|
MARTHA ARMSTRONG was educated at two Church of Christ
schools, Gunter Bible College and Thorp Springs Christian College,
and has been deeply interested in the Restoration Movement most of
her life. For many years a member of the Pearl Street Church of
Christ in her hometown, Denton, Texas, Mrs. Armstrong is now a member
of the First Christian Church.
Since
coming to Denton with her husband, Boyd, in 1916, Mrs. Armstrong has
opened the doors of her home to many gospel preachers, both from the
Church of Christ and from the Christian Church. A recent high spot in
her life occurred in late 1965 when she visited the National City
Christian Church while President Johnson was in attendance. Seated
just in front of him, she was impressed when he went out of his way
to shake hands with a soldier who had placed membership with the
church that morning.
The Armstrongs have reared two sons, Kenneth and Oramel, besides a grandson who lost his own mother at an early age. Owners and operators of the Armstrong Nursery for years, the couple are known in Denton for having one of the most beautifully kept lawns in the city. Mrs. Armstrong was 70 on October 17, 1965. |
THE
HEART HAS ITS REASONS
By
Martha Armstrong
It
seemed like an impossible task to talk with a minister of the Church
of Christ about leaving
the
Church of Christ! After all, I was the third generation of my family
to be brought up in the Church of Christ, and how could I leave the
church of my parents and grandparents?
This
was the question that burned in my heart one pleasant summer evening
in 1927 when Brother W. F. Ledlow was again a visitor in my home. For
thirty years Brother Ledlow had been a prominent evangelist among the
churches, and he had served as president of the old Thorp Springs
Christian College. He had taught at the University of Texas and was
at that time on the faculty at North Texas State Teachers College.
Even though he was a man of great learning, his faithfulness to God
and to the church could not be questioned. He was often in our home,
and I had grown to admire him greatly. If a member of the Church of
Christ could have a “priest,” then Brother Ledlow was my
“priest.” He was tender and loving, like the One he
served, and I could talk with him about anything-yes, even about
leaving the church of my fathers.
I
spoke softly, as if to speak of someone’s death. “Brother
Ledlow, I simply cannot stand it any longer. I must, for conscience’
sake, leave the Church of Christ. I suppose I’ll go to the
Christian Church in search of the peace I long for.”
If
I was surprised that I could ever say such words, rooted and grounded
in Church of Christ thinking as I was, I was even more surprised at
what Brother Ledlow said to me in reply. These were his shocking
words:
“I
understand, my sister, I understand. If it were not for the many
people I have baptized, who look to me for guidance and
encouragement, I would take the same step you are taking. I would
have left the Church of Christ long ago were it not for these people;
but if I should leave, I fear they might become discouraged and lose
their faith in Christ. By staying, however, I have lost part of my
own family. It is a sad thing. I understand why you have decided to
do as you are doing.”
Hardly
anyone could have been more firmly rooted in what we called “the
New Testament church” than was I. Immersed by Horace Busby when
I was only twelve, I went on to attend the old Gunter Bible College
under N. L. Clark, and Thorp Springs Christian College under A. W.
Young. I heard most of the prominent evangelists of those days,
including G. C. Brewer, Thomas Milholland, Jim and Gus Dunn, G. H. P.
Showalter, R. L. Whiteside, Cled Wallace, Foy Wallace, Jr., and Foy
Wallace, Sr. The preachers who were “running a meeting”
at our congregation often stayed with my husband and me, or at least
took a meal or so at our table. I recall with fond memories the
extended visits of G. C. Brewer during at least two meetings in
Denton.
At
both Gunter and Thorp Springs I was thoroughly grounded in sound
doctrine. Brother N. L. Clark was a dedicated man of God, and I
learned to love and respect him deeply. It was at Gunter that I first
met Brother Ledlow. He came there as a grown man with a family, but
with only a second grade education. I admired him for his willingness
to sit with children in order to get a common education. I admired
him even more as he went on from there, under terrific difficulties
and with almost no encouragement from the brethren, all the way to a
Ph.D. from the University of Texas. In those days a PhD was a rarity,
and for a Church of Christ minister it was unthinkable.
Gunter
Bible College was the last word in sound doctrine. Everything was
done “according to the Book,” and it was here that I
witnessed my first brotherhood fuss. The question was whether it was
scriptural on the Lord’s day to ring the school bell for the’
gathering of the saints who met in the school building. This question
was thoroughly aired, with lots of scripture quoted by both sides,
and it was finally decided that it was unscriptural to have sounds of
an instrument
bellowing
forth from the belfry to summon the saints to the assembly. One might
conclude that we were a bit narrow-minded at Gunter! But I learned my
lessons well, and I loved the old school.
I
was 32 years old, married, and had a growing family when I decided to
leave the Church of Christ. Why did I finally leave? It was because
of years of embarrassment and harassment-and a freedom so limited it
often became downright enslavement.
I
say embarrassment
because
some of the finest people in our community were scolded for being
“sectarians” whenever they were kind enough to attend our
meetings. We
never
attended their
services,
for they were “in error,” and so, when they visited us,
we berated them soundly, naming their particular church and showing
how their doctrines were wrong and ours right.
I
say harassment
because
I was continually subjected to the notion that we
were
right and all
others were
wrong. I grew up believing that we were “the true church”
while all others were “the denominations.” We were
careful to speak only of our ministers as “gospel preachers”;
all the others were “sectarian preachers.” Even if a
preacher of the Christian Church visited with us, he was treated as
any other “outsider,” no matter how pious and dedicated
his life. Whenever “a sectarian” came to our services,
the word was passed along to the evangelist, and the visitor was sure
to get skinned. This deeply grieved and embarrassed me, but I endured
it for almost half a lifetime, and might have continued enduring it
had it not been for Foy Wallace, Jr.
Brother
Wallace came to Denton in 1926 as the minister of the Church of
Christ in that city. He was young, handsome, intelligent, and
arrogant. He came at a time when I was maturing as a Christian,
studying and thinking for myself, and becoming increasingly
uncomfortable with the view that we were the only Christians. Sunday
after Sunday I listened to Foy Wallace as he strode back and forth
across the rostrum, profusely quoting the Scriptures (which he must
have known entirely by memory since he hardly ever used his Bible)
and “skinning the sects” as only he could do. The more I
heard him, the more resentful I became.
He
became to me the sum and substance of all resentment toward our
negative religion. All the preachers were not like Foy Wallace, Jr.,
but his attitude and behavior were nonetheless consistent with what
the Church of Christ stood for, as well as with the image it had with
the general public. The “outsiders” thoroughly understood
the Church of Christ viewpoint: that we thought of ourselves as the
only true church and the only Christians, and that all besides
ourselves would go to hell. I cannot see that this image has changed
any since 1932, unless perhaps our preachers are now saying the same
things a little more subtly.
With
Foy Wallace in the pulpit, I simply could not stand it any longer. I
had to leave. If I could have been exposed more to men like G. C.
Brewer, Horace Busby, and Jim Dunn, it might have been a different
story. But even with these men the viewpoint was the same. They
simply were more subtle and more gentle. Yet despite the narrow views
they were genuinely Christian men.
I
left in order to be a free woman in Christ. I felt that I was in
bondage in the Church of Christ. I can explain what I mean by telling
more about W. F. Ledlow, who tried to be a free man in Christ. When
he was holding a meeting in the little town of Valley View, near
Denton, he called on the local Presbyterian pastor to lead a prayer.
It was like a shattering clap of thunder out of a clear sky! We
members were all shocked and amazed, and we could hardly listen to
the prayer because of what had happened. And yet the brethren seemed
to appreciate it, however surprised they were. I was then a young
girl and worked as the town’s only telephone operator. For days
after that the phones buzzed all over town, and “the
sectarians” delighted in telling about “that Campbellite
preacher that called on Brother Baker to pray.”
Brother
Ledlow had to pay for such transgressions, of course. Not only was he
criticized for fraternizing with the sects, but also for getting an
education. Even though he sacrificed both pride and comforts to
return to elementary school after becoming an adult, and stayed with
his studies through the years until he finally earned the PhD in his
fifties, his brethren (especially preachers and editors) offered
nothing but ridicule. He was “written up” in the pages of
the Firm
Foundation as
some kind of heretic. He was highly respected at the University of
Texas (a professor there wrote a lofty eulogy of him for the Firm
Foundation when
he died) and at North Texas State Teachers College (the dean
delivered a high tribute at his funeral), but his own brethren were
constantly harassing him for being different. His constant theme as a
preacher was the wonderful love of God, and the beauty of His grace
to us through Christ. He spoke of Christ with great reverence, as if
His presence were a living reality. His preaching and conversation
were much different from most of his fellow ministers. And he
could
understand why I just had to leave, even though he chose to stay.
Since
beginning work on this personal message I have recovered the December
6, 1932 issue of Firm
Foundation. from
the bottom of an old trunk. The paper is filled with tributes to W.
F. Ledlow (I recall resenting such tributes from a paper which had
been so critical of him). I wish to quote from one of these
testimonials to Brother Ledlow, written, by W. W. Freeman:
Brother
W. F. Ledlow for twenty-five years found his progress in religious
thought hindered by preachers of less learning who easily capitalized
their traditional loyalty at the expense of his reputation among
conservative brethren. The student of religious history knows the
travail of all religious reformers, and Ledlow was well able to
interpret generously the envious opposition and criticism sometimes
met, heard or felt. He never became bitter, for he knew from his own
growing experience the good intentions of critics.
This
is what I mean by being enslaved. A church that is so cramped in its
ideas that a respectable minister in a community cannot be recognized
in its services without causing a commotion is an unfree church.
Except for the time Brother Ledlow called on that Presbyterian to
lead a prayer, I have never witnessed any visiting minister called on
to do anything in the service of a Church of Christ unless he, too,
were a Church of Christ minister. Even to this good day the Church of
Christ will not treat a Christian Church minister as a brother in
Christ. If he dares to go among them, he will be treated as any man
of the world would be.
And
when Brother Ledlow attempted in a brotherly way to reach across the
barriers that divide men, not only in recognizing ministers in other
churches but in his general attitude, he was, as Brother Freeman
said, “hindered by traditional loyalty.”
Well,
that is why I left. I did not want to spend my life with a church
that impressed everyone with the idea that they think they have all
the truth while others have none, that they are the only Christians
while all others are sectarians. I left because I wanted to be free
and to think for myself. I had been stifled long enough. I left for
conscience’ sake. I left for the same reasons that some give
for leaving the Roman Catholic Church. To me there are striking
resemblances between the Romanism and the Church of Christism that
engrossed me for half a lifetime. Both suppose that they alone have
the truth; both suppose they are the
true church while
others are heretics; both are right about everything, infallible
interpreters of the Word; both teach their people to stay away from
other churches; both are authoritarian and dogmatic; both suppose
their priests or ministers are the only true servants of God; both
claim that the way to unity is to join them and to do as they do in
every particular.
So
that is why I left, for the same reasons people sometimes leave the
Roman Catholic Church. I can belong to Christ, and love Him and serve
Him and be free in Him without belonging either to the Roman Catholic
Church or to the Church of Christ. I must admit that there now seems
to be one important difference between these two churches: the
Catholics seem to be changing, while I can see no real cracks in the
wall of Church of Christ exclusivism. The Roman priest here in Denton
is president of the ministerial alliance. Years ago I could not have
imagined such a thing. Even now I cannot imagine the Church of Christ
ministers in this city having anything to do with any ministerial
alliance. Even yet, I suppose, they would dare not join such a group
lest they be “written up” in somebody’s paper as
Brother Ledlow was years ago.
That
the Church of Christ attitude is still what it was a generation ago
was made evident to me recently as I lay on a hospital bed extremely
ill. A lifelong friend and an ardent Church of Christ sister sent me
a kindly greeting with an attending note that read: “Read your
Bible.” That is always good advice, and of course I do read the
Bible. But knowing the good sister’s religion as I do, I knew
quite well what she meant. She was calling my attention to the fact
that I am in the wrong church, where there is instrumental music, and
that I had better read my Bible and get right before it was too late.
Her advice was well intentioned; that is the way the thinking of her
people goes. If people would just read their Bible, they reason, they
would all believe like the Church of Christ. The conclusion must be
that if we disagree it means we are either ignorant or we do not want
the truth. I myself shudder to think that I might once have been so
cruel.
For
some thirty years I have belonged to the Disciples of Christ, so I am
still a part of the Restoration Movement, which I love. Do I agree
with everything in the Christian Church? I should say I do not! Then
why do I not leave them as I did the Church of Christ? Because I am
now free to think for myself. They do not try to push anything down
my throat, and I can worship with people who believe Christians can
be different and still love each other and work together.
While
I still resent the narrowness in the Church of Christ, I certainly
love these brethren and have no bitterness toward them. I have always
been thankful that I attended Church of Christ schools and had
contacts with so many dear Christians. For the sake of the young
women now growing up in the Church of Christ, as I did long ago, I
would urge the leaders to have more feeling for those with whom they
differ, and to work more realistically for the oneness of all
Christians. The Church of Christ’s plea for unity will never be
listened to seriously until its leaders learn to share in
conversation with others. It is rather childish for any of us to
suppose that we have so much of the truth, and others have so little,
that the answer to division is for everyone else to become like us.
I
would urge those with whom I once worshipped to extend to others the
graces they assume for themselves. We must not suppose that a person
is either ignorant or dishonest if he does not see things the way we
do. There are such things as honest
mistakes,
even when men are searching eagerly for truth. And must we not keep
in mind that we,
too,
might be wrong about some things? We want others to be gracious
enough to understand that our errors are unintentional. Let us judge
only to the extent that we wish to be judged. The truth is that most
of us are what we are because of the circumstances of birth. Most of
us would have been a Mormon or a Moslem if we had happened to be born
that way. Few of us are what we are because of a long, painful search
for truth. It is not gracious of us, after accidentally being born
into the “right church,” to be severe on those who have
done exactly what we have done-remained where the circumstances of
birth placed them. Let us learn to be kind and gentle.
Our Lord assures us that “If the Son shall make you free, you shall be free indeed,” and this has been my blessing. My cup overflows. While I am not a woman of letters, I might quote Pascal in a further effort to summarize my testimony: “The heart has its reasons that reason knows not of.” I have tried to set forth a reasonable account of what I did and why I did it. If I have failed in this, then let us simply say that it is a matter of the heart. It was for Him that I did as I have done. Most of those in the Church of Christ will disagree with me. They will choose to remain where they are. This is as it should be, and may the Lord bless them as they serve Him. For them, too, I say: “The heart has its reasons ….”