end of this essay.
Since
the West
Coast Christian carried
an announcement of our affiliation with the Congregational Church, a
number of friends have written to us expressing regrets. These kind
letters have been appreciated and we are preparing a brief statement
for the information of these interested friends.
The
shock which these good people have received from our move is quite
understandable. We are members of Church of Christ families which
have been identified with the church for several generations. We are
former students of Christian colleges, and I served as head of the
Religion Department in one of them. In days gone by I have had
opportunities to serve those schools as dean and also as president,
and have occupied Church of Christ pulpits from Detroit to Los
Angeles. For four years we were in Japan where I taught in the
Hokkaido Imperial University and assisted in establishing the first
Church of Christ mission in the northern islands of Japan.
Therefore,
our religious change has not been made in ignorance of the Church of
Christ and its teachings. Neither has it been made in haste, nor in
anger, but out of deep conviction—a conviction that has grown
over a period of many years of university training, prayer, and
thoughtful consideration. Our reasons for this change are legion, but
we shall list only a few of them in this statement.
First,
we
do not subscribe to the belief that the Church of Christ, as it is so
labeled, includes all the true Christians. To become identified with
another religious group is no evidence that one is not a member of
the Church of Christ in its true and universal sense.
Second,
the
teaching of the Church of Christ is based upon a superficial
interpretation of the Bible and is fundamentally in error. This is
true with reference to the nature of God, Christ, the Bible, the
Church, man’s mission in the world, and many other issues
having both theological and social implications.
Third,
the
teaching of the Church of Christ is inconsistent and contradicts the
announced slogans of the so-called Restoration Movement. The Church
of Christ proposes to speak where the Bible speaks and keep silent
where it is silent. It does neither.
Fourth,
the
Church of Christ claims to have no creed except Christ, but it has
over twenty unwritten creeds to one of which one must subscribe in
order to have fellowship with that particular wing of the church with
which one chooses to become identified. Some of the letters which we
have received, including letters from ministers known to be “sound
in the faith,” point out that the Church of Christ is becoming
increasingly interested in heresy hunting. How do these heresy
hunters determine when they have found a victim? They hear his
speech, or read his writings, and weigh what they hear or read
against the teaching in the unwritten creed or creeds which they have
adopted as their standard. Christ was wise enough to stay out of the
writing field, but He was finally apprehended by heresy hunters of
His day and condemned on the basis of hearsay. The hearsay was
inaccurate, as it always is, but His devotion to truth was strong
enough to lead Him to His cross rather than recant and subscribe to
the unwritten creed of those He knew to be in error. Had He done
otherwise He would have died in oblivion, and probably would have
lost His own soul as did the heresy hunters who nailed Him to His
cross.
Fifth,
the
Church of Christ claims to have all the truth, but, in fact, is
groping in darkness. It absolutely forbids new light to enter, and
perpetuates its own inadequate insights by refusing to hear those who
have persisted in their quest for truth. The founder of the Christian
religion met the same type of religionists in His day and told them
it was a case of the blind leading the blind.
Sixth,
the
Church of Christ makes great capital of its abilities properly to
divide the word of God, but the system used is without scriptural
sanction and has the net result of rejecting large portions of the
Bible on the grounds that it was written to another people or a
different age. The historical approach to Bible study restores every
verse of the Scriptures and makes the entire Bible throb with intense
interest to the modern student.
Seventh,
the
educational program of the Church of Christ is unwilling to trust the
youth of the church with the facts of life and religion. It exposes
its youth to a smattering of superficialities and when they go on for
more advanced learning they are often left in a state of frenetic
confusion. Some of them drop by the wayside, a few go on to new
convictions, and others apathetically fall in line with public
opinion in the church, ratifying and perpetuating the existing order.
Our souls are stirred by mixed emotions when intelligent,
highly-educated ministers say, “We know these to be the facts,
but our people are not yet ready to receive them. We must go slowly
and lead them gradually.” We would be the last to betray these
ministers. We fully recognize their desire to remain with the people
whom they love better than their own souls, but we feel that a deeper
loyalty to Christ should inspire them to take up their crosses and
follow Him who said, “Ye shall know the truth, and the truth
shall make you free.”
Eighth,
the
leaders of the Church of Christ have placed it in an embarrassing
position by continual warfare upon science and the scientific
attitude. This fight against science is based upon fear that it will
destroy faith in the pet shibboleths of the church. It does. Some of
the most cherished doctrines of the church of Christ burst like
iridescent bubbles when exposed to the searchlight of the scientific
approach in religion. The Apostle Paul was using scientific
terminology when he said, “Prove all things; hold fast that
which is good.” Real science does not drive one away from true
religion. Dr. Millikan is an ardent Congregationalist, and other
scientists are also devout Christians. The scientific approach to
religion should have a salutary effect in driving out much of the
superstition and fear which has haunted religion through the
centuries, and will help the Church to retain in its leadership many
good men who otherwise would be lost.
Ninth,
the
message of the Church of Christ is negative in much of its teaching,
and offers no constructive program to take the place of that which it
condemns. With reference to many of its “thou shalt nots,”
it could well afford to “eliminate the negative and accentuate
the positive.”
Tenth,
the
Church of Christ has such great faith in the correctness of its
position that it has developed a smugness that borders on that
holier-than-thou attitude so well illustrated by certain religious
sects who received the most scathing rebukes of Christ in His day.
Eleventh,
the
Church of Christ preaches undenominational Christianity, but in
reality is the most denominational of all denominations. It is
neither Protestant nor Catholic, but a group of small, warring sects
which are little denominations within a denomination.
Twelfth,
the
Church of Christ preaches unity and practices division more
paradoxically than any church with which we are familiar. The
greatest need in this war-torn world is united effort on the part of
Christian peoples around the earth. In our opinion the Church of
Christ will not espouse such a cause, but will continue to tear
itself to pieces over minor issues while the world burns.
Thirteenth,
the
Church of Christ refuses to cooperate with its religious neighbors in
movements that are designed to make the world a better place in which
to live, but compasses land and sea in quest of proselytes on the
basis that it has a more certain pattern for reaching heaven. Jesus
told the proselyters of His day that their converts became two-fold
more the children of hell; we may well ask ourselves if we are not
helping history to repeat itself at this point.
Fourteenth,
the
Church of Christ, in many places, is trying to carry water on both
shoulders by appearing to be liberal to the world and strictly
orthodox to its own brotherhood. In one case the Church’s
position on undenominational Christianity was deliberately made to
appear as a broad-gauged liberal Christianity which was wide open to
peoples of all religious faiths. Certain of our Christian colleges
have found this to be a good way to gain prestige with the
educational leaders of the community.
Fifteenth,
the
Church of Christ claims to be allied with the religious
fundamentalists, but its position is more accurately described by the
term incidentalist. The merest incidental in the daily experience of
New Testament characters is magnified into a matter of great
importance and around it is built an article of faith for the
unwritten creed.
Even
a matter which was so incidental that neither Christ nor the Apostles
referred to it in any way is included in the creed on the basis that
the New Testament is not only inclusive but exclusive in its
teaching. Instrumental music is an incidental which falls in this
category. The modern hymnal and many other things might well be
condemned on the same basis. The incidentalists in Christ’s day
placed religious significance on the incidental of washing hands; and
it is strange that the Church has not done the same for the washing
of feet, because they have a New Testament example for that custom.
The
Jews and Samaritans considered the place of worship an incidental of
great importance, but Jesus pointed out to them that the place of
worship is a mere incidental and focused their attention upon the
more important fact that God is a spiritual being and “seeketh
such to worship him.” Those same religionists crucified Christ
because He discredited other incidentals in their religion and
pointed them to the “weightier matters of the law.” From
the viewpoint of His adversaries He was a modernist in His day, but
in reality He emphasized fundamentals and they magnified incidentals.
Incidentalism should not be mistaken for fundamentalism.
Sixteenth,
the
Church of Christ has its eyes on the past and is more concerned with
“old paths,” than in directing people to paths they can
follow successfully in our modern age. Although we wear the
habiliments of civilization, some of us have not advanced far from
the primitive tribal faith in the witch doctor. Our gullibility and
non-scientific approach to the concepts of our forebears have
prevented us from getting a true perspective of the world in which we
live.
For
example, in order to preserve preconceived and inherited theories of
Biblical inspiration and interpretation, we vilify God before our
youth by identifying Him with the wars of the Jews and the slaughter
of ancient races while we do and say little to outlaw war and relieve
race tensions in our own day. We pay great tribute to the inspired
prophets of old and attribute marvelous things to the New Testament
period of inspiration, but oppose as unscriptural innovations
everything that might add beauty and inspiration in the religious
experiences of our own children. These are only a few products of
this backward look in religion as practiced in the Churches of
Christ.
Seventeenth,
the
Church of Christ does not encourage growth and has a set policy which
opposes change. No institution, including the church, can hope to
survive in this changing world unless it encourages constant
reappraisal of things as they are and stimulates hope that leads to
action for their betterment. This does not mean that eternal verities
are to be kept in constant flux, but it does suggest that these
lasting values must constantly be reoriented in a changing world,
just as Jesus did for religion in His day. Any other policy leads to
an enduring social stratification based on birth, race, religion, or
wealth—whether inherited or otherwise acquired.
Eighteenth,
the
Church of Christ has no place in its fellowship for one who does not
conform fully to the status quo. Even though we cast him out of our
ecclesiastical circle, we expect him to remain with us and expose his
children to our unfair attacks. Every man, woman, and child needs a
sense of security and a feeling of belonging. It has been my
observation for many years that the Church of Christ withdraws these
essential requirements of the human spirit from those who manifest a
tendency to do independent thinking. This is a subtle type of force.
A more democratic institution appeals to reason rather than force to
secure its end.
Nineteenth,
the
Church of Christ has a double standard for judging persons who are
accused of violating what the church considers to be New Testament
teaching. Those who transgress the moral code are dealt with on one
basis and those who depart from the Church’s theological
position are dealt with on a different basis. Here is an illustration
of how two leaders were handled: one man was reported liberal in his
point of view, the other was convicted of immoral conduct. The
liberal was cast out and forced to seek another fellowship, even
though he loved the church with every fibre of his being. The man who
had violated the moral law was exalted to the most honored positions
in the church. This illustration could be multiplied tenfold.
Twentieth,
there
are many indications that the Church of Christ is showing signs of
decadence and that it is running a marathon race with catastrophe. It
is true that certain shifts in our population are causing increased
membership in some sections of the country, but there is little
manifest interest by those from without. Of greater significance is
the fact that many members of the church are discontented,
discouraged, and starving for spiritual uplift which does not, and
cannot, radiate from a church whose message is basically negative,
argumentative, belligerent, and antagonistic.
Having
been denied in the Church of Christ a wholehearted fellowship in
which we could raise our family, we have sought the fellowship of the
Congregationalists, not because they are perfect nor because they
have all the truth. But they encourage scholarship, are in harmony
with modern religious thought, practice tolerance within and without
their fellowship, earnestly seek and accept new truth, have a rare
faculty for discerning fundamentals, do not disproportionately
emphasize incidentals, weigh all related facts in their
interpretation of the Bible and religion, have neither a written nor
unwritten creed, have a constructive and modern educational program
for youth, encourage intellectual honesty, take cognizance of the
present and look toward the future, cooperate fully with every good
cause, encourage growth, are not opposed to change, allow for
individual differences in spiritual growth, and fellowship those who
have attained different levels of religious thinking in their
development.
If
we ever come to feel differently we shall be frank to say so, and
shall be as sincere then as we are now in the stand we are taking. In
the meantime, we are still your friends and shall continue to love
you as we always have.
POSTSCRIPT,
1965
My
wife and I have, in our hearts, great and abiding sentiments about
the church of our childhood and always rejoice in every report of its
achievements and progress. It is heartening to know that an
increasing number of its leaders are assuming an open-minded attitude
toward the facts of modern scholarship in religion. My wife and I
enjoy the friendship of many Church of Christ members, even though we
are no longer affiliated with that fellowship.
It
is my feeling that the Restoration Movement was motivated by
conditions in the religious world which were oppressive and in need
of reform. I was impressed anew with this on a recent eight months
trip around the world during which my wife and I visited thirty-two
countries. The shrines and temples in Oriental countries, the
monuments and pyramids of Egypt, the colossus of St. Peter’s
and the fabulous cathedrals of Europe are all monuments to the
slavery of the poor, illiterate masses and to departures from the
simple foundations of all world religions, including Christianity.
I
believe that the attempt to restore the simplicity of the New
Testament church was a worthy cause and that the Church of Christ
stood in the vanguard of a movement which could have resulted in
great good had later leaders in the movement not succumbed to narrow,
authoritarian dogmatism which turned it into one of the most
denominational sects of our modern age.
EDITOR’S
NOTE: Many years ago the Gospel
Advocate published
an undated pamphlet in which G. C. Brewer reviews the reasons given
for their departure from the Church of Christ by both Mr. Etter and
Mr. Reedy, whose essay appears elsewhere in this collection. Mr.
Brewer admits that “no two young people in our times have been
held in higher esteem than Carl and Grayce Etter” and praises
their “fine personalities, their zeal and their faith.”
He then considers their arguments in order, referring to them as “the
educated Reedy and the spoiled-child Etter,” as “a
disgruntled and a renegade preacher,” as “this blind,
blatant Modernist,” as “apostates,” and declares
that “Verily the Etters and Reedies like Judas went to their
own place!” The pamphlet can be purchased from the Gospel
Advocate for
$1.