DAVID DARNELL has roots that go deep in a Church of Christ past. Brought up in a Church of Christ home, he attended Abilene Christian College (1950-51) and Florida Christian College (1953), returning to the former for graduate study. He preached for Churches of Christ during his college days and until 1958.

Additional academic work followed at the University of Toronto and at Brite College of the Bible in Texas Christian University. Mr. Darnell is currently studying towards a Ph.D. in Biblical Studies at Duke University. Now minister of the First Christian Church in Fayetteville, North Carolina, he was earlier minister for the First Christian Church in Archer City, Texas, from 1958 through 1961.


MUSINGS OF A PILGRIMAGE

By David R. Darnell

All of my grandparents were members of Churches of Christ and lived out their lives in active Christian service among that brotherhood. The Will Ranciers, my maternal grandparents, were leaders of the Church of Christ in Killeen, Texas. The David N. Darnells, my paternal grandparents, were life-long leaders of Churches of Christ in Texas, including Thorp Springs, Abilene, and Sweetwater. Before her death, my grandmother, Mrs. D. N. Darnell, was distinguished as having held the longest continuous subscription to the Firm Foundation of any living person.

Both of my parents, the Dewey R. Darnells, were reared in the Churches of Christ; both attended Abilene Christian College; and both served for many years as active influential workers among Churches of Christ, especially at the Fifth and Marble Church of Christ in Albuquerque, New Mexico.

It is therefore no surprise that I was born into the spiritual atmosphere and nourishment of the Churches of Christ; that in 1940, at the age of nine years, I was immersed for the remission of sins in the baptistery of the Fifth and Marble church; and that throughout my youth I rarely, if ever, missed a church service on Sunday mornings or nights, or on Wednesday evenings.

Upon my graduation from Albuquerque high school in 1949, I enrolled in Abilene Christian College, at Abilene, Texas. During my first year there I decided to give my life to the preaching of the gospel of Christ. Deeply influenced by the teachings of Homer Hailey, I followed him to Tampa, Florida, in 1951, and enrolled for my last two years in Florida Christian College. In 1953 I graduated with a bachelor of arts degree, magna cum laude, and moved back to Texas, where I became minister of the Eighth Street Church of Christ in Cisco. For six years I preached for Churches of Christ and shared in revival meetings and fellowship with many of the leading ministers and missionaries among Churches of Christ today.

I mention these facts to show that my roots are deeply planted in the Churches of Christ. In their midst I was taught to pray and to read the Bible. There my faith was nurtured. There I was baptized into Christ. There I received my call into the proclamation of the gospel. For all of this I am deeply grateful. I am thankful for that little band of Christians in Albuquerque who shared with me their faith and Christian nurture; thankful, too, I am for the fellowship and love of the broader fellowship I came to know as I went to college and as I began my ministry. There are so many dear friends, too numerous to mention, whose memory now brings joy to my heart. I am thankful for the deep respect and concern for the Biblical message which I learned to share in their midst, and for the vivid sense of my standing before God which I came to know in their fellowship. I give thanks to God for this rich heritage which is mine because of the Churches of Christ.

But while there is so much for which I am thankful, there is also much among the Churches of Christ with which I cannot agree, and which I personally can no longer uphold. Since this is an essay and not a book, I must limit my statement to two broad attitudes among Churches of Christ which I have found impossible to maintain.

The first is this: a “closed” attitude towards religious learning.

As I grew up in Albuquerque, I was taught by my parents and my church always to be open to truth, wherever it might lead me. We had nothing to fear from any truth, they said; only half-truth and error needed to withdraw itself from open investigation and criticism. I remember well how a minister from the Christian Church came once to speak to my father about the possibility of his preaching among the Churches of Christ. He asked what he would have to preach. My father replied that he could preach the truth as he saw it. He would have to endorse no peculiar position or belief, but simply study the Bible for himself and proclaim the truth that he learned.

I rejoiced in this openness toward truth and supposed that it reflected a general attitude among Churches of Christ. I t seemed to me to be the distinguishing mark between the Lord’s church and the churches of men that were bound down by human, creedal limitations. Early in life I read much from Richardson’s Memoirs of Alexander Campbell, and thrilled at his willingness to publicly and openly present his views and let them be subjected to the most able criticism that could be brought against them. Campbell, sitting in his study surrounded by the writings of leading thinkers of his day and of ages past, listening fairly and calmly to all who wished to speak, respecting others in spite of their differences from him, and yet boldly teaching the truth as he found it—this was my idea of the Christian minister’s attitude toward truth. And this, I believed, was the attitude that marked the Churches of Christ: an open willingness to hear and to be heard, a refusal to reject others unheard or to burn books, and eager readiness to proclaim the Biblical message in the arena of human thought, and an impulse to lead mankind in its struggle to understand the deep problems of human existence in the light of God’s revelation.

But as I reached out beyond my home congregation and sat in classes at Abilene and Florida Christian Colleges, I soon came to realize that the Churches of Christ did not hold such an attitude towards religious learning at all. In the preaching and teaching which surrounded me, I found myself exposed to one viewpoint and one only—a viewpoint hammered into my thinking from every angle. The leading thinkers from the Churches of Christ were not joining the great battle with unbelief, they were not leading mankind in wrestling with the crucial problems that cry out for religious answers in the twentieth century: economic and social injustices, war, national and racial unrest, population explosion, division in Christendom, the need for and scarcity of depth psychology and pastoral counseling, Biblical criticism and comment. They were writing no significant books. They had withdrawn themselves from the mainstream of human thought to build up and defend their peculiar, narrow party beliefs-to fight nineteenth century battles in our twentieth century world.

When we studied what we called “Denominational Doctrines,” we did not study them sympathetically, to seek to understand and appreciate what earnest and sincere Christians believed and were trying to say—not at all. We studied them to know how to answer them, and how to convert them to our conception of the truth. We could easily dismiss a giant like John Calvin and his Institutes, or Augustine and his works, by a passing reference to their being the sources of most denominational heresy! And this while we ourselves refused to grapple with the great problems which they had sought to solve!

In all of this we were being taught to defend and maintain the peculiar tenets of our party in Christendom, but we were not being taught to be open, to go on an intellectual pilgrimage ourselves, to seek to wrestle with the great issues of Christian faith and human destiny on our own. Our constant assumption was that we already “had the truth,” and we either refused to listen to the voices of others or else we studied their views only to point out their weaknesses and reply to them. It was never a matter of really seeking to understand them; we never allowed for the possibility of actually changing our own viewpoint because of what we learned; and our approach to religious knowledge was therefore sterile and irrelevant to the crying needs of our world.

This same attitude was expressed constantly in almost every class I attended. (There were exceptions, and for them I am very thankful now, although at the time I suspected those very teachers of being “modernists”) . We were always told which books, and which men were “sound”; and we quickly learned which scholars, and which positions were “poison,” to be handled only with extreme caution and suspicion. We learned to study and appreciate scholars who supported our own assumptions and conclusions; we looked upon all others as pathetically lost and hopeless, even though we had never read a line from their own writings.

I remember well the first day of a class in Biblical Criticism, in which the instructor began his lectures by asking, “If you were the Devil, attempting to destroy the Christian faith, how would you begin?” Someone replied, “By attacking the confidence of people in the reliability of the text of the Bible.” The instructor said that this was correct, and with that comment we began our investigation of textual criticism—as the Devil’s fiendish attempts to uproot Christian faith and destroy belief in the Bible! And we were the ones who said that all “sectarians” looked at things through colored glasses!

Examples could be multiplied, but this will suffice to illustrate what I am saying. Churches of Christ have taken upon themselves a closed attitude towards religious learning. In so doing, they have isolated themselves from the rest of the Christian world and they are no longer making an effective contribution to the thorny problem of division among Christians. By adopting this closed attitude, they have un consciously taken to themselves an unwritten creed and they have become victims of the need to promulgate their own peculiar way of thinking, instead of speaking in Christ’s name to the real problems of this century. Religious learning has ceased to be the challenging adventure of dedicated disciples who would speak His word to their world; it has been sidetracked onto the endless defense and promotion of a narrow, irrelevant kind of Christianity. It is for this reason that I think the Churches of Christ no longer constitute a “Restoration of New Testament Christianity,” as they so forcefully proclaim. Instead, they have substituted a legalistic and artificially patterned religion for the rich, dynamic truths of the New Testament.

And this “closed” attitude towards religious education has violated the very basis of real learning. When one begins by assuming that he has all the truth and then proceeds to defend that assumption without ever really questioning it, or honestly listening to other views of “the truth,” he may get his prejudices bolstered but he is not going to get an education. Real education questions and examines all assumptions, listens sympathetically to all proposed solutions, and seeks out new truths for itself. Real religious education is “open.” It reaches out into the mainstream of human thought, both present and past. It does not assume its conclusions before it gets to them. It exposes its assumptions and opinions to the full light of public, critical examination. There, in the open arena, in honest give and take, genuine faith is born and takes root.

During my college days I studied New Testament Greek; after graduation I did further work in the language. As I began to read the Greek New Testament in earnest, I began to wonder about the words psallo and psalmos. The more I inquired into their usage, the more I became convinced that these words describe singing accompanied with an instrument, and that they do not at all imply a capella singing. Because of this, I decided that I could no longer preach that people who sing with musical accompaniment in Christian worship are acting in violation of the New Testament, and I so informed the elders of the Lake Worth Church of Christ in Forth Worth, where I was preaching. I did not want to make an issue of this in any way, and our agreement was that I would make no mention of it in my teaching and preaching. The only change that I made was that I stopped saying that the use of the instrument would condemn people.

Over a year later, I was asked to teach Bible in Fort Worth Christian College, and accepted. But the week before school began, I received a phone call from the president of the school, asking me what I believed about instrumental music. I told him how I felt, and stated that I certainly did not want to make this an issue in any way, or even bring the matter up in my teaching. But this did not satisfy him. He asked me for a direct answer, yes or no, as to whether a man who used the instrument in Christian worship would “go to hell.” When I answered, “No,” I was told in reply that my services could not be used at Fort Worth Christian College. I had failed in my “creedal examination.” It was not a question of my loyalty to Jesus Christ, or of my ability and desire to teach the Bible. I had refused to utter the proper shibboleth; I could no longer be trusted to teach our young people the Bible.

When I informed the elders at the Lake Worth Church of Christ that I could no longer keep silent on this matter, they told me that I could not again speak in the pulpit of the church. The following Sunday, a visiting minister “tried out,” and at the close of the service I was allowed five minutes to say goodbye to the congregation I had loved and worked with for some three years.

Needless to say, this was a heart-breaking experience for me and my family. But what seemed at that time a very terrible experience seems to us today one of the most blessed events of our lives. That separation broke the hold of a narrow, unwritten creed on our minds. I became, in a very real sense, a “free man in Christ” on that day. I began to turn from a narrow, sectarian view of religious truth and to drink afresh from the living water. I ceased to call any man, or group of men, “Master.” I entered into a joyous fellowship with all who honor Jesus Christ, and I began the arduous but joyous process of working through to my own theology in the open arena of world-wide scholarship and criticism, looking to the original documents of our faith with a freshness that continues to thrill and challenge me to this very day.

So it was this basic attitude towards religious learning that led me to reach out beyond the exclusive fellowship of the Churches of Christ. The question was whether learning should be conducted in a closed, creedal atmosphere, or in open, questioning discussion. I chose the latter. I would choose it again today.

The second attitude which separated me from those with whom I had so long worked was this: a lack of love and a suspicious fear of other Christians.

For some three months following my dismissal from the pulpit of the Lake Worth Church, I continued to attend Churches of Christ regularly. But it was never the same again. I was no longer “Brother,” but “Mr. Darnell.” I never again was asked to lead in prayer, nor recognized in any public way. I was only told that I ought to repent and “come back.”

I was doing construction work at the time, and one rainy day, when we could not work, I went by the seminary building of Texas Christian University and spoke to the dean of the seminary, Elmer Henson. In the course of our talk he told me that I could attend classes there and that they would expect me to “hammer out my own theology”—that what I believe and preached would be a matter between me and God, but that the teachers and library of the University were mine to use. At the time, I didn’t believe him. Surely they held some peculiar view that I would have to espouse! But as I began taking courses, and as I continued with my B.D. program, I came to realize that the dean had meant every word. Here were devout Christian men who were interested in helping me grow as Christian scholar and minister, but who did not consider it their responsibility to predetermine the conclusions at which I would arrive.

One day I went to Archer City, Texas, and preached for a Christian Church. I did so with much fear and trembling. How it shocked my ears to hear the singing with piano accompaniment! What a shock to hear the whole church sing “Happy Birthday” to those who had had a birthday that week! How different it was to what I had known! But those warm-hearted ranch people listened eagerly to what I had to say, despite the fact that much of it was new and strange to them. I went back to that little church for almost four years. I found there acceptance as an individual even though we differed about many of our understandings.

This was the beginning of a wonderful experience for me. I began to reach out to know and share with Christian people and ministers from varying religious backgrounds. I found in them the same fruits of the Spirit of God that I had found among Christians in the Churches of Christ. I came to know that the Holy Spirit of God is much larger and more all-encompassing than the narrow bounds I had found erected among Churches of Christ. And I began to see that what is really wrong among the Churches of Christ is a sickness of heart, a fear of others who differ with them on doctrinal issues, and a lack of love for such persons. It is a kind of spiritual paranoia that looks with suspicious distrust on those who are different, that demands credentials before it will give its love, and that destroys all possibility for real growth in Christian thought.

One evening I went to the home of a very well-known evangelist for the Churches of Christ and met there four other prominent ministers for a lengthy discussion. We talked of the meaning of Acts 21:17-26, and I said I thought that this, and other passages, show clearly how first century Christians felt free to continue observing the religious customs of the Law of Moses. One of the ministers, a speaker for the “Herald of Truth” (a national television program), said: “But if that is true, how can we condemn the Catholics?”

Indeed, how can we condemn the Catholics? Is that an essential to our faith, that we condemn others ‘? Why should we not look for grounds for fellowship, understanding, and agreement instead? Why not build bridges instead of walls?

As I look back now, this attitude seems to me to be decisive in my religious pilgrimage. Churches of Christ do not teach or practice genuine love for their religious neighbors. They do not really come to know their religious neighbors, nor to share sympathetically in their religious longings and convictions. They have so separated themselves that they are left “high and dry,” unable to enter into real dialogue and constructive criticism with other churches. They miss the strengthening which such mutuality would give, and which all of us so desperately need. After all, if we are right about necessity of weekly communion, and of immersion, why should we run away and hide? We cannot convince others of the correctness of our plea by refusing to know them—really know them. If we do indeed have, as we say, the one workable plan for Christian unity, it seems odd that we should pull away from all others who claim to be Christians and spend our time quarreling and dividing among ourselves.

It is my constantly growing conviction that we disciples of Christ have nothing to fear from encounter with others, whether in an academic way, or in religious fellowships. Rather, we have much to gain. Only when we truly know others can they begin to hear what we are saying. We gain nothing by isolating ourselves and refusing to listen to anyone else. There is so much for us to gain that we cannot afford any longer the tragic luxury of self-centeredness and separation from our fellowmen, whose loyalty and devotion to Jesus Christ are every bit as strong as our own.

As the years have passed, my family and I have grown to know the validity of God’s providential guidance of our lives. We have been enriched spiritually. Our faith has deepened year by year as we have learned to love, and appreciate, and share with Christians of Roman Catholic, Greek Orthodox, and Protestant backgrounds. Our love and respect for Jesus Christ is much stronger today than it was ten years ago. Our belief in the validity and relevance of His teaching has grown yearly. It is our deep longing and prayer that our brothers in the Churches of Christ will be blessed and used by God’s Spirit, and that new days of fellowship and understanding in the light of Jesus Christ lie before all of us. In a world desperately needing the Light of Life, may we, the “light-bearers,” not let our candles be hidden under any of our creedal bushel-baskets!

O God, forgive all of us our pride, our self-centeredness, our divisiveness, our ignorance, and our lack of understanding. Cleanse our hearts from suspicion, mistrust, and party-spirit. Fill us with deep, out-reaching love for all Thy children, our brothers, and a deep faith that will leave us unafraid. Open to us anew Thy truth, that the Spirit and power of Jesus Christ may be in us, and that we may speak Thy Word to the crying needs of our lost world. Give unity to all who love and honor Jesus Christ as Lord, that in oneness of mind and purpose we may proclaim the gospel to the nations. In His name, Amen.