WILLIAM P. REEDY was reared in the Church of Christ and became a minister at 21. After several years of traveling in various states as an evangelist, he moved in 1915 to Long Beach, California, where he served the Church of Christ for eight years as a located minister. In 1923 he moved to Los Angeles, helped establish the Southwest Church of Christ, and worked with this congregation for thirteen years. While there he earned a B.A. and an M.A. from the University of Southern California.

Attempting to share the new insights resulting from these studies, Mr. Reedy found himself described more and more often as a liberal. He taught Bible at George Pepperdine in its first year of existence as a college, but soon found himself at odds with the administration. Although urged by some to seek a less restricted religious environment, he hesitated to break old and dear ties. He chose to involve himself in studies again, spending three years at Yale Divinity School, from which he earned the B.D. degree.

Returning, Mr. Reedy found himself unable to change attitudes and decided at last to switch his religious affiliations. He was granted ministerial status by the Congregationalists and worked first with one of their churches near San Diego. Given a later assignment with the Temple Street church in Los Angeles, he spent some ten years in service before resigning because of declining health. He now teaches a class in a congregation of the United Church of Christ. He is chaplain of his service club and active on committees.


WHY WE CHANGED

By William P. Reedy

Editor’s note: This explanation by William P. and Jessie T. Reedy appeared in the West Coast Christian in 1945. Mr. Reedy has added recent comments in a postscript at the end of this essay.

My “changed attitude toward the church” has not come about suddenly without due consideration of all that is involved in such a change. It is not the result of anyone thing which has happened at—church or any other church. It is not due to any real or fancied slight or wrong done to me. Moreover, I was not motivated by an ambition for place or prestige or distinction, nor moved by “preacher pride,” nor by concern over loss of “professional” status.

No, it is far deeper than that. I will confess that I have struggled for years within myself, trying to reconcile certain practices and attitudes of the Church of Christ, as I know it, with the Spirit and teaching of our Lord and His apostles. When it came finally to the point that I had to say and teach what I sincerely believed in order to be true to myself and to my God, I found that I could not do this without being criticized, ostracized, and regarded as “off color,” unsound,” “not loyal,” and the like.

The church has devised a formal pattern, to which one must conform even to stereotyped phraseology, if one is to retain favor with “those who seemed to be somewhat” (Galatians 2:6). A deep conviction which told me that I must be true to what I believed was right and what God wanted me to do, moved me to rebel against such intolerance. I could not be true to myself and to God, and remain within the fellowship of the Church of Christ.

Yes, I have changed. I am glad I have changed. But to many, this is an unpardonable sin. There are those who speak with pride of their “unchanged and unchanging position.” I do not think it is smart to be smug. But there are some who consider changelessness a mark of “loyalty,” of religious superiority. Those who are entirely filled with the spirit of conservation have no spirit of exploration or advance.

I offer no apology for having changed my mind on many subjects. I am not ashamed to admit that my mind is not yet made up on many other matters. I do not feel that my present judgment represents the last word. No one has heard the last word—it has not been spoken. I hope to outgrow tomorrow what I think and preach today.

Ultimate truth is, of course, fixed, but my conception of truth is not fixed nor should it be. If it were, all possibility of growth would be ended. Within the Bible itself there are great growths—great developments in the basic concepts of truth. The attitude of the Church of Christ at this point constitutes her gravest error. She has crystallized her concepts of God, Christ, the Bible, the “Plan of Salvation,” and all the rest, into a closed pattern, and by so doing she has identified these concepts with the total truth on such subjects.

This is wrong. It is not right to identify truth with our concepts of truth. This attitude on the part of the Church of Christ makes her intolerant and causes the good that is in her to defeat the best which she might have. This attitude closes the door against all progress, and forbids the voicing of any newly discovered truths or the expression of honest convictions. This is exactly what the Pharisees did in our Saviour’s day. This was the cause of His break with them.

All churches (fellowships) are human in many respects, including the Church of Christ. And in so far as they are human, they are imperfect and sinful. It is therefore obvious that all have truth—and all have error. I have, frankly, not found it very satisfying or fruitful to compare and try to determine which church is nearest to the “divine pattern,” seeing that one is “nearer” in some things, while others are “nearer” in other things. One will never find a body, a church, a fellowship, which is right in every thing and at every point, and I do not think that one can ever belong to any church and believe or accept everything it teaches and practices.

I did not do this when I was in the Church of Christ fellowship, and of course there are certain tenets held in Congregationalism (my present commitment) to which I personally do not subscribe. But in the Congregational Church there exists an attitude which tolerates, even appreciates, points of view which are different. So, if I want to believe in immersion and preach it, I may, without being disfellowshipped. Could I follow that principle in the Church of Christ as we know it? In the Congregational Church one does not have to subscribe to any creed or dogma or to any certain belief other than that of belief in Jesus Christ as Lord.

All the while that I was identified with the Church of Christ I was preaching unity and practicing division. The unity of Spirit, or unity in diversity, which is in my judgment, the unity taught in the Bible, is all but unknown among those who are with the Churches of Christ. I feel very strongly that the Congregational Church comes “nearer” to demonstrating what the real unity of the Spirit is, as this is taught in the New Testament, than any other fellowship I know.

Now let me hasten to say that I do not consider that I have left the Church of Christ, nor departed from the faith. As a matter of fact, all I have done is to shift my fellowship from one group to another. I have not believed for a long time that the Church of Christ, as we knew it, could boast properly that it was the only true Church of Christ. As a matter of fact, it is not. No group can make such a boast; no group can claim to be the one and only Body of Christ.

Yet it does not follow that Christ has no Body. He does have indeed. The Body of Christ is bigger and better than anyone group or all of them together. I would not even say that all of the churches, as such, constitute the Body of Christ. I do not know who all of God’s people are in this world, in the USA, or in any local fellowship. I imagine the names on anyone “church book” are not the same as those God has enrolled in heaven for that church. But we are not the judges of that.

I admire the words of a dear brother in Christ, written a few years ago. They are appropriate and I here make use of them. He said: “Some one may say that the church consists of the ‘faithful,’ or ‘loyal.’ But who are they? We must remember that no one is absolutely ‘faithful’ or ‘loyal.’ We can be so relatively, not absolutely. Some are very faithful in some respects, and very unfaithful in others.” All are unfaithful somewhere. When we try to answer the question: Who is ‘faithful’ or ‘loyal,’ we are faced with the fact that everyone will raise or lower the standard according to his measure of understanding as to what is important as a basis of fellowship and as a formula of salvation. In the Church of Christ alone, as we know it, we can get twenty-two or more different answers. In calling a divided church to unity, it would depend on who was doing the calling as to what the basis of unity would be!

What modern, model church reaches up to the brotherly love, benevolence, unity, missionary zeal, personal purity of life, discipline, radiance and joy of the true, divine church of God? Why isn’t it just as fatal to lack apostolicity in one respect as to lack it in another? Why is it more important to restore the “form of doctrine”—outward, objective forms—than to restore the true “spirit” of the early church?

I believe that I find some of God’s people everywhere, in all of the different fellowships, and that the Spirit of Christ which prevails in them will invariably find expression. This Family of God, this Church of Christ, is the all-glorious Body which concerns itself with great issues and does not parley over matters of trivial import.

As to the name, just this comment: if one thinks of the church in terms of that heavenly, spiritual Body which is composed of all redeemed, past and present, in heaven and in earth, and not in terms of some small group or sect or denomination, he will have no difficulties. It is the former thing that is the Church of Christ, and to this truth all Christians will give assent.

I must say, quite frankly, that while it is most likely that the first church did not use instruments of music in their worship, I am not convinced on that account that it is wrong. I shall never again make an issue of it. I feel now that it should never have been made an issue. The slogan has been, “Where the Bible speaks, we speak; where the Bible is silent, we are silent.” Actually, the Church of Christ has often spoken where the Bible is silent, and has often been silent where the Bible speaks.

One good brother whom I esteem very highly wrote and “wondered if I could say with Paul, ‘I have kept the faith.’‘’ All I may say is that I still love the Church and the Bible and my reverence for God is deeper and more meaningful and my peace of soul is far more satisfying now than it ever was. I would have you remember, however, that Paul left the Jewish Church and was himself accused of “persuading men to worship God contrary to the law.” (Acts 18:13) Just as he broke with the traditions he had known so that he might lay hold on the new truths that had come to him, so have I. I cannot regret it.

I might have continued in the Church of Christ fellowship. I turned down many invitations from brethren and churches in various places. Why did I not accept, continuing to preach and teach within the limits of the “brotherhood”? One good and influential brother told me frankly: “You will be accepted if you will go back and preach the sermons you preached twenty-five years ago and hold protracted meetings as you did twenty-five years ago.” That, of course, I could not do. This ought to be obvious to anyone. The gospel of Christ means infinitely more to me now than it did twenty-five years ago. How can one “go back” when the whole genius of the gospel says “go forward”?

I want to be tolerant toward sincere Christians whose convictions differ from my own. This does not mean that such tolerance dissolves convictions. On the contrary, Christians must have positive convictions about the truth. We all need to grow in our comprehension of truth. But this is not possible without tolerance, without the spirit of respect for a clear, personal faith on the part of another.

I share the feeling and spirit of an honored contemporary who writes, “I have come into the Congregational-Christian Churches seeking for a more flexible and adequate instrument with which to work for the Kingdom of Jesus Christ on earth. I have come hoping for that combination of honesty and freedom, breadth and tolerance, and spiritual earnestness and passion, which is by no means always wrapped up in the same bundle. Thus far I have been disappointed in my search. I am grateful beyond words for a communion which is as wide in its welcome and outreach as the Spirit of the Living God. May I say in conclusion that no one should be compelled to depart from his inherited church home base in order to find freedom, tolerance, and spiritual vitality.”

POSTSCRIPT

During the years that have intervened since I wrote the foregoing in 1945, much has happened to me, and I believe all to the good. The change I made at that time was not a sudden impulse nor an afterthought. It was the result of several years of inner conflict and prayerful meditation. It was a struggle against an attitude of narrow provincialism and arbitrary theological dogma, a struggle against an attitude that assumed it was right while all others were wrong. In my earlier years I was led to conform to and accept a narrow pattern of thinking which would allow little or no change.

I was glad then and I am glad now that I changed. I have never regretted it. True, I had many friends among the Churches of Christ whom I loved and still love. But many of them did not understand. I was forced to be true to myself and to my God. My conscience forbade me to allow myself to be a slave any longer to narrow, arbitrary and inflexible patterns. I challenged this attitude; I dared to be a non-conformist. This, predictably, was my undoing with the Churches of Christ. I was sorry, but I was under compulsion to be a free man in Christ Jesus my Lord.’ I could no longer consciously be pressed into a mold of human traditions. The liberty I yearned for and sought out gave me a sense of dignity as a man; I no longer felt as if I were a puppet manipulated by pulling of strings.

The change that I made has done much for and to me. I have experienced a sense of freedom of thought and action, both in and out of the pulpit, that I did not and could not have before. I was relieved of a load that I had tried to carry for years, but with misgivings. The human spirit must not be bound. Freedom under God is the most precious possession One can have.

Let me hasten to add that one must not take freedom to mean license. Freedom under God has a built-in quality called responsibility. It will not allow one to follow every whim and fancy or “cunningly devised fable.” It will not permit one to use a passage of Scripture out of context simply to bolster a preconceived idea. It allows one to search and find the truth that is vital to the needs of one’s own soul. Freedom with responsibility leads one into a genuine encounter with the Eternal.

With this freedom I have found the Bible more interesting and challenging than ever. My appreciation for it grows from day to day as I search for deeper insights into the meaning of life. I plead that many in bondage to dry legalism can find a new lease on life if they only will. We should look at the Bible as a library, rather than a code book. When one interprets some fragment and gives special emphasis to it, a schism is started.

An overly-literal interpretation leads us far afield, too, although the most ardent fundamentalists find this hard to accept. Men of old had experiences with the living God and they tried to tell us in song and story, myth and fable, symbol and law, parable and metaphor, what the meaning of life was. Their revelations were guidelines for generations to come. From them we learn about the age-long search for the living God. In my present church framework I have enjoyed a wonderful freedom to study the Bible fearlessly and to see how Jesus emerged into history as the true light of our world. I shall be forever grateful.

Soon after I made my change, I received ministerial status in the Congregational Church. I was given a cordial welcome and was assigned to a church. I entered the pulpit without the slightest misgivings. I was able to preach what I believed to be the truth of the Gospel. If any disagreed, I was not ostracized. All of us were happy in the exchange of ideas. There seemed to be none of that fear and insecurity I had so often seen before. With grand cooperation from the congregation, I was able to give renewed hope and to put the group in position to be a greater force for righteousness in the community. No one can imagine the thrill of this experience unless he has struggled through long years, as I did, in frustration because of authoritarian attitudes.

Most importantly, I came to know God in a personal way after I realized clearly that I was an individualization of the Eternal Spirit. This consciousness sustained me in many dark hours of blighting circumstance. Some may think that all this would have come anyway in the passage of years, but I am deeply convinced that in my own case the blessings came because I escaped the restrictive world in which I had so long lived. I am a free son of God today, responsible only to Him who will be the final judge of us all. What comfort, what peace of mind, what joy of life came to me as a result of my decision, no one can know for sure except those who have been brave enough to step forth and “stand fast in the liberty wherewith Christ has made him free.”