|
CHARLES E. WARREN was born in Rogers, Arkansas, and
grew up in Paducah, Kentucky. Since his family were all of Church of
Christ background, he entered David Lipscomb College in 1947. In the
winter of 1949, he left to serve the Valparaiso, Indiana Church of
Christ. While there, he completed his B.A. degree at Valparaiso
University in 1952 and in the fall of that year entered McCormick
Theological Seminary in Chicago.
After
a year at McCormick, Mr. Warren gave up efforts to maintain a
relationship with Churches of Christ and served for two years as
assistant minister in Faith Presbyterian Church in Chicago. Upon
graduation from Seminary in 1955, he became minister of the First
Christian Church at Deer Lodge, Montana. In 1957, he accepted a call
to the Englewood Christian Church, Portland, Oregon.
Mr. Warren is now serving as associate minister of the Gordon Street Christian Church in Kinston, North Carolina, having gone there in 1961. This church is fully cooperative in the Disciples of Christ brotherhood and associates itself with the National and World Council of Churches. |
NO
CREED BUT CHRIST?
By
Charles E. Warren
It
is quite a challenge to retrace one’s spiritual and mental
travels, especially if one feels that he has come a long distance
from where he once was. The intention of this essay is to state some
of the ways in which I still feel some kinship of life and thought
with my early background, but primarily to relate the ways in which I
now feel removed from it.
It
may be well to state that I did not originally wish to leave the
Church of Christ. Outward and inward pressures compelled me. There is
a saying in the Restoration movement: “We have no creed but
Christ.” This certainly seems to be a wonderful emphasis on
unity of faith and love, while at the same time leaving plenty of
room for variety and difference of thought. But in my experience in
the Church of Christ, the slogan did not work out that way.
After
a short tour of duty in the Air Force in World War II, I realized
that I had confronted a larger world than I had known before. As I
began college I found myself wrestling with some new-found ideas in
psychology and philosophy. A questioning mood possessed me. I recall
a day in the Church of Christ college I attended when I heard with
some shock a conversation between a teacher and a student. In their
talk they were agreeing that things of the Bible and of our faith
should simply be accepted and taken at face value without any
questions or theories about underlying reasons. I interrupted them
with the remark, “I believe a person should
ask
questions, and should
seek
underlying reasons.” The teacher cut me down with a blunt ex
cathedra utterance:
“The secret things belong to the Lord our God; but the things
that are revealed belong to us …” (Deut. 29:29). He
seemed to think it rebellious and sinful to have a curious mind, to
ask questions, and to seek more adequate understandings. But I kept
asking myself if it were not part of every free man’s dignity
to seek truth wherever it led without fear and intimidation.
The
writings of men like Darwin and Freud unsettled me. One Church of
Christ philosophy teacher did a great deal to help me struggle
meaningfully and constructively with the theory of evolution, but
none helped me struggle meaningfully with Freud. In fact, the whole
world of clinical and therapeutic psychology seemed taboo.
A
brother of mine, serving at that time as a minister in the Church of
Christ, became embroiled in a conflict over some broader attitudes
and ideas which he had come to hold. I loved him, but I was not able
to accept all aspects of his thinking at the time. So I sought to
discuss some of the ideas he was wrestling with, hoping that teachers
and others in the Church of Christ could help me put them in proper
perspective. I wanted to remain in that particular fellowship.
I
found no one with the willingness (or perhaps with the religious
perspective) to help me with this personal crisis. Outwardly some
were very kind and showed good will toward me. But nearly all seemed
to have some fear of me and of the situation I was in. This
contrasted sharply with the attitude of Jesus, who showed no fear of
the troubled nor any reluctance to go near those in crisis. I would
today consider myself disloyal to Christ if fear kept me from drawing
near and helping with all the grace and wisdom in me any man caught
up in trouble or crisis.
I
left the Church of Christ college before I graduated and moved to
northern Indiana to preach for a small Church of Christ congregation
and to finish my college work. In a Missouri Synod Lutheran liberal
arts college a whole new religious perspective began to grow in me.
Teachers who took differing views from my own, which were still loyal
to the Church of Christ interpretations, opened up for me the reality
of the grace and love of God. Much of the Bible that had been
meaningless to me before came alive. Yet here were teachers who,
according to my belief, were outside the pale.
The
mental conflict was intense. I had to know what to do about teachers
who had revealed to me so much more about the Christ than had those
of my own party.
So
it began to come to me that a true, personal laying hold of the grace
of God in Christ is more important than correct outward observances.
I came to know that it is much better to have personal grace and
goodwill toward others and be wrong about facts and externals, than
to be perfectly right about facts and externals without any personal
grace and love. “The code killeth, but the Spirit makes alive.”
My
growing insistence within the Church of Christ was not that externals
were to be changed, but that a new attitude and spirit must be
breathed into their way of thought, life, and worship. I still very
much wanted to stay within the Church of Christ tradition of
simplicity of worship, adult immersion, weekly observance of the
Lord’s Supper, and use of the Bible as the basis for preaching
and Christian living. But it seemed increasingly clear to me that
members of the Church of Christ were making themselves out to be the
only Christians. I felt that a return to the saying, “We are
not trying to be the only Christians, but Christians only,” was
urgently in order. After all, I had already found Christians outside
the Churches of Christ who had taught me more of Him than those
inside. And I had been taught from youth up that Christ was the only
proper creed, not some unwritten tradition of a religious party.
After
finishing college I moved to Chicago to attend a Presbyterian
seminary (reflecting, meanwhile, that all the founding fathers of our
Restoration movement had Presbyterian educations!). I preached for
Churches of Christ for about another year before leaving their ranks.
My brother had written an essay called “The Heresy of
Legalism,” which had offended many leaders and members in the
Church of Christ. I was soon to realize what this meant. I preached
for a few Sundays in a Church of Christ north of Chicago; the
membership was gracious enough to call my preaching helpful and
Biblical. But another preacher, eager to purge the church of any who
might be tainted, came along and explained to these good people who
my brother was. That slammed the door in my face.
I
was hurt by this growing exclusivism on the part of the Church of
Christ. I had no creed but Christ; I was using no book but the Bible.
For a movement that claimed to have no written creeds, it seemed to
me that the Church of Christ had an amazingly potent unwritten creed
and anyone who dared deviate from it was in dire trouble. For all
practical purposes my association with Churches of Christ was ended.
The
last two years of seminary I worked part-time with a Presbyterian
church in Chicago. One may wonder why I did not stay with that group.
The simple reason is that I could not bring myself to give up
immersion and weekly observance of the Lord’s Supper. These
things, however, I saw in a different light than did most members of
the Church of Christ. It seemed to me that the Churches of Christ had
made adult immersion merely an arbitrary command of Christ’s,
to be conformed to or else. Little or no emphasis was given to
baptism as a personal response to Him, an acceptance of God’s
free grace and love, and a total commitment to live according to the
Spirit and teachings of Christ in all that one did. Church of Christ
baptism seemed to take seriously neither the free and abounding grace
and love of God, nor the radical nature of becoming totally
responsive to the Spirit and will of Christ. Baptism itself seemed to
constitute the obedience, rather than serving as the symbol of a
commitment to be Christ-like in all things.
To
illustrate how baptism seemed to be put in false perspective, I
recall studying carefully the first five verses of John 10. How often
I had heard these verses used to prove that if anyone tried to get
into the Kingdom of God without believer’s immersion he was
both a thief and a robber. But it became clear after more careful
study that Jesus was speaking of his own credentials as Christ and
Savior. He was also speaking of the personal recognition that will
cause people to become his followers. This discovery shocked me,
slight as it may seem, and opened a vista before me of how strongly
external acts and laws were put before a personal confrontation with
Christ in the church I had served. Believer’s immersion became
much more significant to me, but in a totally different light from
that in which most Church of Christ members see it. In somewhat the
same way the Lord’sSupper seemed to be observed as an arbitrary
command of Christ without being seen as symbolical of one’s
continual participation in Christ and the Christian fellowship, as a
way of keeping in touch with God’s Spirit in Christ, and as a
way of drawing strength from other committed Christian souls. From
Acts 20:7 it seemed clear that the Christians gathered for the
express purpose of participating in the Lord’s Supper. I felt
that the Supper, then, should be the center and high light of Lord’s
Day worship. But in the Church of Christ the sermon got the lion’s
share of time and emphasis, while the Lord’s Supper was handled
routinely and briefly. I felt that this gave scant attention to our
need for continual participation in Christ through the Spirit, and to
our need for continual participation in the company of those
committed to Him.
Again,
the tendency of Churches of Christ to identify the Holy Spirit with
the written words of the Bible revealed a deistic bias. Eighteenth
and nineteenth century deism thought of God as creator of the world,
but as one who had set it going and then left it to be governed
solely by natural, scientific, and moral laws. Like a railroad
engineer he had set the controls on the engine, then jumped off to
let the train run along the tracks by itself. But the Bible seemed to
me to teach that God was always active and working in His world
through the Spirit, that Christ had promised the Spirit to His
followers, and that we should not think of God as limited by any
so-called natural, scientific, or moral laws. Certainly the science
and philosophy of the twentieth century have called into question the
dated eighteenth and nineteenth century concepts of “law.”
It seemed to me, therefore, that the Church of Christ attitude toward
the Holy Spirit seemed to be of the nineteenth century rather than of
the first century.
While
deeply appreciating much about the Presbyterian church, I decided to
become a Disciple of Christ (Christian Church). As stated earlier,
this was due to my convictions about baptism and the Lord’s
Supper. A good friend of mine in seminary asked me once who the
Churches of Christ were. I answered, facetiously, “Non-fiddlin’
Campbellites.” He laughed and wanted to know something about
the Campbells. Later, when I decided to become a Disciple, he wanted
to know who they were. I answered, “Fiddlin’
Campbellites.” This oversimplification at least serves to bring
up the question of proper music in worship, a matter of great urgency
in the split between Christian Churches and Churches of Christ.
The
first Christian church I served was in Montana and it was this church
which ordained me as a minister. On the afternoon of the ordination
service a thunderstorm knocked out the electricity so that the organ
would not play. When the service was over a good friend of mine, a
minister who was also of Church of Christ background previously,
joked: “The Lord was giving you that last warning about the
organ, Charley.” I laughed, but I knew that to members of the
Churches of Christ this was serious business.
A
cappella
singing can be moving and beautiful. It is also true that an organist
or pianist who knows what he is doing can bring some excellent
singing out of a congregation. To me the question of instrumental
accompaniment to singing is of minor importance. Through the beauty
of a building, or of words, or of various material objects, all
churches seek to add beauty and dignity to their worship.
“
My most serious quarrel with the Church of Christ emphasis is that it
often separates faith and life, putting religion in its proper
pigeonhole and secularizing the rest of life. This is well
illustrated in the matter of music. In my home we often sang hymns
around the piano with my mother playing. This was a memorable worship
period for me. I recall reading an argument by some Church of Christ
ministers on the matter of whether it is sinful to play religious
hymns on instruments outside the formal church worship. One of them
seemed to cinch the argument to his satisfaction by explaining that
singing hymns to instruments outside
the
church worship was practice, and therefore not intended for worship.
In this way, he said, it was not sinful.
But
Jesus said that where two or three are gathered together in His name
there He would be with them. If three or four of us around the family
piano forgot that we were merely practicing, if we fell into the
spirit of what we were singing, and if we reverently used Christ’s
name, did that mean we had suddenly begun to sin? Is the only true
church that which meets for formal worship in the church building?
Where persons live in reverence and in the Spirit of Christ in the
home, is this not also a church?
If
one attends a concert or a symphony and the beauty of the music leads
him to deep reverence before God’s work in His creation, is
this not worship? Is it at the same time sin? Is the religious only
that which takes place within the confines of the formal worship
service? Is the temple of God really a building?
Or
is it the totality of one’s life, inseparable from all one
does? Churches of Christ often permit instrumental music in a wedding
ceremony. Are not these vows of fidelity and these prayers for God’s
blessing in one of life’s most important relationships an act
of worship? Does the music turn this worshipful attitude into sin?
Surely the genuinely religious is more than a fragment of one’s
life and includes far more than he does in the formal worship
service.
Then
there is the matter of church government. I remember a situation in
the Church of Christ once when it was suggested that the members of
the group should vote on certain issues and not just follow the will
of the elders. Some prominent ministers in the group protested with
indignation that the church is a kingdom, not a democracy. They
appeared to me to be arguing the “divine right” of
elders. I am ordained, and the elders of the church I now serve are
ordained, but none of us would get far arguing “divine right”
to our membership. I have long felt that elders must justify their
leadership directly to the congregation; in the Churches of Christ I
knew they seemed to be a self-perpetuating body of leaders who would
not let their minister share the fruits of his studies, but who
refused to study seriously and deeply themselves. It may be that such
an eldership is the most urgent problem for the Churches of Christ
today.
In
another area of government, Churches of Christ claim autonomy for
each congregation. In the Christian churches I now serve we have
state societies and a national convention, plus other agencies
through which we cooperate to do much work. It does not seem to me
that one finds any uniform or fully developed method in the New
Testament for church organization.
There
are references made to the church in a certain city. Does this mean
that there was just one congregation in that city, or did a number of
different home congregations make up the church in that city with one
group of elders? I really do not know. Certainly there were many
apostles and evangelists traveling from church to church, exerting
influence on many different persons and serving as agents for
missionary and benevolent work. The early churches did not live alone
without being influenced by other churches, and they joined together
in many cooperative enterprises.
Pure
local autonomy is probably something that never really exists. No
person or group lives totally apart from others. In the Churches of
Christ it seemed to me that college presidents, teachers, and editors
were centers of influence and authority. To cross or to ignore some
of these leaders was to put one’s standing in grave peril. I
must say that I have seen no leader in the Christian churches wield
such immense personal power as I have seen editors, college
presidents, and teachers wield in the Churches of Christ. As a
minister in the Christian churches I feel quite free, though at the
same time responsible to the church I serve and to our brotherhood at
large. I really do not know what a perfectly Biblical organization
would be. Whatever it is, I am positive that only the Christ can
claim “divine rights” to rule.
And
there is the Church of Christ’s attitude toward the Bible
itself. For me, this book is simply an accurate record of God’s
revelation of Himself to man, culminating in His final and complete
revelation through Christ and the first apostles and Christians. The
Bible is not a revelation of mathematical, scientific, or purely
rational truth. It was written out of the background of the world
views of the times of the writers and it is colored by the situation
and temperament of each one of them. It was written in the language
of the time and in terms of the thought patterns of the time;
otherwise its message would have been gibberish and no revelation at
all. To try to prove the Bible to be a collection of mathematical or
scientific truths is a hopeless endeavor. Yet the Churches of Christ
feel compelled to do this, no matter how literally and woodenly they
must read some parts of the Old Testament in order to do so.
I
felt that Church of Christ folk unnecessarily fear scholarly study of
the Bible. They are afraid that acknowledgment of the contributions
of historical, linguistic, and archaeological students will somehow
weaken the power of its message. They are often frightened by study
of the Bible which treats it as, among other things, a collection of
various kinds of literature. My own feeling is that the Bible
contains self-authenticating truth, carries immense authority within
itself, and will lead us to God. But I do not fear to examine it
carefully and to accept a great many of the findings of dedicated men
who have pondered its nature for their entire lifetimes. I fear that
the Church of Christ tends to worship the book, rather than the
Savior; to become bibliolaters, rather than adorers of Christ. This
makes their study of the Bible rather inflexible and leads them into
some curious situations.
I
want to mention briefly the ecumenical movement and the attitude of
Churches of Christ toward it. Like any group claiming to be the only
true church, the Church of Christ feels that any significant
involvement with other churches is a dangerous compromise. They do
not allow their ministers to join ministerial alliances for this
reason. But I cannot see this quest for Christian unity in our time
as an exercise in compromise. Each church is expected to bring into
the quest the strength of its own convictions. Real unity will exist,
but it will be unity in diversity—a very real kind of unity
despite those who believe that only in conformity can there be such
harmony. I deplore the unwillingness of the Church of Christ to join
in this enterprise. In the face of threats from communism, from
nationalistic religions, and from mushrooming materialism and
secularism, it is imperative that churches seek unity in Christ so
that their witness may be strong. Denominational separateness is an
expense we can no longer afford.
The
ecumenical movement is not really an effort to build a super church.
I remember that in Churches of Christ I often heard that it was wrong
to belong to a church that one did not have
to
belong to in order to be saved. In other words, there was no
justification for any church if it were not the only
true church.
There is little room for freedom and diversity of opinion in such a
position, of course. But this always seemed to me like saying that if
my home were not the only home where true grace, love, and
responsibility reigned, then I should not be a part of it. Homes do
differ widely and we treasure the differences; so churches may keep
their freedom and individuality without becoming sectarian and
divisive. There are many ways in which differing denominations can
work together in labors of love without conflicts over theology.
I
have been startled in recent years about another matter: the deep
involvement many in the Church of Christ have with certain social and
political concerns. The identification of the Christian faith with
radically conservative views in politics seems to me a distortion of
the best in the Church of Christ tradition. As I always understood
this tradition, the church was to maintain some detachment from such
matters. This did not mean that one’s faith did not have
meaning and implications in such areas, but there was no effort to
describe a “Christian position” in social matters and in
politics.
It
would certainly be tragic if persons became members of certain
churches because of positions these churches take on social and
political matters, rather than because of the churches’ ability
to lead them to firm faith in God and discipleship to Jesus Christ.
There should be room in all churches for responsible conservatives
and responsible liberals, both of whom see in God and in His Christ a
deep and powerful basis for unity. With such a viewpoint they can be
free to hold differing judgments as to how good is best realized in
this life, while at the same time respecting one another.
I
must say before closing that I have deep respect for the zeal and
concern of many members of the Church of Christ. Paul Tillich has
defined faith as “ultimate concern.” Certainly Church of
Christ folk have such strong concern. Disciples of Christ could use
more of it. As this essay has indicated, I suspect that the object
of
Church of Christ concern is all too often a God of legalism rather
than a God of love and eternal hope; but if their great zeal could be
fused with the spirit and greater universality of some other kinds of
Christians, it would be a happy and useful marriage.
This short essay is simply the way one man sees his past involvement in the Churches of Christ from the viewpoint of his present commitment to the Christian Churches (Disciples of Christ). I claim no infallibility for my convictions, obviously, nor do I maintain that they are representative of views held by my fellow Disciple ministers. My convictions have been born out of the crucible of my own study, some tearing life experiences, separation from many I loved, and a deep desire to know as intimately as I could the life and teachings of Jesus. Happy in my work, I am thankful for God’s blessings and hopeful that He will enable me to communicate the story of His grace, love, and salvation to others.