|
ROY KEY is now senior minister of the First Christian Church (Disciples of Christ) in Ames, Iowa. He has had many years of close ties with Church of Christ pulpits and schools. He is a graduate of David Lipscomb College and George Pepperdine College and has taught at Dasher Bible School in Valdosta, Georgia. He has served Churches of Christ as a minister at several places in the Los Angeles, California, area, including two years at Fillmore and one year at the Sichel Street congregation. He preached for three years on Long Island and for ten years in Chicago (approximately five years each at Harvey and West Suburban Church of Christ in Berkeley). The
holder of many scholastic and personal honors (among them the
presidency of the Pepperdine student body), Mr. Key has an M.A. from
Pepperdine, a B.D. from Drake University School (1962), and has
attended Union Theological Seminary McCormick Theological Seminary,
and Chicago Lutheran Theological Seminary, during his sojourn in New
York and Chicago.
While at Drake University, Mr. Key preached for the Lohrville Christian Church and taught a freshman course in introduction to the Bible at Simpson College in Indianola, Iowa. Following his graduation from Drake, he spent a year as associate minister for University Christian Church, Des Moines, Iowa, moving in July, 1963, to his present position. |
A
LETTER TO DADDY AND MOTHER
By
Roy Key
FOREWORD
I
am glad to say a word about my decision in 1960 to enter the
fellowship of the Christian Church (Disciples of Christ). Since it
was made out of great agony of spirit and through long months of
struggle in prayer, there are no simple statements that can convey
the meaning of the experience. Therefore, rather than write an essay
now about what took place four years ago, I have chosen to bare my
most intimate thoughts and share with you a letter which I wrote to
my parents.
It
is with reservations that I permit publication of so personal a
correspondence. Though many will read with compassion and
understanding, I fear that some will stare with scorn. But I know of
nothing I could say now that would speak to the real reasons for my
decision more clearly than this letter home. I wrote it broken in
spirit, with the realization that had I been a better Christian I
might have been able to pay a starker penalty. Some pages I wrote
barely able to see the paper before me and, at times, literally on my
knees.
Because
my heart aches for the estrangements among us; because I know that
God is at work through the cross to bind up our wounds and make us
whole; and because I want to make every effort I can to help heal our
rift rather than widen it, I consent to the publication of this
letter, with the prayer that our Lord’s petition for oneness
may be more fully answered.
* * * * * * * * *
Dear
Mother Sue and Daddy,
Crises
come to us individually and as families. Some of them are terribly
painful, but all of them are guided by God for good, if we permit.
Together we have weathered many a storm, but one is coming now which
is unusually fierce. I shall try to tell you how it has risen. But
that is a long story, and I want to start at the beginning.
When
we were children at home, times were hard; but even when the rain
didn’t come and the cotton was stunted and the corn burned, we
were not anxious. We were sure that our parents could take care of
everything. Since we believed that you loved us, we were secure in
your care.
God
must have given us parents that we might learn love and obedience,
learn better how to think of Him and find security in Him. Afterward
when life brings change, disappointment, disapproval, and finally
death, we may face them all in the knowledge of a Father’s
concern.
You
made it possible for your children to find in God a Father who
understands, cares, forgives, and empowers. Often, in trying to
picture our security in His love, I have said, “If my Daddy or
my Mother were God, I would not be afraid.”
Undoubtedly,
our family relation helped to reveal the personal kinship of love as
the highest tie possible. It is as high as the heavens above the
legal relationthat of one citizen to another, or of the criminal
before the judge. The stedfast love existing between husband and
wife, or children and parents, is not in deadly peril of crumbling at
each moment.
It
was a long, long time, though, before I came to see that this
intimate, personal, family relation exists between us and God.
The
road was long and torturous as it led me to the happy realization
that we stand or fall before God not on the basis of code-keeping,
but on the basis of loving trust. It was long and torturous because
we were taught at church and through our religious papers that the
Gospel of Christ is another law
in
the same sense as the Law of Moses. We were taught that we stood
condemned or accepted before God on the basis of a complete keeping
of that law. So you see, though I was secure in the belief of your
love, I was far from sure about my relation to God.
Many
a time I dreamed of the Judgment Day, but never did I dream that I
was saved. Always I was lost. Still do I remember those nightmares
and how happy I was to wake up, finding that you had already covered
the distance between our beds and were there in the dark reassuring
me. Yet I could not believe that if I died before morning God would
take me home with Him. Perhaps I knew that I didn’t deserve His
salvation. While I didn’t deserve your love either, I knew it
was there, anyway. That was the difference.
How
could I be so sure of my relation to you and so uncertain of my
relation to God? I think it must have been because you both knew your
love of us better than you knew God’s love for you. Our
relation at home was one thing, our relation to God something
entirely different. You, too, had been taught that the law is supreme
and that its slightest infraction endangers the soul. Our family, and
many of our brethren, were born and bred in this atmosphere of dark
and suffocating fear.
While
I was still at home, I began to puzzle over the lack of assurance in
the hearts of our people generally, as contrasted with the glad
certainty in the hearts of New Testament Christians. Our brethren
seemed to know what
they
believed, but they never smiled confidently and declared, “I
know whom
I
have believed and am persuaded that He is able to keep that which I
have committed unto Him against that day” (2 Timothy 1:12). It
was all quite strange for people who kept insisting, “We are
New Testament Christians.”
One
day as I read an editorial from the Gospel
Advocate on
“The Gift of the Holy Spirit,” I was shocked and deeply
troubled, for I could see at that age that our leading brother had
failed to come to grips with the Scriptures. I kept asking myself,
“Do our brethren not know all the truth? Is it possible that
other religious teachers and preachers could know more about some
things?”
Such
painful questions I tried to repress, attempting to find security in
maintaining that our brethren knew almost
all
the truth, at least all that was really vital. Deep down inside,
though, I feared that our hearts were less sure than our tongues.
At
Lipscomb and Pepperdine I studied hard to find what it was that early
Christians had and we had missed. I enrolled in some Bible courses
not required and audited still others, aside from my private study.
Not that I was unsure about “The Church of Christ” and
what it stood for, but because I was groping for a surer personal
grasp of God. I saw brethren full of anxiety, and I felt that I
couldn’t help them as I ought until I had won victory over that
same paralyzing fear.
More
and more I studied the books of Romans and Galatians, for in them I
caught gleams of light in the dark. Fresh air right from the windows
of heaven seemed to blow in my face. I would catch my breath,
wondering if we really had a Gospel as good as Paul seemed to say. It
was too good to be true.
Nightmares
came no more. My dreams were haunted with glory. As Paul described
the “righteousness” which God gives to the man who has
none of his own but does have “faith in Jesus Christ,” my
heart thrilled as it never thrilled before. Here was one who had not
done
the necessary work required by the law (I knew this one to be
myself), but he had
believed
in Christ. Here was my certainty. Though unworthy of God’s gift
of redeeming love, I knew that my whole trust was in Christ Jesus as
Savior and Lord.
What
did Paul say of this one? He quoted David’s pronouncement of
blessing upon the man to whom God reckons righteousness apart from
works:
Blessed are those whose iniquities are forgiven, and whose sins are covered;
blessed
is the man against whom the Lord will not reckon his sin. (Romans
4:6-8)
My
heart almost burst with joy. My eyes and soul spilled over in
gratitude. To think that I was really accepted not on the basis of my
perfect obedience to law, but through faith in Jesus Christ—the
thought was incredibly glorious!
At
the moment I was not concerned about arguments over “faith
versus works.” I needed no reminder that true faith lures a man
to work far beyond all legal demands. I was seeking no easy way to
pardon, a way devoid of effort. Gladly I would have worked till I
dropped dead, if only I could be sure of God’s loving
acceptance. Now I had it as His gracious Gift in Christ.
On
the basis of being perfectly right
in
understanding and life I knew myself lost. Now, however, I knew of a
man (the believer in Christ) to whom God would not reckon his sins.
Here was a standing with God that did not depend on one’s
perfection. I found peace in the midst of my imperfection. I knew
that faith was far more than believing the facts of the Gospel. I
could never have peace through that kind of faith. I knew that it was
commitment in trust to Christ as Savior and a full reliance upon Him,
without stopping to hold up a single trait or deed of self.
Many,
many truths had to be related to this central one that “in
Christ” “through faith” we stand in right relation
to God. I had to study the Scriptural relation of repentance to
faith, of baptism, of grace, of works, of the Holy Spirit, of growth
in Christlikeness. But in all I could see that God deals with us as
persons, not puppets, as sons-in-love and not sons-in-law.
My
groping for God was really His grasping of me. How clear it became.
The Almighty wants a Family. He offers Himself to us as Father. The
Gift is Himself-in loving companionship. He cannot force Himself upon
us. No amount of works on our part or marking through sins in some
celestial ledger on His part will give to us Himself.
Love
can neither be purchased at the super-mart nor created by juggling
the entries in the account books of our lives. Our family was not so
created, and neither is God’s.
As
I learned more about
God
it became crystal clear that what brought peace and the deep
enriching of life was not mere information. The word “Father”
was familiar enough. Only now it became more than a word. It was a
window, a window in the Throne room of the Almighty. I could see Him
who ruled the world as “my Father.” It was He who had
come near in Jesus holding out His hands, grasping ours in His own
and refusing to let go, taking us all the way to Calvary and there in
the blaze of His Cross illumining the depth of our selfish, fearful
pride and the height of His selfless, transfiguring love.
The
joy of knowing Him who sees us as we are and accepts us anyway is a
heady wine that bursts all the wineskins of words and spills through
our souls. I wish desperately that there were some way of saying it
so that you would have to understand. I not only want to know that
God’s Gift to us in Christ is Himself in loving friendship, but
I want you to know the Gift is yours, as well as mine. May the Spirit
of the living Christ breathe through these pitifully inadequate words
something of His own Presence.
Please,
let me labor this point, for it is a labor of love. You gave us many
things at home: something to eat and wear, an opportunity to go to
school, an extra something when it could be squeezed into the budget.
But
these were not your greatest gifts. Greatest of all was yourselves.
Not just your protection or information about you, but you we
received.
If
all that I knew of you was that you were responsible for my birth,
that you are older and much wiser than I, and that I must honor you,
as a family we would be non-existent. What really made the home was
to know you, Mother Sue and Daddy. O, this was much, much more than
having enough information to write a book about you, even as you know
how much greater the joy to be with
those
you love than to hear from
them.
How
would you feel if your children never thought that it was possible to
know you personally? What if they thought faithfulness meant studying
feverishly the accounts of your movements, memorizing your letters
and making a legal code out of them by which to order their lives?
What if they were scared to death that a mistake would cause you to
cut them off forever? Would this make you supremely happy or break
your heart?
What
pains me terribly is that we generally in Churches of Christ are
breaking God’s heart while striving feverishly to be right,
absolutely right. We should try to be right, but when we think that
our relation to God is based on that rightness, we live under the
constant threat of doom. We are not infallible. We blunder. If God
will seize such error to damn us, then we are damned, for we are
sinners.
To
avoid despair we must shout loudly (until we believe ourselves,
whether or not anyone else believes us) that we are right on the
things that really count. We can take the easier things: immersion,
weekly communion, “Church of Christ” name, and contend
that these are the things that make us true Christians. Even if we
don’t love God or our brothers as we ought, we have kept the
greater commandments. If we insist loudly enough, we generate a type
of assurance, but the very shouting and stamping of our feet reveal
that we are yet anxious and insecure deep inside.
Among
many of our brethren the sense of God’s acceptance is based
upon everybody’s else’s rejection. Where people disagree,
somebody is wrong. People who are wrong cannot be saved. Therefore,
it is not merely pride and arrogance that make us shout frantically
that we are right. Whatever security of soul we have is at stake. We
must
be
right. We cannot afford to admit otherwise. If we are wrong, we are
utterly lost.
This
view makes it necessary to fight fiercely those who disagree with us.
Not simply because we love them nor because we love the Kingdom, but
because our soul-security trembles in the balance. Only in the
insistence that we are right and all other groups wrong are we able
to find sufficient assurance of God’s acceptance to make life
bearable. We must cling to it at all costs.
Should
we consider the possibility that people in the “denominations”
may be saved, our very faith would be shaken. How startling a
revelation is this! It shows that our faith is grounded wrong. It is
not really faith in Christ as God’s redeeming sacrifice for us.
It is faith in our rightness
and
everybody else’s wrongness.
Of
others like us Jesus once said, “They trusted in themselves
that they were righteous and set all others at nought” (Luke
18:9).
We
have come to illustrate in devastating fashion what is meant by
“self-righteousness.”
It
does little good for us to be deeply offended when outsiders say so.
Our denial is far from convincing. It has become impossible for us to
smite our breasts and cry, “God, be merciful to me a sinner!”
for that confession would put us on the level of other sinners.
Nothing that we have, or are, or know, would give us any advantage.
We simply cannot afford such humiliation, and it proves beyond doubt
that we really are “self-righteous.”
When
one realizes that God accepts him, not because he is good or smart
(better and smarter than others), but while he is a sinner, he wants
to sing of the mercy of God. He wants others to know of such a
Savior. He finds that he has a security in Christ that does not rest
upon the damnation of those with whom he disagrees.
For
nearly twenty years I have seen that “The Church of Christ”
is not the whole family of God. It can be only a part. All those
everywhere who have been “born over from above” are in
the family. Jesus said, “He that believeth and is baptized
shall be saved” (Mark 16:16). There are millions aside from us
who have done just this. How on earth can we assert, “We are
“The
Church
of Christ,’ “ excluding these whom Jesus declares
“saved?”
We
must deny Jesus’ words or grant that all baptized believers are
in “the Church.” Some brethren will admit it but refuse
to recognize them as brethren by contending that they are “in
error.” Self-righteousness prompts us to say, “We are the
true Christians not
in
error.” When our own Brotherhood is split some twenty-odd ways,
we are obviously “in error.” None of us has hope apart
from God’s over-flowing mercy. We all have the privilege of
prayer and forgiveness. “In Christ” there is continual
cleansing. I know not why we should declare that in Christ is
continual cleansing for us alone.
The
thought seems to be that as individuals we sin constantly, but as
a group we
are perfect, “without error.” We fool no one else, and we
hardly fool ourselves, for we then hasten to add, “We are
without doctrinal
error.”
When we have run out of breath asserting our doctrinal purity, our
divisions stand there mocking us.
The
Church of God on earth is always “in error,” morally and
intellectually. We ever stand under judgment because of sin. But also
through faith we stand under God’s mercy. If we decide we do
not need to stand under His mercy, but can now rest on our own
perfection, we are “fallen away from grace,” (Galatians
5:4). If we knew what it meant to be saved by grace, we could catch a
glimpse of God’s greater Family.
A
long bitter road has led us to believe that God forgives every kind
of error but “doctrinal” error. What makes us think that
He forgives stinginess, lust, character assassination, worldliness,
laziness—everything but instrumental music in worship? Such
shallowness of heart and head is not born of the New Testament nor of
the Restoration Fathers. It is the bitter end of a sectarian spirit
that thrives on division and ministers to pride. It destroys us
spiritually.
I
doubt that we come to see God’s larger Family by pointing out
how good and right people in other churches are. Judged by Christ’s
perfect love and obedience they are all lost. And
so are we! It
is by seeing how we are put right, though
unrighteous, that
we come to see how other unrighteous souls are also “through
faith” “reckoned righteous.” At least, so it came
to me.
When
I realized that faith is personal rather than creedal, I could say,
“I do not know how right or wrong my brethren are on attitudes
or doctrinal points, but I do know that I am trusting Jesus Christ as
Savior. My relation to Him is personal and not legal.” I could
see my weakness and His power, my folly and His wisdom. I was
gloriously free from the law’s condemnation, but love was there
binding me to Him in a glad servitude that I would not escape if I
could.
Similarly,
I knew that others who laid themselves at Jesus’ feet for
mercy, as I had done, were as truly saved as I. If He did not
“reckon” my sins, He would not reckon theirs. Since both
are imperfect, neither of us can afford to boast. This doesn’t
mean that we can’t teach one another, point out the other’s
faults, if we discern them. If the same Spirit dwells in us both,
then He is patiently trying to lead both to the light and mercifully
covering our failures.
Because
our family has been one where we have attempted to be understanding
and forgiving, I am counting on you to glimpse what God is trying to
do with His Family and how He feels about His children. He is not
trying to send them all to hell, anymore than you are watching
jealously to find some reason to sever all relations with your
children. Surely, we break His heart when some of His children will
not even recognize others in the same Family.
Here
is the bend in the road for me—I cannot go on acting as if we
are the only Christians, refusing fellowship to others because my
“Church of Christ” brethren will not allow it. I cannot
continue the kind of church life that rends the Father’s Family
and breaks His heart. I must protest. Whether it does little good,
much good, or no good, I must be faithful to the right as God gives
me to see the right.
I
wish that I could widen my fellowship without being cut off by those
in Churches of Christ. No one can possibly know how much I care for
these people, how much I have suffered with them and by them, nor how
much more I would try to take, if it would help. But as Paul once had
to turn the larger part of his ministry away from those he loved most
dearly, I must turn, too. I do it not without months and years of
wrestling with my own soul and with God.
Several
months back I wrote concerning my health and the killing pressure
under which I have worked for years. I do not wish to flee any
Divinely-appointed task, but I don’t believe that God wants me
at this time to sacrifice either my life or my sanity in what seems a
fruitless endeavor. Believing also that He does not want me to give
up the ministry completely, I must do the best that I know to do,
trusting in His guidance.
How
much I hope that you can understand. How much I would like to make
you proud of me. But I surely will only make you ashamed, unless you
can understand what I am saying.
There
is no easy way for God to take us, break up the old cemented patterns
of thought and lead us into new paths, even when they lead to freedom
and peace. I am sure, Mother Sue and Daddy, that when you left the
Baptist Church before most of your children were born, you did not
find it easy to do. You had family and friends to consider. You did
it because you had to do it, because you believed God wished it and
that Scripture led to it. Now we must be as faithful as you were. It
is excruciatingly hard for us, but we wish that it might be easier
for you.
The
awareness of your pain is a knife-thrust in my own heart. It seems a
tragedy to come to the place where one must bow his head in his arms
and weep because he cannot spare a cross to those whom he loves. But
I cannot lay a heavier one upon my Lord. In all His compassion, He
still turns on us with blazing eye if we let those whom we love
better than life itself come before Him.
I
have tried harder than ever before to come back across the miles and
the years to let you walk with me down to the bend of the road where
I now stand. If you can look up and see with me, I shall fall on my
knees in gratitude to God. If you cannot, I must hold you a moment
and walk on, praying God to keep His promise of strength to us all,
trusting some day that He will remove your cross and mine and make
the dark things plain.
Above
the storm is God’s bow of promise, His covenant of grace with
us. He promises to receive us and to hold us “in Christ,”
all of us who will really accept Him. We must trust Him to do just
that. He has also promised to hear our prayers when we come to Him in
faith. Though I have prayed for a long time about this decision, one
day I went down on my knees and didn’t come up until I had it
out. I had to come to the place where I could say “Thy will be
done,” and mean it. I ask you to do that now. I am claiming
God’s promise in this matter. I am asking you to join me in it.
He will not fail.
With all my love and devotion,
Roy