ROBERT MEYERS has been a minister in the Church of Christ for twenty-five years. He attended Freed-Hardeman College (1941-43) and graduated summa cum laude from Abilene Christian College (1948). He was awarded an M.A. from the University of Oklahoma (1951) and a Ph.D. from Washington University (1957). During World War II he took special courses at Oxford University and at Salisbury, England.

Now serving as a professor of English at Friends University in Wichita, Kansas, Mr. Meyers has taught at the University of Oklahoma, at Washington University, at Harding College, and at Stetson University in Florida. He has twice received $500 awards for excellence in teaching.

Mr. Meyers is entering his sixth year of service as a minister for the Riverside Church of Christ in Wichita. He is a book reviewer for the Dallas Times-Herald and writes frequently for religious and educational journals.


BETWEEN TWO WORLDS

By Robert Meyers

I remember clearly when it all began. There were those long Sunday afternoons in Uncle Clell Martin’s living room on that farm in Oklahoma. I was a boy of five or six during those summer months and I could not understand what it was that my father and my uncle talked about so seriously and for so long. Their voices would rise stridently at times to startle me out of some childish reverie. Later, in the languorous evening, they would talk quietly, exhausted by their efforts to communicate. What I did not know then was that Uncle Clell was converting my father to a new set of religious values.

My father had been a Methodist first. His parents had worshipped with less inhibition than most do now. They “got the Spirit,” as they explained it, and they were never greatly interested in arguing the logic of it. They put their hands upon their hearts and said, “Jesus lives here. I know He does. Nothing you can say will make me change my mind about that.” I was taught later to ridicule that way of talking as “better felt than told” religion, a foolish thing when compared with my own legalistic, argumentative head-religion.

As my father grew up he turned away from the religion of his parents. Perhaps some parts of it embarrassed him. Perhaps a friend influenced him. He tried the Baptists for a while. He embraced the Dunkard faith. He believed for a time that he had gotten religion in the cornfield and owed no one any further explanation than that. By the time he married my mother in Oklahoma, he was adrift religiously. She was a member of the Christian Church.

Uncle Clell, who belonged to the non-instrument Church of Christ, won my father to that church. From the time I was six I went to its services every time the doors opened. I can still vividly recall my parents’ beaming pride as I sang lustily the first church song I ever learned, “Bringing in the Sheaves.”

Always a person of strong enthusiasms and deep attachments, I became the most loyal Church of Christ youngster imaginable. I liked to read, so I read all the literature that church provided. I learned the arguments by heart and recited them glibly. It was not long before I could vanquish any of my childhood playmates with barrages of proof texts. What a heady joy it was to dominate them so completely! I was secure and, as I now see, religiously arrogant. I could not imagine the ignorance of people who knew the Church of Christ was right there in their own towns but who persisted in being Presbyterians or Nazarenes. I was discouraged from visiting them, so I knew nothing about them firsthand. This did not matter, of course, since my own preachers assured me that they were foolish folk who did not seem to care how far they missed God’s teachings. Once or twice I sneaked off to sit on some back pew and watch them curiously, but no one had helped me know how to understand them, so I only laughed. May God forgive me.

I was baptized at eleven under the preaching of the famed Negro evangelist of the Churches of Christ, R. N. Hogan. I began immediately to memorize huge batches of proof text verses so that I might crush the “sectarian” religionists as R. N. Hogan crushed them. The fact that he required police protection around his tent in Okmulgee, Oklahoma did not make me wonder about his methods. I merely thought it exciting and believed that the true man of God must expect hatred from other and false religionists.

The initial fervor diminished after I had learned several hundred verses but at fifteen it returned with extraordinarily powerful impulse. Will M. Thompson, a famed old debater became minister of my local church. Under his guidance I began preparing bulging notebooks loaded with points to make in debates with “sectarians.” Ultimately I had a stack of these over a foot high, laden with typewritten clinchers. For example, after each one of the thirty-six arguments made by Baptists who believed in the impossibility of apostasy, I would have an extensive reply which made the argument appear puerile. I would not have confessed it then, or perhaps recognized it fully, but my answers were replete with quibbles, dodges, evasions and satirical sallies. I used many exclamation marks and happily jotted down all the clever ways Will M. Thompson taught me about winning debates and emerging as party champion. There seemed to me to be no more glorious life imaginable than that of defender of the faith against all the diseased Protestant sects that differed from my church.

In my junior year in high school I began to preach. It was a wonderful experience. By the time I graduated from high school, I knew what my life was to be. I rejected the senior year of football so that my father would buy me a desk, a typewriter, and some books. When Abilene Christian College offered me a four year scholarship to play football (mainly because they hoped a friend of mine, an all-state player, would be thus encouraged to come), I turned it down and went instead to Freed-Hardeman College, a Church of Christ Bible school in Tennessee. I had heard that ACC preachers spoke too often on “love” and were therefore, perhaps not so “sound” as those at FHC. Above all else, I wanted to be sound.

Packing all my debate notebooks and my small library, I went away to Tennessee. I engaged in those mock debates which were often featured at our Monday night preacher’s club. I enjoyed excellent “appointments” in area churches. H. A. Dixon, a minister in Jackson, Tennessee and later to become president of Freed-Hardeman, once predicted from his pulpit that I would be one of the great defenders of the faith (i.e., Church of Christ interpretations). This heady praise only confirmed my conviction that I was on the glory road, destined under God to point the way to all who had an ear to hear.

Then came Pearl Harbor and, shortly, three years of military service. The experience was cataclysmic. Not because I was in mortal danger in foxholes. On the contrary, I was lucky enough to be a newspaper and radio correspondent and seldom in any real peril. But because I moved outside my isolated Church of Christ world for the first time in my life. I met Seventh Day Adventists whose devotion to Christ put mine to shame. I met Presbyterian lads in whose hands I placed my life with full confidence. I watched thirty different religious groups worship together in army chapels, carried above their differences of tradition by a consuming faith in Jesus Christ.

Suddenly my beautifully structured world began to crumble. I lay in a pup tent or on a cot many nights and cried quietly into my pillow because the house I had built was falling apart. I had intended it for a lifetime and it had seemed to excite the admiration of . all my friends, but it was being shaken to pieces. The friends around me in the army were bound to be lost; I knew this because dozens of preachers had told me so. Yet how had it happened that they had such beautiful faith in Christ? How was it that their characters had taken on more of the Christ image than mine, the defender of the faith? I could beat any of them into subjection in a few minutes with my formidable array of proof texts and my debate-sharpened mind, but I began to feel hollow after the victories. I had some fellow Church of Christ friends to chum with for a time. A few were splendid fellows, generous and loving; others were pinched and narrow, unhappy and loveless. I saw clearly that my religion did not inevitably turn out superior people. And I saw that religions I had been taught to scorn as hopelessly false often turned out men more Christlike than any I had met before.

Always an avid reader, my reading now underwent a marked change. Whatever I had read of religious material before, I read from a fixed position. Whatever differed from that position, I rejected easily without being troubled. Now, with my certainties tottering, I opened up to what I read and discovered a completely new world.

One day in North Wales, lying on a straw mattress, I read a book I had bought in a bookstall in Llandudno, It was called In Quest of a Kingdom. I would doubtless have bought another volume of Hardeman’s Tabernacle ? Sermons, since I had already memorized five volumes of them, but none were available. No Church of Christ material was to be had. I think this study of parables by Leslie Weatherhead was seminal for all my later development. In it I caught a glimpse of a kingdom of right relationships which surpassed in loveliness anything I had ever heard about in my boyhood church meetings. The book is no profound theological study, but it was the door through which I walked into a new country. I shall always remember gratefully the debt I owe to the London preacher.

From that time, I read everything of the kind I could get my hands on. And I observed people. I watched from jeeps, trains, and marching columns as peasants worked the turnip fields in Belgium under gray skies; I watched old women grabble in GI slop cans for fragments of food; I watched desperate boys and girls try to live life quickly before a bomb or a bullet ended it. And I knew that none of them had ever heard of my Church of Christ, southern style, USA. They might as well have been on Mars.

How would I be able to return to the pulpit and condemn them all with a wave of the hand? How could I accept, even silently, my church’s dictum that there was no hope for those who had not reached our plateau of understanding? I knew at last that I could not. I came home to finish my work at Abilene Christian College, but this time as an English major, not as a Bible major. I saw all things in a new light. I preached, but it was apparent to those who heard me that I was no longer a candidate for honors as defender of orthodoxy.

The years of graduate study followed. My doctoral work involved me heavily in textual criticism. I could not help but see how it transferred to Bible criticism. Families of manuscripts, kinds of textual errors, collations to show divergencies in parallel accounts such academic exercises I applied to Biblical problems. My emphasis on Renaissance literature led me deeply into study of the sixteenth century as the great age of English translation of the Bible. I shared all these things with the Central Church of Christ in St. Louis, a wonderful group who were not afraid to listen and to encourage. We studied the development of the canon, the apocryphal books, the variant accounts in the gospels, the transmission of the English Bible, what inspiration is, and kindred topics. I felt that in such an atmosphere any Christian might live and grow.

But the time came when I felt I must return to Harding College, where I had taught two years before beginning my final studies in St. Louis. Dear friends at Central doubted that I could find sufficient freedom there after the invigorating years away, but I believed I had to return. A twenty-year dream of teaching in a Christian (i.e., Church of Christ) college was not yet dead. I had known dear friends and fine students at Harding. Perhaps, I told myself, I can continue to grow there and share with others in frank talks the attitudes I had come to cherish.

I was wrong. Over a period of three more years I learned slowly but surely that I was no longer party champion enough to be happy at Harding. When the president of the school, under urging by some members of the Bible faculty, decided against renewing my contract, he acted wisely. As for me, perhaps nothing has happened to me that was better than this severance. I might soon have reached a point where cherished friendships and hallowed ties would have urged me to compromise convictions and fall into line.

I came to Friends University in Wichita where the forty-two different denominations represented accepted me as fellow Christian and teacher. Having had previous experience with students and ministers of my church, the president and dean of Friends asked me only one serious question: “What is your attitude toward other believers?” I understood at once. They wished to know whether I could work with them and accept them, or feel constantly prompted to convert them to my understandings. I explained that my attitude was one of acceptance, that I did not hold to the infallibility of any pattern of interpretation, and that I could happily maintain my personal convictions while talking without rancor to those who held others. On such a basis the Quaker-sponsored liberal arts college employed me. The Riverside Church of Christ in Wichita engaged my services at the same time and permitted me to talk freely and openly about all kinds of Christian concerns. The two labors have teamed well and have been immensely fruitful and satisfying to me. At the time of writing this essay, I count myself one of the fortunate few who are genuinely happy not in one job, but in two.

To this point I have deliberately made my essay autobiographical because in other places I have tried to set forth structured criticisms of the religious system in which I grew up, and in which I remain. But I must now honor one of the purposes of this book by speaking explicitly of the failures of that religious system which so long held me in thrall.

I know now that I suffered tragic losses as an adolescent. I was taught narrowness by those who fashioned me. Deliberately isolated from other religionists, I came to think of them as insincere people who simply did not care enough about being right. By speaking always only to those who approved what I said, I lost the priceless opportunity of receiving correction from older and wiser heads whose religious orientation was radically different from mine.

I was taught to be so completely sure that my interpretation of the Bible was the only correct one that I could not even understand that the Bible is one thing and individual interpretation of it quite another. It was excruciating to learn that my interpretation might be as fallible as the next man’s and when, one day, I finally knew this, my rigidly authoritarian religion crumbled into dust.

The plasticity of children is a beautiful and a terrifying thing. I idolized those authoritative and impressive-looking men who told me that my religion was the only correct one, and that no other could be of use to any man. I accepted happily my amazing good fortune at having been born into a family which embraced this true religion. Sometimes I was puzzled to observe how much of our time was spent in fighting among ourselves over proper interpretations. I knew that we had “the truth” and that any deviation from that was heresy, but occasionally I was not sure when we had a violent internal quarrel just which of the two parties was the “right” one.

It now seems terrible to me that I have no distinct memory of having been impressed, ever, with the extraordinary transformation which the Spirit of Christ may work in a person. I was impressed by fluency, by authoritativeness, by strength of conviction about interpretations, by party solidarity-by many such things-but I had to be grown before I found the full, glorious flowering in the human spirit of the Spirit of Christ. The result was that my religion was a head religion. It performed precise exercises, added and subtracted with marvelous skill, and knew how to dissect and analyze. But its only rapture was the joy of conquest and of correctness. It knew no other warmth.

Little was said about love in the sermons of my boyhood, except that the vital thing was that if one loved God he would keep His commandments. I can hear that now, ringing down through the years of my growing up. The first and greatest commandment was inevitably reduced to this, and only to this, and I knew scarcely any other possibilities for it. Those ministers who occasionally tried to explore the limitless suggestiveness of the word “love” were called “soft” and said to be in danger of losing their doctrinal purity if they were not careful. Little was said of the Spirit and its indwelling power, except that we were warned that it operated only through the written word and must never be considered as mysterious in the least.

We split terribly once, when I was a lad, over whether it was right to have a kitchen in the church building, or whether it was right to use literature in our classes—I have forgotten which. But half of us went one way, and half the other, and the town hid its face behind its hand and smiled at our quarreling. It took fifteen years before the bitterness of that tragedy wore off, and by then hardly anyone knew anymore what had started it all.

Yet I repeat that my tragic loss was not in learning this, that devout men may divide sharply over interpretations. My loss was that I met no singularly gracious human being whose whole life literally sang of Christ. I knew firm men, fighting men—but no man whose spirit had been so changed by Christ that he could, under almost any circumstance, display serenity of spirit and true greatness of character. And because of this I was into my twenties before I knew that the essential thing in religion is the difference it makes in the character of a man. When I began to meet such beautifully humble persons, to my great shock they often came from groups I had been taught to view as heretics because their interpretations of the Bible were unlike mine.

This little history is not unique. Thousands have shared it. It is, in fact, of importance only because it is common. It suggests that many of us have an initiation moment when we see all our training in a new light and for the first time evaluate it by a different set of standards. My new standard became this question: Is the winsome personality of Christ visible in this man? If it were not, despite lifelong church attendance and constant talk of dogma, I concluded that something basic was wrong with his kind of religion. He was part of a body from which the spirit had departed. He had a form of godliness and talked persuasively of what was scriptural and what was not, but he had no power within him to change his personality. Truly believing His word that by men’s fruits they are to be known, I found my closed system of religious values radically altered.

My church’s approach to religious unity failed me. I once saw a newspaper cartoon which summed it up classically. A parson is shown sitting on a stump in the moonlight, looking out across a meadow. Beneath the picture is his reflection: “Christian unity seems simple enough—all it would take is for everybody to agree with us.” Most of us are not quite so honest as this parson is made to be. Instead of saying “agree with us,” we prefer to say, “All it would take is for everybody to agree with the Bible.” That is, we equate our views with the Bible itself, and thus we become unassailable. No professing Christian wants to argue against the teachings of the Bible, and if a sect is convinced that its views, and the Bible, are identical, its position becomes invulnerable.

When my people talk of unity, most of them really mean conformity. Conformity decrees that everyone shall be exactly alike, thinking and talking alike about all the party interpretations. The total experience of humanity proves that this is not possible, but we go on talking as if it were. Only conformity can be enforced. An environment can be created in which it is easier to keep quiet than to express a dissenting view. Once it is clear that men who think for themselves will be persecuted as violaters of tradition, all the more cautious men in the group will be careful to keep their true views hidden. This is the unity of conformity. It is the only unity some religious groups know. But it is sterile, and ultimately self-defeating.

The other kind of unity, unity in diversity, unity of spirit and purpose, is the only sort that works. Everywhere in the world are Christian people who see the true image of Christ in other believers. Spirit is linked with spirit in a holy bond of fellowship. When such Christians find that they differ about interpretations, they are not so much dismayed as intrigued. They seek to learn from one another, respecting convictions on both sides. They talk with one another, rather than to one another. I know well what the difference is, for I was trained to use my opponent’s comments as welcome interludes in which I might be fashioning my next attack upon his position.

It is ground for hope that so many of us manage to unlearn this approach to religious differences. Exposure to Christian neighbors from other church groups often upsets the applecart. We find it hard to believe that such persons are wilfully stubborn, as our ministers tell us, and we are uneasy about what attitudes to hold toward them. It puzzles us that God should have granted to a few of us the proper interpretations, while denying them to millions of other intelligent and honest men. It is this deep-rooted honesty and the uncertainty that arises from it that cause many thousands of my people to stand ready to be more charitable when they find ministers who will permit them to be.

I have been appalled by the degree of party spirit within my church. Like John in Mark 9, we seek too often to build a fence around a clique and leave on the outside all the people who do not possess our special knowledge. Like John, we have yet to learn that the Kingdom of God has God’s dimensions, and that those who truly do the works of Christ, and bear the fruit of the Spirit, belong to Him.

John was looking for labels. He wanted to be sure that the man doing good belonged to the right party and wore the right name. Jesus said, in effect, “Look, instead, for actions, attitudes, and dispositions. When you find the things which delight me—mercy, justice, faith—welcome them. Do not meet them sourly.” How desperately my people need to learn this lesson. We often find it hard to be glad about work done by those who do not share our interpretations. We talk of missionary enterprises without happily acknowledging the ground-breaking done earlier by Adventists, or Friends, or Methodists. After other religious groups had gone in and gentled the local population, civilized them, and introduced them to Christ, then we went in with what we were pleased to call the “real truth” and sought to convert them to our own particular set of dogmas. This is painful to confess, but it is the best way to purge ourselves of the shame.

Christ once met a Roman, a pagan according to Jewish standards. He said of the man, “I have not found so great faith, no, not in Israel.” I have sometimes tried to imagine the reception this remark would get among some of my people today. If Christ were to make this statement about some religious group, it is quite likely that one of us would reply, “If the man has so much faith, why is he not a member of the right church?” Some of us have come that far in bigotry.

One of our greatest needs is to realize to what degree most of us are prisoners of our heredity and environment. We like to think that we make our own choices, but the truth is that only a small part of our commitment in any area is the result of deliberate choice. I know Southern gentlemen of strong religious drives who simply cannot throw off all the racial prejudice bred into them. Other men find it impossible to be completely unbiased about politics. Try as they will, they over-value evidence on the one side and undervalue it on the other. Religion is not different. People as wise as ourselves, and quite as sincere, are honestly unable to accept all of our views. If we are to rule all such people out of the Kingdom because they cannot share our interpretations, we elevate ourselves into judges and announce ourselves as keepers of the gates of Christianity.

We have failed through being inconsistent in our’ assessments of others and of ourselves. We emphasize the weakest positions of those who differ with us, minimizing their strengths until it is clear that no sensible person could possibly believe that way. At the same time, we overlook our own deficiencies and exaggerate our strengths until we appear far more superior than we are. Our refusal to measure our best against the best of others, and to confess our weaknesses as no less obvious than theirs, puts the lie to any claim of objectivity which we make.

A year or so ago I read in the pages of one of our widely circulated church newspapers a story about some nuns at a Roman convent who disgraced themselves by getting in a fight. They pulled at each other’s garments and had to be subdued. The implication of the report in our paper was that here was proof of the perfidy of the Roman Catholic Church.

What else could one expect to come from a group in such hopeless error? Yet a more sympathetic view might explain such conduct quite differently. I recalled the sudden, unreasonable fights that broke out among my soldier colleagues in war time when they had been cooped up together too long. I pitied the nuns, who undoubtedly were shamed and embarrassed because of their lapse.

And then I remembered the Church of Christ minister in Texas who floored one of his elders with one looping punch, but whose lapse was never reported in the editorial page of this newspaper. And the Church of Christ minister whose three-time robbery of a supermarket and subsequent prison term was never once thought of as proof that Church of Christism is a perfidious religion which could only be expected to turn out robbers.

It is not wrong to throw the mantle of charitable silence over the failings of our own. But to say nothing of their defections while we trumpet loudly the defections of those who differ with us, this is abominable. To print gleefully the tales of a Baptist minister who runs off with a choir girl, but to keep conspiratorially mum about that minister of ours whose cottage meeting activities resulted finally in life imprisonment for double rapes—this is to cheat against all rules of gentlemanly or Christian conduct. We must not use human failures among our religious neighbors as proof of their doctrinal errors, when human failures among our own people are hushed up and forgotten.

But all these things will pass. A great change is in the air. Those who have vested interests, who would have to reverse a lifetime of word and action if they moved across to another world, are fighting desperately to isolate my people from these ideas. They must preserve the system, because it is under the system that they have grown powerful and prominent, and it is under the system that they can enjoy the heady excitement of guarding orthodoxy and punishing those who offend. But “our little systems have their day” as Tennyson affirmed, and God is greater than they. Our system has had its day and we are, even now poised between two worlds.

Our system is our apprehension of God’s eternal truth; it is forever partial and incomplete. We are fragments; only our Lord is whole. But once we have humbly confessed this, we may do much good. With a membership of more than two millions, the Churches of Christ can exert influence for good in a world which urgently needs all the moral leadership it can get. But no large group will ever listen seriously to an organization which refuses to credit others with Christlike graces. It will be only when we acknowledge readily the sincerity and wisdom of those who differ with us that we shall fulfill whatever destiny God has for our particular group to work out.

It must be apparent that I am hopeful. The Church of Christ is historically a very young group, still in the adolescent stage of growth. I say this despite the sweeping assertion that this particular group dates itself from Pentecost. The truth is that our traditions have evolved from the Campbell-Stone movement on the western frontier in the early nineteenth century, and this makes us young. I realize that nothing quite so angers an adolescent as being reminded that he is one, but sober analysis supports my analogy.

Like the adolescent, we have been quite unaware of our past and of our debt to those who went before us. Like the adolescent, we have been unaware of those around us. An adolescent tends to be all wrapped up in himself, knowing little of what others do or think. The church I grew up in was like this. My friends and I cared nothing of what other religious groups did, because we were self-sufficient and self-contained in our own little world of religious exclusivism. Once or twice we ventured out, but so thoroughly trained had we been that we merely ridiculed what we saw.

But there is no cause for dismay about adolescence. It passes at length into maturity. Many of the religious groups in America today which pride themselves on their maturity were once just like this. Religious groups are really much like humans in their growth. They begin by being born into a big world which cares little for them, and takes scant notice of them. Consequently, they huddle closely together and formulate their “group language” and get acquainted with a set of group beliefs. This gives them a sense of security, and is pleasant.

By and by, as adolescents, they pass through the feelings and attitudes I have just described. But eventually, such groups mature. This is happening now to my own people. It is painful. We have “growing pains.” But the general rise in levels of formal education, and a wider knowledge of different religious parties, is slowly but surely changing us. We are growing up. Nothing can stop it. And adolescents may think that nothing is better than childhood, but no really mature person would trade what he has for the tyranny of adolescence again.

Thousands in the Churches of Christ are profoundly disturbed already by the aridity which authoritarianism produces. They are apathetic when their preachers speak to them only the time-honored platitudes and party cliches. The time is ripe for the beginning of a slow, massive turnover. I have no doubt that it is underway. I am glad to see it begin because I so deeply value my heritage in the Church of Christ. Friendships beyond assessing have come to me through my association with these people. I have no intention of leaving them so long as one of their churches is free enough to hear such compassionate strictures as fill the pages of this book. I join my voice to that of every writer here in pleading for that better spirit which is not only possible, but which is already in existence in many places among our people. I echo their plea that we shall learn how to differ from others in mutual love and respect and that God will lead us, together with all Christians, into fields of greater Christian service than we have yet known.