CECIL L. FRANKLIN, who became Rector of the Church of Christ the King (Episcopal) in Arvada, Colorado in 1960, was born in 1927. His father was a Disciples of Christ minister who later became a minister of the Church of Christ. Mr. Franklin attended Abilene Christian College as a ministerial student in 1943-45 and received the A.B. degree from Phillips University in 1947. He attended Harvard Divinity School and received the degrees of S.T.B. (1950), S.T.M. (1951), and Ph.D. (1961). He was ordained a priest in the Episcopal Church in 1957. He has been active in writing religious materials, in social services, and on a wide variety of church and civic committees. Currently he is a Lecturer in Bible and Religion at Monmouth College (Illinois).


WIDER HORIZONS

By Cecil L. Franklin

It is with a large measure of reluctance that I have been persuaded that my contributing to a collection of critical essays about the Church of Christ might serve a useful purpose. There are several reasons for my reluctance. It was in the Church of Christ that I first was taught the Christian faith, was baptized, was nourished in Christian teaching and behavior. It is mere decency to hesitate to join in a criticism, no matter how well-intentioned, of a church from which one has received so much. Furthermore, I have friends who are faithful and loyal members of the Church of Christ. I should not like in any way to offend or alienate them. I can only ask the reader to believe that I have no consciousness of any present hostility against either the Church of Christ or any of its members.

**********

A biographical note will provide a useful and necessary background for what I have to say. My father was a minister of the Church of Christ, having entered that church from the ministry of the Christian Church (Disciples of Christ) when I was a small child. During my senior year in high school, I became convinced that I, too, ought to devote myself to the ministry.

I entered Abilene Christian College in 1943, at the age of sixteen. I left in 1945, having, for all practical purposes, lost my “fundamentalist” 1 belief, and with it all that I cared to call Christian faith. At that time, I did also acquire some degree of hostility and bitterness towards the Church of Christ and some of its members.

Here, I think I must interject a reflection that comes from later years. It is my opinion that at that point in my adolescence I would probably have rejected any religious view with which I had been brought up. This appears to be, for many people, a part of the psychology of that stage of development. It is possible that if my associates during that period had been more understanding of that psychology, there would have been less of hostility and bitterness. But I believe that neither the faith itself nor anyone connected with the church was in any appreciable degree responsible for my rejection of fundamentalist Christian belief. The fact of my rejection of the Church of Christ at that point in my development is not so significant, in my opinion, as the fact that, at a later point, return to the Church of Christ was not something that I was able to consider as a live option.

My situation during that period was not comfortable. On the one hand, I felt almost a glee in emancipation. But I did not know quite who I was or where I belonged. Most of my friends were members of the Church of Christ, many of them studying for its ministry, and I did not have the feeling of personal security to enable me to speak freely of my doubts and growing disbeliefs. Furthermore, to do so would usually have been interpreted in terms of personal hostility. It was all somewhat tentative, but I was coming to the opinion that I could no longer be a member, let alone a minister, of the Church of Christ. Yet I knew that study of religion was the one thing that interested me most, so I continued to pursue it, not knowing where it might lead me.

My next two years of college, in Phillips University, were not very happy. Though the conservatism there was not so extreme as at ACC, it was sufficient to make me feel not-at-home, and to cause me to be far less than candid in the expression of ideas.

Only when I went to Harvard Divinity School in 1947 did I feel quite free to express myself, and to pursue my studies in the way I wanted. I reveled in the “liberalism” and “modernism” which then (more, I think, than now) characterized the school. I felt myself drawn to Unitarianism, a religion in which my beliefs—or lack of them—were easily tolerated. For a few years I felt largely comfortable in the Unitarian context, though I never actually joined the Unitarian Church.

Slowly, however, there began to grow in me a conviction that Unitarianism was inadequate. I yearned to believe the Christian faith. Intellectually, and perhaps also emotionally, I could not accept the fundamentalism which I had been taught in my childhood; yet it was very difficult for me to separate the Christian faith from fundamentalism. When I was finally able to do this, I was also able once again to examine the Christian faith. As a result of this re-examination, I became a member, and subsequently a priest, of the Episcopal Church.

I believe that I can make my contribution to this collection of essays most effectively not by pointing at things in the Church of Christ which I believe to be wrong, and saying why I think so, but rather by suggesting something in the way of broader vistas and wider horizons which I believe would contribute significantly and fruitfully to thinking within the Church of Christ.

1. The first of these has to do with reverence for truth. This is something in behalf of which virtually all men would make protestations. We all believe that truth is to be preferred over error. And yet we sometimes become peculiarly defensive about the truth, as though it were intrinsically stronger than error.

I am not here about to propose some kind of liberalism that teaches that we should, within the Church, permit every opinion which someone holds to be truth. Once I might have done that, but not now. The Church is a community of faith, not a debating society.

I do, however, modestly suggest that our attitudes towards people who sincerely disagree with us on what the truth is, sometimes partake of a personal hostility that is both irrelevant and un-Christian.

Although we believe that truth is real and absolute, we recognize that the minds of men are finite and fallible. Of course, we recognize this about the minds of other men more readily than we recognize it about our own. But even when we are able in some degree to recognize it about our own minds, we have the conviction that we must pursue and proclaim truth as best we can with such finite minds as God gave us. What we must also recognize is that every other man must also do the same. We know, from observing others, that it is possible for other men to arrive at a position (though erroneous to us) which is the conclusion of their thinking and the criterion for all truth thereafter. We must learn that this is possible also for us.

What, then? Must we give up our convictions? Must there be a diffident and qualified tentativeness about all that we believe and say? Not at all. As Christians, we must have a firm faith, and must proclaim it firmly. But at the same time, we must in humility recognize our own fallibility, and re-examine our understanding of that faith from time to time. We must also recognize the full sincerity of people who disagree with us. We must, in brief, take seriously the motto that ends, “and in all things, Charity.”

2. The second point is closely related to the first. Most people recognize, upon reflection, that it is possible for two persons who are equal in intelligence and sincerity to arrive at diametrically opposite conclusions about something. This reality causes a problem for many who would like to think that if a person is reasonably intelligent, and genuinely sincere, he can infallibly arrive at the truth, or at least at any really important truth. But it is only a person who has isolated his mind that is able to believe this with confidence. For we readily find people whose intelligence and sincerity we cannot easily doubt, who believe things that are very far from the truth as we understand it. Surely the type of mentality that assumes that all disagreement with truth as one understands it is due to deliberate, wilful and sinful insincerity is the epitome of sectarianism.

This is a threatening idea, for it suggests the possibility—however remote we may deem it—that we ourselves are in error, and no matter how hard we try, cannot arrive at the truth. This idea destroys the security which we would like to get from our firm conviction. But perhaps that security ought to be destroyed, because it is a security that attaches to intellectual propositions. Our true security ought to be in God Himself, rather than in intellectual propositions about Him. But here, we find ourselves further entangled in the difficulty that we can think of God only through intellectual propositions: that He is, and that He is supremely good, and holy, and just. This entanglement is one of the conditions of our creaturely finitude. We have no right to expect the security that God Himself has. We can seek security only in Him, with childlike trust.

But again, the question arises, if our convictions are such as to be subject to conditions and qualifications, whether we can firmly hold and proclaim them. If they are the result of the best and most sincere thought we can give them, we cannot abstain from holding and proclaiming them. But we must do so in the knowledge that God Himself is inconceivably greater than any convictions about Him that we can hold. This knowledge will help us to govern our relations with our finite fellow-creatures.

3. The third point I want to make concerns the fact that there are many millions of people who profess and call themselves Christians. Many of them are persons who, with great piety and devotion, offer themselves to God through Christ in worship, both in the congregation of fellow-believers and in the secrecy of their closets. They read their Bibles regularly with all the intelligence and devotion that they can muster. They partake in the supper of the Lord with regularity and frequency. In their daily lives, they try to follow Christ, and, as members of His Body, to give themselves as instruments of His will. For their hope of everlasting life in the presence of God, they trust, not in their own works, but in the merits of Christ, who died for them.

But the people who believe in Christ and try to follow and obey Him are divided. This ought to be a source of deep sorrow to every Christian. Christ prayed that His disciples should be one, but they are separated from one another. The apostle Paul proclaimed that there is one body, but that body is tragically broken.

Some people are able to calm their minds about this in an easy way: “We are right. Therefore, Christian unity can be achieved if the others will join themselves to us.” This is an attitude which, until recently, has characterized the Roman Catholic Church, though there is some evidence that there may be a beginning of change in this. It is an easy way that can be adopted only by what is essentially a sectarian mentality which refuses to take seriously and attempt to understand a different belief.

Certainly, we cannot say that all the things that divide people who call themselves Christians are unimportant. There are deep and important convictions that divide Christians, and if we take Christianity seriously, these divisions cannot be done away with at once. But also if we take Christianity seriously, we cannot rest comfortably in our sectarian security, untroubled by the divisions which separate us. On the contrary, we must take one another seriously, and take one another’s convictions seriously, fervently praying that the Spirit of God will further enlighten us all, and draw us closer together, and in His time reunite us.

4. Not only is Christianity far vaster than the particular brotherhood of Christians to which you, or I, belong; it is also vaster historically than our generation, or than the history of America, or than the history of England. Ever since that Day of Pentecost after Christ’s ascension, the day on which the Spirit of God fell on the disciples as a divine enthusiasm, there has been a great company of men and women calling themselves Christians and devoutly trying to follow Him. Of course, some Christians have made bad mistakes. Some men who pretended to follow Christ were scoundrels, and some of them got into positions of prominence and leadership in the Church. There have been tares among the wheat. And even some of Christ’s faithful sheep have sometimes been misled. Yet we have His promise that His Spirit will continue to guide His Church, even though the members of that Church appear not always to have heeded and followed His guidance.

But sectarianism obscures the fullness of that history. In some circles, one gets the impression that there is a long, dark tunnel between the times of the apostles and of Martin Luther; in others, that the tunnel extends still further, to the times of Alexander Campbell. In yet others, one might get the impression that the track ran straight from Jerusalem to Rome, and stopped there; or to Constantinople, and perhaps to Moscow. But the fact is that the history of Christ’s Church is far vaster than any of these sectarian views would suggest. Even Canterbury is not the end of the line!

We, then, are the heirs of almost two thousand years of Christian history, in many countries, among peoples of many tongues and races. We are the heirs of their insights into the truth of God in Christ, of their piety and devotion to God through Christ, and also, alas, of their mistakes and errors. To cut ourselves off from any of this heritage is to impoverish ourselves.

5. Not the least of the achievements of these centuries of Christianity is the development and systematic formulation of Christian belief. Some of the results of that process are sometimes taken for granted by Christians, without their realizing that they came about in the course of Christian history. Most notable of these is the New Testament itself. The books of the New Testament were all written in the very early period of Christianity. But they were not all immediately accepted as Scripture. Nor are they the only early Christian writings that were sometimes accepted as Scripture. Indeed, it is not until the fourth century of the Christian era that we find a list of books identical with the list that finally came to be accepted among Christians as the books of the New Testament. It is thus due to the sifting process of several generations of Christians that we have the New Testament in its present form.

Many theological doctrines which some Christians take for granted are likewise the end-product of a process of devoted Christian thought in the light of the Scriptures: the Trinity, the Incarnation of God in Christ, the atonement, etc. Many of the same problems have been present to every generation of Christians. Many of the same questions have been asked by members of every generation of Christians.

Certainly, there is no other area of study in which one would presume to start from scratch without learning of the history of that study. For example, one would hardly try to find truth in physics or psychology without learning what preceding physicists and psychologists have learned and believed. Similarly, it behooves one who wishes to learn the truth of God in Christ to study what earlier Christians have learned and believed. We do not stand alone. We are members of a great procession, marching through the centuries.

6. The Bible has always been, and must always be, central in the thinking of Christians. It tells us all that we know about that great central event of human history: God’s sending His Son to earth to become man and to die and rise for mankind’s sake. But we ought never to assume that we know every thing of importance that can be learned about the Bible, nor to close our eyes to new methods of approach to it. An unwillingness to consider new ideas about the Bible may be related to a desire to defend the truth against falsehoods. But we ought to examine carefully whether we are really defending the truth itself, or rather defending ourselves against the hard and uncertain work of seeking the truth with the energy which it deserves.

During the past few generations, new developments in historical and literary research have thrown new light on the probable historical origins and backgrounds of the Bible. We must be willing to examine these developments fairly, and ask, not whether they support what we have been accustomed to believe, but rather whether or not they are probably true. It is hard to suppose that we can be genuine disciples of Him who is the Truth at the same time that we defensively protect ourselves from what are claimed to be new discoveries of fact. That is not to say, of course, that we ought uncritically to accept every new theory that is proposed. An idea is not by any means more likely to be true simply because it is new. Quite to the contrary, we ought to move slowly. But we ought to move; we cannot ignore the newer researches.

Virtually all who call themselves Christians attribute authority to the Bible and call it the inspired word of God. But these words are subject to a number of interpretations. It is necessary for us conscientiously to re-examine periodically just what they ought to mean. I believe that several centuries ago, when it began to be suggested that the earth moves around the sun, one Christian theologian repudiated that notion, quoting some such passage as Psalm 93:1, “the world also is stablished, that it cannot be moved.” None of us today would use that as a reason for rejecting this commonly held astronomical belief. Nor do we suppose that this idea destroys the authority and inspiration of the Bible. But we concede that it gives us a clue for defining a little more accurately what we mean by authority and inspiration.

Important researches are continuing in the area of study that is called “Biblical theology.” Many scholars are contributing to this study, on the basis of presuppositions which do attribute authority and inspiration to the Bible, not in terms of the idea of infallibility, but rather in terms of seeing the Bible as consisting of the basic data for understanding the work of God among his people, and especially of that central work, the incarnation in Christ. If we cut ourselves off from this new learning, again we impoverish ourselves.

7. My last point concerns the relation between the Church and the world. Sometimes we become so involved in our own narrow concerns that we act as though the world existed for the sake of the Church, whereas in reality the Church exists for the sake of the world. God became man in Christ for the sake of world, because He loved the world so much. When we cease to think of the Church as existing for the world, we lose our entire perspective.

What can and ought the Church to do for the world? What can and ought the individual Christian, as a member of Christ’s body, to do for the world? This can be answered in many ways. One might point to the works of mercy enumerated in the parable of judgment: feeding the hungry, giving drink to the thirsty, welcoming the stranger, clothing the naked, visiting the sick, going to the prisoner. This is at the center of what once made the “social gospel” so popular in certain circles. That movement sometimes took on utopian overtones. But the excesses which may be connected with that do not diminish our social responsibility in the social context in which we find ourselves.

The Christian, loving the world because God loves it, must concern himself with the problems of the world, both on a large scale-problems of war and peace, of poverty and famine, of overpopulation, of national and racial hostilities—and on the most local scale—the Negroes or Mexicans in our town who are not getting a fair shake; the people who are unskilled and untrained in habits of thrift and enterprise, and cannot get a job; the people whose married life is so fouled up that there appears no way out of the mess; the people who are burdened with the disease of alcoholism and are unable even to recognize their problem, let alone remedy it; and the people in the next block who are lonely, aimless, and lost. It was to such as these that Christ Himself ministered as He had opportunity; it is to such as these that the body of Christ must minister today, as its members are able.

**********

I cannot close without a further personal word. Some of what I have written could be interpreted as coming from one who considers himself intellectually or morally superior to his readers. I suppose this is the perpetual danger for a preacher. Like most people, I preach better than I practice. Probably like most preachers, I rarely preach without the gnawing consciousness that I could be a better Christian if I would yield my life more fully to God’s grace. What I have written, I have written in love and sincerity, and I can only hope that it will be read in the same way.

______________________

1 I am not sure whether this term is honored as much within the Church of Christ now as it was then. I know that in some circles the term “conservative evangelical” is now preferred. Even at that time it did not mean precisely what it had originally meant. in terms of the set of books, The Fundamentals, published in 1910. In this essay, I use the term chiefly to denote the point of view which holds firmly to Biblical inerrancy, and rejects the historico-literary approach to the Bible which has the unfortunate name of “higher criticism.”