|
RALPH V. GRAHAM served Churches of Christ as minister
for almost a quarter of a century before leaving in May of 1964 to
begin work with the First Christian Church (Disciples of Christ) in
Colorado City, Texas.
Baptized
in Abilene, Texas in 1939 by Louis Nowlin, Mr. Graham entered Abilene
Christian College in that year and graduated with honors in 1944.
During his undergraduate years he preached at Tuscola, Texas, at
North Park in Abilene, and at Pryor, Oklahoma.
In
1944, Mr. Graham entered Princeton Theological Seminary.
During
several years of study he preached for the Trenton, New Jersey Church
of Christ. He graduated from Princeton in 1949. A year’s work
with the Flushing, New York Church of Christ followed, after which
the Graham family moved to Collingswood, New Jersey in 1952.
During twelve years as minister at Collingswood, Mr. Graham attended Temple Graduate School of Theology, where he received his S.T.M., completed all residence requirements for the S.T.D., and completed twelve hours of graduate study in Guidance at Teacher’s College, Temple University. |
WHY
I LEFT THE “CHURCHES OF CHRIST”
By
Ralph V. Graham
In
1964, after twenty-five years of active membership in the Church of
Christ, I said farewell to that particular segment of Christendom and
began work with a Disciples of Christ congregation in Texas. The
months since then have brought the joy of new friends, great
challenges, much more freedom, and an opportunity to work toward what
I consider more authentic goals.
What
I have to say about leaving the Churches of Christ will not be
intentionally impertinent, arrogant, or self-righteous. I intend to
express my views and judgments clearly, with conviction, and for
constructive ends. I have no desire to justify myself, to prove
something to anyone, or to engage in any bitter exchange. What I
have, rather, is a word of explanation to those who have asked,
“Why?”
In
addition, I feel that such a statement is required of a friend to
friends and brethren who mean much to him. My prayer is that no one
will want to disfellowship me for the step I have taken, that the
greatest possible number will understand it, and that the greatest
possible number will consider seriously my criticisms which I intend
to be constructive. I think all of us should ask ourselves, “What
should I believe?” “How can I live in harmony with my
faith?” and “What do I dare to hope?” When we find
adequate answers, we should follow where they lead. I write with the
hope that what I say will be helpful to someone.
Looking
back, I can see clearly how my studies, working experiences, and
association with believers of different denominations led me
gradually into a deeper and broader Christian commitment than the
restricted liberty afforded me in the Churches of Christ. Being quite
outspoken in my preaching, talk, and writings, I found the
restrictions placed on my freedom of expression intolerably
frustrating. I and my congregation became subjected to a West
Berlin-type of isolation because of my views.
In
addition to this growing estrangement imposed from without, I found
also that I had come to be in complete disagreement with the aim,
views, message, method, and attitudes which characterize the Churches
of Christ. I had concluded that in all these areas the “position”
of the Churches of Christ was incorrect theologically,
philosophically, and psychologically, or, to be quite practical,
unscriptural, irrational, and unhealthy. Under the circumstances, I
did not have adequate moral support, opportunity to express and
practice what I believed to be the total will of Christ, or freedom
enough to work for the realization of what I considered to be
essentially Christian goals.
In
leaving the Churches of Christ I realize I have widened the distance
separating me from my brethren in that denomination. The opportunity
for dialogue has been diminished. In leaving, however, I did not
leave the fellowship of the body of Christ. I am conscious of a wider
fellowship than many members of the Churches of Christ feel. I am
aware that my departure was the occasion for some to feel
disappointment, some grief, and some satisfaction for being right in
their anticipations. But I feel no satisfaction in others’
disappointments and griefs. I have no feelings of rancor, bitterness,
or animosity. I do not wish to lose a single friend nor to dissolve
the bond of fellowship I have with anyone in Christ.
I
remember with pleasure a great deal of freedom in the Collingswood
congregation. No one mistreated me or compelled me to leave. I walked
away free, and I am free now. And I feel that no one should ever be
compelled to submerge his freedom or integrity in compromise for the
sake of friendship, brotherhood, peace, or security. I must say this
despite its apparent severity because it must be understood that
faith is a very personal thing and that one cannot speak freely and
honestly about faith and morals without hurting feelings. But neither
friendship nor freedom is compatible with silence. If my views offend
or wound anyone, it is done only as a friend wounds or offends.
“Faithful are the wounds of a friend,” the Scriptures
say. (Prov. 27:6).
Oliver
Wendell Holmes has said, “A man’s mind, stretched by a
new idea, can never. go back to its original dimension.”
Serious and continuous study in the pursuit of truth leads to new
plateaus and new relationships. Leo Tolstoy, in his Reply
to Edict of Excommunication, said:
“I do not believe my faith to be the one indubitable truth for
all time, but I see no other that is plainer, clearer, or answers
better to all the demands of my reason and my heart; should I find
such a one, I shall at once accept it …. But I can no more
return to that from which with such suffering I have escaped, than a
flying bird can re-enter the egg shell from which it has emerged.”
And Samuel Taylor Coleridge has declared: “He who begins by
loving Christianity better than truth, will proceed by loving his own
sect or church better than Christianity, and end in loving himself
(his own peace) better than all.”
These
men were advocates of honesty and believed that honesty demands a
tentative faith. But a tentative faith does not imply spineless or
weak convictions. I think it was Emerson who said once, “What I
believe today I speak in words like cannon balls. If my belief
changes before tomorrow, then tomorrow I will be speaking my new
convictions like cannon balls.” To follow a principle with
constancy will not necessarily result in consistency of belief. The
one thing I would like to have acknowledged in my case is honesty in
faith. Accepted on that basis, I could be much helped in my efforts
to live in harmony with honest faith.
I
shall set forth, now, at some length, views which I realize are not
acceptable in the Churches of Christ. I do not state them in order to
shock, but because I believe they are in harmony with Scripture. I
believe in the universality of truth, Christianity, the gospel, and
the church, but I have found that in the Churches of Christ, all
truth
does not enjoy free course.
I
am convinced, for example, that the Scriptures teach that the person
who confesses sincerely Jesus as Savior, Lord, Son of God, and
Christ, and serves him faithfully in that profession is a Christian
despite any errors he may hold unintentionally. Further, I do not
think anyone has the right to dictate how this conviction shall be
expressed. But evangelistic techniques in the Churches of Christ
exploit men’s fears, promise a spiritual security which is
secured only by man’s obedience, and place every convert in a
state isolated from all believers who are not members of the Churches
of Christ.
I
believe in Jesus Christ as the living Word of God, as the personal
interpretive principle of the Bible, and as the Lord of the Bible. He
is greater than the Bible and the Bible must fit Him, not He the
Bible. I believe that the Bible is a trustworthy account of the
Incarnation of the Living Word and of man’s encounter with God.
It is the normative witness for our faith and practice. But great as
the Bible is, it is not big enough to exhaust the meaning of Christ
for Christian faith. Once we learn of Him through the Bible, we will
continue to seek Him “beyond the sacred page.” The Bible
was never intended as a detailed blueprint of faith and practice.
When everything is forbidden that is not commanded, and everything
commanded that is not forbidden, believers are no longer free sons
but slaves of tyranny.
I
believe the creativity of man is God’s gift to be used in His
service and worship. There is positively and absolutely no Scriptural
warrant whatever for opposing instrumental music in the worship or in
forbidding any other artistic talent’s use for the glory of
God. All music, painting, architecture, and other forms of art in
good taste and capable of transmitting true devotion are acceptable
means of man’s adoration of His Creator. The Bible does not
teach that human initiative and spontaneity motivated by adoration of
God are to be penalized or outlawed as unscriptural.
I
believe that church organization in the New Testament is functional,
flexible, and pluralistic. There is no one form of church government
dictated by the New Testament in word or in example. Therefore,
differing patterns of church government do not justify religious
divisions. Means are always subordinate to ends. The congregations of
the church are intended by God to function as the body of Christ. To
maintain each congregation in isolation from every other is to
frustrate the church’s mission, misrepresent its nature, and
impoverish its fellowship.
I
believe that unity is a major concern of the heart of Christ. But
unity among believing Christians is not yet realized. It can be
achieved only in a common loyalty to Jesus as Lord and Savior through
mutual discussion, cooperation, give and take. Unity will never be
achieved unilaterally by any fragment of Christ’s body. The
standard for Christian unity is the unity we see between the Father
and the Son. This is the kind of unity our Lord desires. It is not
doctrinal, organizational, or ritual unity, but a unity of character,
purpose, action, love, fellowship, and will. The only real unity is
one that is functional, dynamic, and socio-personal.
I
believe in the liberty of the individual conscience in Christ. Men do
not have the right to dictate and determine the content and
expression of a Christian’s faith. The Christian is the servant
of his Lord and to his own Master he stands or falls. Freedom in
Christ is the individual’s right to act responsibly in the
fellowship of the body. Responsibility is determined by the Lordship
of Christ, the indwelling of the Holy Spirit, the insights of an
enlightened and rational conscience, the fellowship of the body, the
needs of the situation in the context where one is. The Holy Spirit
works dynamically in sanctifying believers; His work is not limited
to the effect of the words of the Bible on the human heart and mind.
He works when, and where, and how He pleases, rather than according
to predictable and fixed patterns.
I
believe that the church must be involved with ministering to the
whole man with a gospel unqualified by culture, nation, or race. The
church cannot isolate itself from the problems of politics,
economics, culture, health, freedom, human rights, and peace. I do
not believe in the proselyting of other believers, in following a
policy of isolationism, exclusivism, or neutralism. At the present
time, we Christians should be supporting the war against poverty. But
we should war also against prosperity when it is achieved at the cost
of integrity.
I
believe in distinguishing things that differ, in recognizing the
priority of some values over others, and in living by a scale of
values set forth in the Bible. Scripture speaks of some values in the
superlative. “Now abideth faith, hope, and love, but the
greatest of these is love.” Some values are put in the
comparative. Jesus is the surety of a better covenant, enacted on
better promises, introducing a better hope. Some things are just
good, others expedient, or lawful. Our Lord teaches “first
things first.” “Seek ye first the kingdom.” He
exalts the inward above the external, the substance above the shadow,
the eternal above the temporal, the spiritual above the material, the
principle above detailed minutiae, mercy above sacrificial obedience,
His word above tradition, the ideal above the practical, and human
need above ritual conformity even if a law must be broken.
I
believe in the present activity of God in history and that history is
meaningful as the stage of God’s activity. I believe in the
value and achievements of biblical scholarship, women’s work in
the church, the total involvement of the laity in Christian service,
and in the dignity and authority of the Christian ministry. I believe
in the aims of the ecumenical movement and that all Christians should
partake in its work. I believe church work should be comprehensive,
progressive, and relevant to contemporary life.
Holding
all these things as important to spiritual growth, I found the
Churches of Christ deficient. They seemed to me to offer poor
environment for development in the Christian graces. They are growing
numerically and their material expansion is astonishing. But
quantitative growth is no guarantee of truth or approvedness. I can
remember when smallness was used by them to some advantage when their
size was pointed out. One would hear them say, “Only two out of
two million who left Egypt reached the promised land!” “Only
two out of twelve spies who spied out Canaan entered that land the
second time.” “Only eight were saved in the flood.”
They said, “Jesus says, ‘Many are they that enter the
broad way, but few enter the narrow way of salvation!’”
We do not hear these illustrations used so much these days.
Let
us note, now, some of the environmental conditions in the Churches of
Christ which are not conducive to spiritual growth. The Churches of
Christ identify themselves as a “Restoration Movement”
which proposes to restore the New Testament Church in name,
organization, doctrine, worship, doctrine, vocabulary, unity,
conditions of membership, and creed. But the whole object of the
“Restoration Movement” is improper. Restoration assumes
the disappearance or cessation of the church in history. Now, we may
think of the church ideally or actually. The ideal church never
existed except as an idea in the mind of God. It has no real
existence, members, organization, or place in time. The ideal church
cannot be restored since it never existed. The actual church as
described in the New Testament did not have a uniform organization,
worship, practice, or faith, in all its congregations. The actual
church was plagued by heresies, divisions, immoralities, ignorance,
indifference, apostasy, and weakness. It has never ceased to be thus
plagued. Since it neither disappeared nor ceased being, it is not an
object of restoration. The Scriptures teach that the Lord’s
church cannot be destroyed. But, even if it could, would
“restorationists” restore the actual church? Do they know
what it is they are trying to restore? Actually, they should declare
themselves no longer a “Restoration Movement,” since they
claim to have restored the church already.
In
order to pursue their aim, they are compelled to interpret and
present the Christian religion in terms of externals. But an external
religion does not resolve religious problems because it misses the
heart of man. The use of such external emphases reflects an intention
to identify the church of Jesus Christ with external marks rather
than by the presence of the Spirit of Christ and the regeneration of
believers who exhibit the fruits of the Spirit. Man is not
transformed or nourished by outward marks, but by a personal
encounter and communion with God in Christ. Wherever this is possible
is the place to meet and to worship, to learn and to serve Christ.
But changing externals will not transform personality. “The dog
(remaining a dog) turns back to his own vomit, and the sow (remaining
a sow) is washed only to wallow in the mire” (2 Peter 2:22).
The cup and the platter are not cleansed by washing only the outside
(Matt. 23:25-26). Changing externals still leaves man’s heart
untouched, unchanged, unhealed, and unredeemed.
A
“Restorationism” which emphasizes externals as
identifying marks of the true church degenerates into sectarianism.
Alfred T. DeGroot, in his book, The
Restoration Principle, states:
“A cramped, or limited, or distorted estimate of the wholeness
of Christian faith and life produces a fellowship with the same
characteristics. Smug satisfaction with small success then inclines
to insulate the little community from the major concerns and currents
of life in the church as a whole. Failure to participate in the
throbbing processes of the larger body brings a pallor of sickness
and a withering of vitality to the degree of withdrawal” (p.
8).
“Restorationism”
ceases to be a movement when it separates itself from the
institutions and the society it seeks to restore. The vacuum created
by the exclusivism of the Churches of Christ leaves nothing to be
restored but themselves. A movement is a movement only so long as it
retains universality, flexibility, spontaneity, and openness. But
once it crystallizes or becomes stereotyped in an organization, in
its dogma, and in its separateness, it ceases to be a movement and
becomes narrow, sectarian, and arrogant.
The
result is that it comes to embody errors similar to those it proposed
to abolish. The “Restorationism” of the Churches of
Christ has not solved a single one of its major aims within its own
ranks! It is as badly divided and has as much disagreement as any
other denomination. A religious group that thinks it has “arrived”
is formalistic and legalistic; it can hardly avoid the concomitants
of such attitudes. More frequently than not, its fruits are revealed
as hypercriticism, arrogance, traditionalism, divisions, decline in
spirituality, legalism, formalism, authoritarianism,
uncharitableness, unethical treatment of those among its members who
disagree with its orthodoxy, and witch-hunting. Jesus, speaking of
the nature of such nonauthentic lives, said: “By their fruits
ye shall know them” (Matt. 7:16).
The
doctrines of the Churches of Christ are irrational. Their
“Restorationism” is self-contradictory. They claim that
they have achieved restoration of the true church while proposing to
restore it. They measure themselves by themselves. Their attitude is,
“If you doubt whether we are right, just ask us.” They
fail to distinguish means from ends. To them, everything is an end in
itself. By absolutizing means, the ultimacy of true ends is obscured
as well as the flexibility, temporality, and dispensability of means.
In
the name of freedom, they deprive others of freedom. In the name of
equality, they subordinate all to those who maintain “Restoration
policy” and reserve for these latter the honors. They
subordinate theological truth to atomistic conclusions drawn from
biased exegesis of passages relating to salvation, baptism,
communion, and the like. They ignore the biblical hierarchy of
values, giving equal value to all points. But their authoritarian
“blue-print” principle of the Bible is not carried out
consistently. They gloss over the Biblical teaching regarding women’s
hair, women’s silence, women’s veil, and women’s
subjection. They have no teaching regarding singing when sad or
alone, only when one is cheerful or worshipful (see James 5:13). They
ignore the Biblical examples and teaching regarding love feasts,
ordination of church officials, deaconesses, the holy kiss, the
orders of virgins and widows, wine in communion, church councils, the
examples of the one cup in communion, solo singing, and mutual
ministry. They are unwilling to follow Paul’s example of
religious fraternization with non-members for the sake of evangelism.
“Restorationism”
as advocated by the Churches of Christ is unhealthy. It assumes that
legalistic formalism will heal the sick in sin and the divisions
among believers. Many forms of neuroses and psychoses are treated as
sin. As a way of life, “Restorationism” is irrelevant to
man’s needs. Too many members of the Churches of Christ are
dogmatic, implacable, and sectarian. The consequences of these errors
are pride, anger, suspicion, smugness, bigotry, and uncharitableness.
Believers are encouraged to penalize one another for deviationism.
“Big brother” watches all the time. They consider all but
themselves non-Christian and compel even the most devout and godly
believer who joins their group either to be rebaptized or to confess
publicly that he has been living in sin! They try constantly to
proselyte believers from other denominations. But if it was wrong for
Roman Christians to rob pagan temples, what about Churches of Christ
robbing other Christian Churches? (Rom. 2:22b). I gladly admit that
these policies are repugnant to some individuals in the Churches of
Christ, but they are accepted and promoted by the generality.
There
are, certainly, some good features in “Restorationism” as
practiced by the Churches of Christ and I do not want to overlook
them. Many great souls in this denomination hold and practice the
highest ideals despite the system in which they are members. Here
follow some valid and commendable features professed by many in the
Churches of Christ and which are worthy of praise and encouragement:
With
respect to authority, they aim to subordinate all human authority,
tradition, and the church to the personal authority of Him to whom
the Bible bears trustworthy witness. They seek a valid and practical
interpretive principle and rightly uphold the superiority of the New
Testament over the Old. They seek a Biblical doctrine which is also
psychologically valid concerning conversion and initiation into
church membership. They contend for a complete obedience to the
divine will.
With
respect to Christ, they acknowledge Him as Son of God, Lord, and
Savior. They exalt Him as the only Head of the church in heaven and
on earth. He is presented as the perfect man, the Exemplar of the
good life. His atonement, resurrection, ascension, reign, and return
are all devoutly proclaimed.
With
respect to the church, they stress the factuality of its existence,
the definability of its identity, and its accessibility. They
underscore the importance of church membership. They emphasize
simplicity in organization and sincerity in worship. They profess
to
embrace all the redeemed as the body of Christ and are committed to
the universal mission of the church. They exhibit courage,
independence, and boldness in proclaiming their message.
With
respect to believers and unbelievers, they long for the unity of the
faith and the healing of divisions. Loyalty to the church is stressed
in every way and is practiced well by the membership. They contend
for the priesthood of believers as a valid ministry. And they
restrain by reason and self-control the extremes of emotionalism.
There
are, as must be obvious from this essay, suggestions for improvement
which I would make, hopeful that the good I have praised will be
increased and the evils I have enumerated may be diminished. Here are
some of them:
The
Churches of Christ should admit the reality of their denominational
status and humbly confess the possibility that they may be wrong in
belief and practice. They should stress the value of special training
for ministers, officers, and teachers, and reconsider the public
ordination of ministers, elders, deacons, and deaconesses as the
Bible teaches. They should practice comity with other believers in
meaningful ways and acknowledge them as brethren with real
contributions to make toward unity.
They
should cultivate existing unities and discuss the real
issues
rather than continue to waste time on peripheral matters. They should
exalt the Lordship of Christ even above the Bible and the church, and
learn to enjoy the freedom of the Spirit in Christian life. They
should surrender and renounce the “blueprint” concept of
the Bible. They should discover the unity of the Bible, its scale of
values, its principles, and its subordination to the Lord Jesus
Christ.
They
should eliminate all sectarian barriers to fellowship, such as their
opposition to instrumental music in worship, contention for one
pattern of church government, communion only on Sunday, and salvation
by baptism. The scholarship of the world does not support these
views.
They
should revitalize the worship by practicing the Presence of God. In
many Churches of Christ, worship is not a moving experience.
Communion is too much of a mere formality because it is considered
little more than a memorial. A real sense that Christ is living and
present at the table would bring warmth to their devotions.
They
should make the gospel Christ-centered as it was meant to be, rather
than baptism-or-church centered. Neither baptism nor the church is
primarily gospel. They should be willing to let consensus of rational
opinion of all Christian scholars of whatever church and age be the
decisive factor in matters of interpreting the Bible. And, finally,
they should review and correct their conception of what needs
restoration.
I
do not know how soon these problems may be solved, but I found that
for my own ministry it would not be possible to wait longer. I left
the Churches of Christ because freedom and opportunity to speak
became too restricted and because I believe these churches are in the
unrelenting grip of false conceptions and purposes. I left because I
believe they have drawn lines of fellowship contrary to the New
Testament, because they have destroyed hope of achieving through
their system the unity Christ wanted, and because they repudiate the
conclusions of the best scholarship in the world. I left because I
believe they have emptied worship of its spiritual depth and mystery
and because the personality of Christ is not for them the reigning
motif of their church life, worship, faith, and work. I left,
finally, because the effect of their doctrines is to make one much
more vulnerable to those human weaknesses which lead to pride,
hostile feelings toward others, an uncharitable and unforgiving
spirit, social incompatibility, factions, implacability, ethical
weaknesses, and anxiety.
Let
me assert firmly, however, that I love the people in the Churches of
Christ. I wish them only good. I bear them witness that they have a
fervent zeal, although I cannot believe that it is according to the
truth as it is in Christ. They have a form of godliness, but they
deny its power in human life by stressing the form rather than the
godliness. They are diligent, aggressive, intelligent,
self-sacrificing, and persistent in their beliefs and works. I take
no satisfaction from pointing out their errors. My heart is heavy
because of my separation from many dear friends. I must say, too,
that the criticisms I have written are not true of all the members of
the Churches of Christ. There are many who agree with my views even
if they cannot imitate my action.
It
is the system, really, which most concerns me. There are thousands of
good Christian men and women in the Churches of Christ who could do
much to improve the situation by being true in word, attitude, and
deed to the mind and spirit of Christ. My prayer is that we shall all
grow more like our Savior, knowing that as we make this progress our
paths will merge somewhere, sometime, somehow, in a deeper and more
loving fellowship in Christ. My fervent prayer is that constructive
changes will take place in the doctrines and attitudes held by
members of the Churches of Christ that will reduce the unhappiness
many experience as a consequence of them, and that the width of the
chasm which separates them from other believers will be bridged over
by love. understanding, and a meaningful exchange of ideas.
Meanwhile,
dear reader, please believe that I have not spoken in anger or
bitterness, and that I have not desired to make anyone angry. Just as
you must do what your conscience in Christ leads you to do, so must
I. I will close with an ascription of praise to Christ which is the
will and sentiment of my own best self, and with a quotation
describing His final victory, for which I work and hope:
“Worthy
is the Lamb who was slain, to receive power and wealth and wisdom and
might and honor and glory and blessing!” (Rev. 5:12)
“The kingdom of this world has become the kingdom of our Lord and of his Christ, and he shall reign for ever and ever.” (Rev. 11:15).